Experts Reviews
Cindyrella Cakes & Cake Supply Shop logo

Cindyrella Cakes & Cake Supply Shop

4.9 ★★★★★ · 99 Google reviews · 24 photos
Bakery · Atlanta, GA

Cindyrella Cakes & Cake Supply Shop at a glance

Google reviewers rate Cindyrella Cakes & Cake Supply Shop 4.9 out of 5 based on 99 reviews, highlighting accurate custom designs, moist flavors, and punctual delivery. Customers frequently mention the availability of bakery supplies and responsive communication during the ordering process. A recurring criticism involves the sweetness of the icing, while one reviewer noted difficulty accessing the shop due to disconnected phone lines and closed doors despite posted hours.

  • Google rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 99 reviews (96% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 99 Google reviews (94 with written comments, 29 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 36% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: October 15, 2026.
  • Service: Wedding Cake Baker serving Atlanta, Georgia.

Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.

Photos

Customer reviews

4.9
★★★★★
99 reviews on Google
5★95
4★2
3★1
2★0
1★1

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Angel Jones10 reviews
★★★★★

Above and beyond my expectations!! What you want and ask for is exactly what you get! That cake was absolutely beautiful an delicious

Review from Google · view on Google
DeeLocal Guide · 13 reviews
★★★★★

Feel like I fell in love with this place at first sight! They have bakery supplies options, you can get custom edible sheets, custom cakes, and they had some goodies ready in bakery to purchase. I’m sitting here eating my strawberry cupcake now! Omg! Soooo delicious. I also tried the brownie and key lime pie. Even the icing is good lol. So happy to have found this place, as a girl with a sweet tooth, you’ll be seeing me often! lol 10/10 Also the owner is sooo sweet and awesome!

Response from the owner · 3 weeks ago

Aww thank you so much for your kind words. Glad you love my cute little shop as much as I do. Can't wait to see you again.

Review from Google · view on Google
Robert McLarinLocal Guide · 64 reviews
★★★★★

Love the cakes, very nice staff

  • Order type: Take out
  • Meal type: Other
  • Price per person: $90–100
  • Noise level: Very quiet
Review from Google · view on Google
Ashley WalkerLocal Guide · 11 reviews
★★★★★

I ordered an edible image for my sons cake and it came out great!

Review from Google · view on Google
Karen StickneyLocal Guide · 46 reviews
★★★★★

I was gifted a Pink Champagne Cake decorated with a tiara, gold leaf, macarons, chocolate candies. Wonderful taste and presentation. The most beautiful cake I’ve EVER received

Review from Google · view on Google
Keachana DuPont8 reviews
★★★★★

Mrs. Cindy did an amazing job with my cupcakes, cookies, and cake! Everything turned out beautifully, and her customer service was excellent. My order was ready on time with no delays, which made the entire experience even better. I was extremely pleased with her work and will definitely be using her again for future events!

Review from Google · view on Google
Wanada Mcmath8 reviews
★★★★★

I shop there for all my needs for baking and decorating my cakes everything is top tier I ONLY SHOP WITH HER

  • Order type: Take out
  • Meal type: Other
  • Noise level: Quiet, easy to talk
Review from Google · view on Google
Yvonne Amihere1 review
★★★★★

Thank you so much for the beautiful graduation and birthday cakes. I am honestly so happy to be a first time customer 😊 Everything was absolutely amazing, from the look to the taste. I truly appreciate your talent, care, and attention to detail. I am so grateful, and I will definitely be ordering again!

Review from Google · view on Google
Diandra Pile11 reviews
★★★★★

I've ordered my 3rd cake from her and I will certainly be ordering again. They are always so beautiful and taste great. Pick up is always quick and easy

Review from Google · view on Google
Kel's Cakes & Cupcakes1 review
★★★★★

My fave shop to get my cake decorating supplies. 🙌🏾💕

  • Price per person: $20–30
Response from the owner · 9 months ago

Thank you very much for your support. Truly appreciate it.

Review from Google · view on Google

Cindyrella Cakes & Cake Supply Shop on Google Maps →

Business details