The staff are always great and helpful. Picked up my old lady's birthday bag of goodies from them today!
Thanks for the 5-star feedback. We'll share this with the team. We hope the birthday gift made your old lady feel young!

Google reviewers rate All The Best Pet Care in Columbia City 4.8 out of 5 stars based on 368 reviews, with the owner responding to 96 percent of feedback. Customers frequently praise the knowledgeable staff, helpful product recommendations, and convenient services like free delivery and online ordering. While many note fair pricing comparable to online retailers, recurring criticisms in lower-rated reviews describe inconsistent customer service, perceived rudeness, and limited inventory for cats compared to dogs.
Data from Google, last updated November 13, 2026.
Score per factor (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: momentum and replies to reviews; weakest: satisfaction.
Bar = this company · dark tick = category median.
368 Google reviews we collected
Phrases our text analysis found in 191 written reviews
How often each topic comes up in the written reviews
We read 191 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“…advanced (I often only order online now) and all of the staff is so helpful and sweet when I am in store.…”
“…helpful or friendly (I was buying the merchandise) 🙄 It was pretty rude of her, subtlety is not her strength…”
“They are so helpful, always available to give advice, and the prices are fair.”
“what I ended up purchasing was overpriced and under-quality”
“five stars their dog treats tasted amazing”
“Unfortunately I will not return to this location and will spread the word to avoid this location due to the customer service.”
“Recently, i had the pleasure of meeting Casper, it was a great experience dealing with him!”
“He answered all of my questions, & helped me pick out the right food for my pup.”
“The staff was so friendly and immediately put out our lost cat sign”
“He's been a huge reason we keep coming back as he is someone we trust to give good, sound, advice, and thoughts.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
The staff are always great and helpful. Picked up my old lady's birthday bag of goodies from them today!
We (and our dog) love All The Best - Columbia City. It’s such a great local, neighborhood store that is also digitally advanced (I often only order online now) and all of the staff is so helpful and sweet when I am in store. The fact that they do free delivery is just the BEST for our busy lives. Thank you!!!
We came in after a senior vet visit which can always be tough. Casper was a massive help. They treated my little old man like a prince. Casper was very knowledgeable about the store, it's programs, and it's products. Conky even got little treats while he was there and was glued to Casper the whole time. I hope…
~ Everyone I’ve dealt with here has been so nice, & knowledgeable. Recently, i had the pleasure of meeting Casper, it was a great experience dealing with him! He answered all of my questions, & helped me pick out the right food for my pup. Now I need to adopt another, so i can go back soon! Casper will be ready to help me again, I’m sure. 🐾😇🪬 ~
We love visiting All The best! Despite my giant gsd being very anxious. Abby is his favorite person there! She took the time to make him comfortable with different treats and he loves her! We love the variety of limited ingredient quality products and the yearly birthday treat is so sweet and thoughtful! Highly recommend!
My chihuahua Baja’s favorite place for treats, toys, clothes and food. Staff here are very helpful, friendly and knowledgeable about their products.
4.8 ★★★★★ 368 reviews on Google · rating breakdown
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
The staff are always great and helpful. Picked up my old lady's birthday bag of goodies from them today!
Thanks for the 5-star feedback. We'll share this with the team. We hope the birthday gift made your old lady feel young!
All the Best is Always the Best! :)
Thank you for the 5-star rating, Zain! We are happy to hear we're living up to our name. :-)
We (and our dog) love All The Best - Columbia City. It’s such a great local, neighborhood store that is also digitally advanced (I often only order online now) and all of the staff is so helpful and sweet when I am in store. The fact that they do free delivery is just the BEST for our busy lives. Thank you!!!
Wow, it's wonderful to hear that you have a positive shopping experience both in our stores and online. Thanks so much for the feedback and 5-star rating, Mariam!
five stars their dog treats tasted amazing
We’re so glad the treats were a pup-pleaser. Thank you for your 5-star rating, Liesl!
Lovely people who love animals
Hi Nicholas, Thanks for the great feedback. Hope to see you in the store again soon!
We came in after a senior vet visit which can always be tough. Casper was a massive help. They treated my little old man like a prince. Casper was very knowledgeable about the store, it's programs, and it's products. Conky even got little treats while he was there and was glued to Casper the whole time. I hope Casper is there to help me and my dogs each visit. This was my first time in and based on my experience, this will be official after vet visit stop to calm my boys down in a friendly environment. Thanks again, Casper!
Prince Conky deserves the royal treatment. We've shared your kind feedback with Casper and the team. We look forward to the next visit from the boys. Thank you for the review, David!
~ Everyone I’ve dealt with here has been so nice, & knowledgeable. Recently, i had the pleasure of meeting Casper, it was a great experience dealing with him! He answered all of my questions, & helped me pick out the right food for my pup. Now I need to adopt another, so i can go back soon! Casper will be ready to help me again, I’m sure. 🐾😇🪬 ~
Thank you for your review, Richard! We’re glad Casper made your experience with us a great one, and we're ready to help you spoil your next pup, too. :-).
We love visiting All The best! Despite my giant gsd being very anxious. Abby is his favorite person there! She took the time to make him comfortable with different treats and he loves her! We love the variety of limited ingredient quality products and the yearly birthday treat is so sweet and thoughtful! Highly recommend!
Thank you for the adorable photo of your birthday pup and the 5-star feedback, Cardina! We will share it with Abby and the team, and it will be a day brightener.
The staff was so friendly and immediately put out our lost cat sign
Thank you for the 5-star rating, Carmen. We hope you have a speedy reunion with your kitty.
My chihuahua Baja’s favorite place for treats, toys, clothes and food. Staff here are very helpful, friendly and knowledgeable about their products.
We're honored to be the favorite place of a pup of distinction like Baja! Thank you so much for the 5-star rating and for sharing the adorable photos of your super shopper.