Google reviewers for Baker's Man Inc in Atlanta generally praise the bakery for its detailed custom designs, delicious flavors, and professional customer service. Clients frequently highlight the owner's responsive communication, flexible scheduling, and ability to translate specific visions into realistic cakes for weddings and birthdays. While most feedback is positive, one low-star review criticized a cake for being dry with an overpowering butter taste, though this did not appear to be a recurring pattern among the majority of satisfied customers.
Google rating: 4.8 out of 5 from 85 reviews (95% five-star).
Reviews on this page: 85 Google reviews (72 with written comments, 27 with photos).
Owner responses: the business replied to 27% of reviews.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
CJ
Caitlin JamesLocal Guide · 15 reviews
★★★★★
After trying some other bakers for my wedding cake, I was nervous I wasn't going to find a good quality cake in distant Atlanta suburbs. I took to Google and found Baker's Man. Mark welcomed my fiance and me into his business and had a very professional presentation waiting for us with a tasting menu so we can mark our favorites while he explained everything to us. The flavors were beautiful. You could tell he used high quality ingredients, and it was a passion for him - not a side hustle. The cake became one of the top things I was looking forward to on my wedding day!
WOW WOW WOW - The only words that come to mind. This is our third time using Bakers Man for special occasions and when I say 3rd time's the charm, it definitely was. Just when I thought Bakers Man couldn't possibly outdo the last cake they made for us, I definitely ate my words. The cake not only look phenomenal it captured my mom doing her favorite thing, riding her lawn mower in her back yard surrounded by her flowers and birds. When my mom came in and saw that cake, she burst into tears. Great job once again Bakers Man. You continue to impress with your creativity and capture visions and put into cake form. Not to mention the flavor of the cake was simply incredible.
Thank you so much for your dedication to this skill and talent that your team possesses.
Tracey and Kim Venable
I am so glad we purchased a birthday cake from Bakers Man for our children and our guests for a party. Mark was a pleasure to work with and he provided a beautiful AND delicious cake just like we envisioned. We hardly had cake left and it was a large 10" doubly layer cake. Pleased with the service, the presentation, the boxing for travel, the taste, and the price. If there was a 6th star option Bakers Man would have earned it.
Mark was so professional and easy to work with! Not only that, but we got TONS of compliments on our cake at our wedding. The flavor combination he put together was unique and SO delicious, and both we and our guests absolutely loved it. We couldn’t recommend the Bakers Man more!!
We had Bakers Man create our wedding cake and a personal cake for our little boy and wow! Absolutely beautiful, such a hit with the guests over the realism of the sugar flowers and leaves. And of course the cakes were delicious ( I walked in on my inlaws scraping the cake tray for a few last bites.) I had been in an email chain with Mark for months and he was always very polite and communicative. I asked for quite a few flavors in the cake, and I changed my mind a few times on the colors of the florals/ greenery on the cake, but Mark was always understanding and accommodating! We live out of state and had a destination wedding at Lake Lanier, and all of our guests were amazed at how I was able to find such a good baker while being a few states away, but of course the answer is google. I saw so many of Marks cakes on Facebook and was immediately excited. Thank you, Mark and team! You guys rock!
Chef Mark did our gender reveal cake and it was exactly what we were looking for! He made communication and pickup very easy and the cake was delicious! I will be using Baker’s Man for any future cake & dessert needs.
We ordered a cake for our baby’s first birthday from Chef Mark and his team at Baker’s Man Inc, and I truly cannot recommend them highly enough.
From the very beginning, Chef Mark was an absolute joy to work with - responsive, kind, professional, and so easy to communicate with. I had reached out to several other bakers before finding him, and no one else even replied. I’m so glad he did, because the entire experience was seamless, from our first exchange to the smooth courier delivery.
And the cake? Wow. It was a total showstopper - both beautiful and delicious. The level of detail was incredible. The handcrafted sea animals matched our party decor perfectly, and the smash cake was beyond adorable. Our baby loved it, and so did everyone else! Guests were raving and asking for the website.
I’m so grateful for the creativity, care, and talent that went into these cakes. They helped make my son's first birthday celebration so special and memorable.
The artistry was amazing! I could never have imagined what you came up with. My guests were very impressed. While I thought that the cakes at the tasting were good, what you brought to the event was even better. The cakes were great!! You have caused me to make a change in my diet. The cakes were so good that I had cake for breakfast several days after the event. I woke up thinking about them and I just could not wait.
Mark, thank you for giving us the wedding cake of our dreams! Mark went above and beyond to ensure that we got the best service and product possible. He even gifted the bridesmaids an extra treat as we were getting ready for the wedding! When Mark was trying to deliver the cake, my coordinator was not working with him, and Mark pivoted to figure it out. He went beyond his job description and took on more work to ensure that the cake was presented beautifully and in the right place. Thank you for everything, Mark!
