Google reviewers rate Baking Me Crazies five stars based on twenty-six reviews. Customers describe the bakery as professional and accommodating, noting that cakes, cupcakes, and cookies meet specific design requests while remaining affordable. Recurring themes include seamless communication, on-time delivery, and consistent flavor quality for events such as birthdays and quinceañeras. No common criticisms appear in the provided excerpts, as all reviews are positive.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
The cake,cookies and cake pops were fantastic. Everyone couldn't stop talking about how delicious they were. It was a pleasure doing business with you. Thank you for being so accommodating to my needs .
Very professional and accommodating. We got the party package and the guests loved it. Would highly recommend.
Cake was so delicious moist and the frosting was a perfect compliment. I would not have found another substitute for my daughter's quinceañera. Definitely 100% satisfied, it was exactly what we ordered. The process from placing the order to the cake being delivered was seamless. Will definitely recommend to others. Thank you for the wonderful experience.
I cannot say enough good things about my experience with Baking Me Crazies. I had an event in El Paso and provided an inspiration picture. The cake that was delivered far exceeded all expectations! The experience start to finish was hassle free and executed flawlessly. I was nervous because this cake was a tribute to my Husband graduating a prestigious military school and the one request he had for his celebration dinner. Everyone in attendance and patrons at the restaurant made so many wonderful comments about how gorgeous the cake was. Thank You for enhancing our celebration with a cake that was as delicious as it was beautiful!!!
I ordered a cake for a military promotion ceremony and it was delicious! It looked so good and tasted even better! Everyone was so impressed with it! Will definitely order again!
I just want to say thank you for bringing my vision to life for my son’s 1st birthday. The cake was beautiful & delicious! The vanilla bean cupcakes with lemon frosting & marshmallow fluff were an absolute hit! Thank you, thank you, thank you so, so much! Would definitely recommend to anyone who’s looking for beautiful, tasteful & awesome desserts! 😋
We had the most pleasant experience working with Baking Me Crazies. The cake turned out beautiful and also tasted just as good! Will be using her again for all our future parties!
She did absolutely amazing! I couldn’t stop staring at the beautiful cake! I got so sad to cut it but I had my guest come up to me and saying how delicious the cake was! It is all around the best cake I’ve ordered and worth every penny! I highly recommend it. Amazing work! Thank you!
Absolutely AMAZING!!!!! I ordered cookies from a town 4 hours from El Paso. Scheduled Delivery for the day of our shower and everything worked out perfectly. The delivery was on time to the second, and the cookies were impossibly PERFECT!!! I couldn’t be happier and if you’re in El Paso and need something special, THIS IS THE PLACE! If I could recommend this company to everyone in the world, I would do that over and over again! Thank you for adding to our special day!
I asked Brenna to recreate a specific cake from a music video and she definitely delivered. She kept consistent communication and was willing to work with me on any adjustments. The birthday girl was very happy!