Analyzing 10,634,67110.6M ReviewsFor 30,17630.2K Experts
Google reviewers rate the bakery 4.8 out of 5 from 301 reviews, with the owner replying to 86 percent of comments. Customers frequently praise the friendly staff, whimsical atmosphere, and high tea service, noting that custom cakes and pastries are often delicious and reasonably priced. However, several low-star reviews criticize the quality of custom cakes, describing the sponge as dry and the frosting as excessive or lacking flavor.
Data from Google, last updated November 13, 2026.
301 Google reviews we collected
Phrases our text analysis found in 263 written reviews
How often each topic comes up in the written reviews
We read 263 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“Great bakery, super friendly staff definitely recommend.”
“I highly recommend this wonderful family-run bakery.”
“I hate leaving negative reviews for anything but will never go to or recommend this place because of how horribly she treats employees.”
“Fun was had by all…thank you to the Elysian Fields family for the memorable afternoon and great service!”
“The cake was very sloppy and looked like it had just been thrown together.”
“The price was also incredibly reasonable for the size and level of decoration.”
“The cake was very much over priced for the way that it turned out.”
“Delicious treats, warm and friendly service, and a genuine sense of joy left me grinning like a child on his birthday.”
“When you walk in, it immediately has this "Bridgerton" vibe to it (if you're a Bridgerton fan, you'll understand).”
“They listened to every word my wife said and even took photos she found for inspiration, and they created the most beautiful and perfect cake.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
4.8 ★★★★★ 301 reviews on Google · rating breakdown
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Great bakery, super friendly staff definitely recommend.
Was at an event and they were amazing. The employees were personable, felt welcomed and not pressured. After having some of there baked goods i can see why they dont need to push a sale. Check them out.
Absolutely delicious cookies, cupcakes, and chocolates. The decorations are really fun and whimsical, and people working there are always polite and helpful. I really enjoyed the cherry blossom cookies, and their seasonal caramel apple fudge on pumpkin bread.
Okay. I read a lot of Reddit stories about people ordering things and show what they ordered and what they got and I always get nervous when I order a cake and I tell them kinda what I want but I don’t know exactly how it’ll look. I ordered a cake from Elysian Fields Magic kind of last minute. It was Thursday evening when I ordered for Sunday afternoon. First I was impressed because we had a memorial to attend Sunday that was last minute and I called to see if we could find a way to pick up the cake around that. The woman that answered was incredible. She did EVERYTHING in her power to help us and I was already blown away by the service. Finally when I went in today about an hour ago to pick it up, I didn’t know what to expect. I’d given a very generic run down of what we were looking for. And what they presented was something I don’t think I could have detailed wanting yet it was EXACTLY what we were looking for- we just didn’t know it until we saw it. I cannot express at all how absolutely in awe we are of this place. It’s been an hour since pick up and my boyfriend and I have talked non stop about this place. Between the service and the service product, and the fact it’s clear we’re at an age now where the presentation of a cake is so incredibly done we don’t even want to cut it to eat it - this place knocked it outta the park. We will be coming here from now on for EVERY cake we order. It’s not even a question. The magical aesthetic here is literally how we feel about the way they took care of us. The way they just knew what we wanted. Everything. EVEN THE COST WAS INSANE! We have spent more on cakes a quarter of the size and about a smidge of the detail. For real. Magic. Thank you to the workers who did our cake and helped us out. You all deserve massive bonuses! Seriously. Don’t be shocked to see this review everywhere I can post it.
My wife loves this place. We walked in and got a cinnamon roll, chocolate croissant, and a gluten free spice cupcake. Everything was amazing. My wife is a cinnamon roll connoisseur and says this is the best one she’s ever had. They just make them Saturdays and Sundays though.
Thank you! Please tell your wife that receiving the title of "Best Cinnamon Roll Ever" from a true cinnamon roll connoisseur is the sort of thing bakers brag about for years! We're delighted you enjoyed everything, and can't wait to welcome you both (and your kiddo) back for more pastries and another cinnamon roll quest :)
Was there to pickup a surprise box of treats via the app To Good to Go. $5.99 for a surprise box of yummers
Thank you! We're delighted your Too Good To Go treasure chest was filled with "yummers." A term we may need to adopt to describe our treats moving forward ;) Every rescued treat deserves a second chance at happiness, and we're so glad our little surprise box found a happy home. You are welcome back anytime!
Imagine wandering through a barren desert, desperately searching for something delightful, only to suddenly discover a cool, crystal-clear oasis. That’s exactly how it felt walking into this bakery this morning. It was like stepping into an alternate universe—or onto the set of a fantasy movie. Delicious treats, warm and friendly service, and a genuine sense of joy left me grinning like a child on his birthday. I highly recommend this wonderful family-run bakery. My only regret is that it’s so far from me! I can only imagine what an incredible place this would be if it were paired with a great coffee shop. What an oasis that would be!
Quick, smelling salts, and a fainting couch! Oh my, how we blush! That was, without doubt, one of the most lovely and generous reviews on our shop. We admit our productivity hushed for a bit as we all crowded around to read your kind words. We bow and curtsy in your general direction, Mike. Thank you for adventuring with us! You and yours are always welcome!
Great place! Would definitely recommend for any occasion. Had this made for my dad's 100th birthday. They did an amazing job! Thank you so much!
It was an honor to create a cake for your father’s 100th birthday! A truly remarkable occasion, and one we were delighted to help celebrate! Moments like these are the heart of what we do, and it means the world to us that our work played a small part in such a special day :) We look forward to welcoming you again whenever you need something sweet for life’s celebrations, great or small.
Found Elysian fields artisan bakery through the Too Good To Go app, and I’m officially addicted! Their pastries are unreal—honestly the best in town. Every time I drive by, I can't resist stopping in to grab something. Thanks to the app, I’ve discovered so many new favorites! If I have a party or just need something special, this is my #1 go-to spot. Highly recommend!
Thank you! We’re delighted that the Too Good To Go app led you to our door (serendipity at its sweetest) and that our pastries have become a favorite indulgence! Discovering new treats is one of those quiet joys in life, and we’re honored to be your chosen spot for both everyday delights and special occasions :) We look forward to welcoming you again whenever you need a sweet treat!
Very happy with the cake and service. It came out absolutely perfect, they really went the extra mile getting this together for my partners birthday. They were exceptionally kind as well, will definitely be back for a custom cake and treats.
Thank you so much for the lovely review, Michele! We always hope to offer not only beautiful (and delicious) confections, but a welcoming experience that feels, if we might borrow from the Professor, like “a place where one could have a quiet smoke and think of pleasant things.” :) We look forward to your next visit, whether for a custom cake or a simple sweet to brighten the day!
Analyzing 10,634,67110.6M ReviewsFor 30,17630.2K Experts