Google reviewers rate Baked Paradise five out of five stars based on 376 reviews, with the owner responding to 47% of feedback. Customers frequently praise the bakery for its punctuality, clear communication, and ability to create custom cakes that match specific designs or themes. The cakes are often described as moist, flavorful, and not overly sweet, with many noting that the pricing reflects the quality of the service and product. However, a small number of lower-rated reviews criticize the flavor profile, describing the cakes as bitter, tasteless, or lacking the expected sweetness compared to standard American styles.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
I ordered a custom cake for my wife's birthday. It was such a beautiful cake and tasted amazing. She loved it so much. We got a strawberry cake and strawberry filling. It was the perfect balance of sweet but not too sweet that you wouldn't go for a second slice. I will definitely be ordering from them again. Highly recommend to anyone.
Delicious and beautiful cakes!❤️❤️❤️
I had my daughter’s birthday cake made here, and I couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out! The cake was so moist, fresh, and delicious! Communication was also great throughout the process, which made everything so much easier and stress-free. They did a wonderful job helping make my daughter’s birthday special, and I truly appreciate the quality of the cake and the excellent customer service. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a beautiful, delicious cake for their special occasion. I will absolutely keep them in mind for future celebrations! 🎂💗
The cake was exactly as ordered and very moist and tasty. Would highly recommend.
I ordered cake here for both my kids birthday’s and also for friend’s gender reveal. I tried Pineapple and Butterscotch flavors. Absolutely loved the customization 🎂 The design was exactly what we wanted, and the attention to detail was amazing. It looked beautiful and tasted even better! Everyone loved it, and it was perfect for our special occasion. Thank you so much for the cake and making the celebration extra special. Highly recommend! ❤️
I ordered a custom lemon cake and it was delicious! The decoration was beautiful. Highly recommend and will order all my cakes from here in the future.
This bakery is amazing. I needed a gluten free cake for a birthday in a few days and she was very accommodating. I ordered a red velvet with buttercream frosting and it was the best I’ve ever had and given I’m in my 60s I’ve had a lot over the years. It was moist and delicious and the frosting was so smooth while not being overly sweet. Her cakes are worth every penny. She does an outstanding job!
Thank you so much for the custom logo cookies for our ribbon cutting ceremony. They were great! We highly recommend for any special occasion!
This was one of the best cakes I have ever had! It was moist, flavorful and not overly sweet! Everything you would expect from the perfect dessert!
I loved the cake and everybody was asking about it thank you i did not expect to be this great because eggless but yeah thanks my husband loved it