Google reviewers rate College City Realty 4.9 out of 5 based on 180 reviews, with the owner responding to 99% of feedback. Tenants and property owners frequently cite prompt communication, quick maintenance resolution, and friendly staff as key benefits of the management services. However, a minority of low-star reviews describe difficulties with billing disputes, security deposit deductions, and perceived unresponsiveness regarding vacant properties or lease-end renovations.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
The guys at College City are the most helpful and friendly people, and everyone I've ever spoken with has been super responsive. It is definitely a change from other companies my son has rented through. I highly recommend this rental management group!
We try Michele. Thank you
THE BEST people to lease from! I always feel safe, anytime I have an issue it’s fixed within the same day, and the space and location doesn’t get any better! Wish I could stay forever!!
Thanks Noor
Very helpful office staff!
we try! thanks Linda
College City Realty has been amazing so far. David and Justin are prompt with responding to any issues and are very reliable. Move in was quick and easy, and they have great maintenance people. I would definitely recommend this company to anyone looking to rent!
Thank you Riley
Just moved in a couple weeks ago, Justin is the best always responds so quickly!
Thank you Lilly. Please let us know if you need anything. College City Realty
As a parent, I can’t express enough how grateful we are for the excellent service and support provided by David and Justin College City Realty while our son has been living in their property during his time at Alabama.
Thanks Hasan
College City Realty has managed our Condo for annual rentals since 2023. I have been very pleased with the response to communication, property management and payment system. David has made the process very smooth and easy. I would highly recommend this company especially if you do not live in the Tuscaloosa area.
Thank you, Carla. We appreciate working with you as well.
Justin Brady is the best realtor made the whole process feel like a breeze never had any issues with this company.
Thanks Gabriel. We will make sure Justin sees your appreciation.
Super friendly and easy to work with. Been renting with College City for 2 years and have had zero problems!
Thanks John
Been living in a house with College City Realty this past year, and they always respond so quick to requests! Never had any issues and Justin has been great!
We will pass this message along to Justin. Thanks Gretchen