Google reviewers rate the agency 4.8 out of 5 based on 45 reviews, noting that the owner has not responded to any feedback. Clients frequently praise the team for clear communication, responsiveness, and thorough guidance during home purchases and sales, often highlighting efficient transaction processes and helpful staging advice. However, one low-star review criticizes the property management division, alleging a lack of care regarding tenant lease issues and a focus on financial gain over customer well-being.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We worked to sell/buy with Casie Blattner. This is our second time working with Casie. We highly recommend her as a relator. She is highly communicative and helped us navigate the selling of our home and buying of a new one. A wonderful overall experience! We will continue to refer others to Casie.
Cara Gill and Caroline Ritter with Area Properties Real Estate are PHENOMENAL! Cara helped us when we purchased our home six years ago and when we sold it a couple of months ago. She answered every question we had and stayed on top of the many tasks that go into selling a home! She was such a great resource, and we will always use her when it comes to real estate needs!
Sarah DeLuca was top-notch! She took all of the strain and burden out of selling a house. She did all of the ground work, significantly reducing any strain on us. She provided clear and concise advice; at just the right times when we needed to hear it. Prior to any decisions, she had all of the information at hand ready for quick decisions. She provided a service that is exemplary and goes above and beyond in the highest professional manner!
Sarah DeLuca did such an outstanding job helping me with the purchase of my home. She is very thorough, thoughtful, full of energy and detailed in the process and guiding me through this purchase. Thanks Sarah, you did a super job and I so very much appreciate it.
Working with Richard Crowley was super easy. He went above and beyond to sell our home, guiding us through every step with expertise and genuine care. From the initial staging advice to navigating negotiations, he was always available to answer questions and put our minds at ease. We couldn't have asked for a better experience!
We had an excellent experience, attention to detail was stellar and Sharon our realtor often went above and beyond her role to ensure we were happy and well taken care of. It was a smooth and pleasant experience for us. Do not hesitate to give them your business.
Chelsea was awesome. She and area properties were very professional. Sale was quick, all documents were very clearly explained.
Huge shout out to our realtor Casie Blattner! Getting us in this house was a journey we started together in late December. Through staging our house, communicating with any update, always trying to make it work, ups and downs of contract offers, and managing my anxiety through it all. Truly could not love and recommend her more!
Becky Harding and Lori Fowler were awesome! Fun while still professional! They have great instincts and connections! I was at peace the whole process, and that is because I felt like my family and I were in good hands! I would recommend Becky and Lori to anyone looking for it to be done well! They have blessed our family!
Our experience with Area Properties Real Estate and our agent Erin Windbigler was outstanding. Erin helped us navigate through the local real estate market and showed us several properties until we found the one perfect for us. Once we chose the house, she made sure we were on track with everything needed to get us to the closing date. Erin and Area Properties Real Estate are highly recommended!