Google reviewers rate Colony Pizza 4.6 out of 5 based on 241 reviews, frequently praising the thin crust pizza, friendly staff, and clean facility. Recurring themes include positive dining experiences and flavorful toppings, though some customers find the pricing high relative to portion sizes. Common criticisms in lower-rated reviews involve poor phone responsiveness, order accuracy issues, and inconsistent food preparation quality.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
My wife and I are camping in Erie from the Ford City area. We just stopped for lunch and had a great salad, a slice of pizza and a peperoni ball. The watress was great, very polite and helpful. The owner was a great guy to talk with and get to know. Id recommend Colony Pizza to anyone. God bless their business.
Ordered a grilled chicken caesar salad and a 12" pizza and 2 fountain drinks, 1 of the 2 dressings given were off color and off tasting and the chicken was dry. The pizza was pretty good. Not worth $38 dollars though for everything.
Delicious thin crust pizza in a clean, no-frills location. Very friendly staff, too.
Best Pizza in Erie! Eric and his crew are top notch every time!
Best pizza in Erie by far. I’ve tried many pizza places in Erie and wasn’t impressed with any until a friend recommended Colony. I’ve ordered about 8 times in past two months and always fantastic.
Love this place. Food is great worth a try.
Their Roast Beef cheddar melt on a pretzel roll was thee best roast beef sandwich, the meat was so tender!!
Great spot for a pizza or slice! Broccota and Eric B special were really good Very nice employees too
Thank you!!!!
First time calling asked for cheese and pepperoni Got just cheese. When i called back to let them know i order pepperoni on my pizza the kid on phone wanted to argue. This is the first and last time i order anything from there. Customer service was poor and quality of food just ok.
I’m very sorry for your wrong order and the poor customer service you experienced. We will take care of this on our end. If you decide to retry our place just ask for Halle- I will make sure that we make it right by you. Again, sorry for your experience
Best thin crust ever !
Thank you!