I cannot say enough positive things about my experience working with First Call Realty of Montgomery. Tonya Lindsay was the realtor assigned to me and from start to finish, she was incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and detail-oriented. She took the time to explain everything clearly, answered every question I had, and consistently went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled properly. What really stood out was her genuine commitment throughout the process. She was responsive, trustworthy, patient, and always had my best interests in mind. Her expertise and attention to detail made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Beyond being an exceptional real estate professional, she is simply a great person to work with. I would highly recommend First Call Realty of Montgomery to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. If you want someone who is knowledgeable, dependable, professional, and truly cares about their clients, look no further!

First Call Realty of Montgomery
First Call Realty of Montgomery at a glance
Customers frequently praise the agency for its responsive communication, detailed explanations, and professional guidance during both buying and selling processes. Reviewers highlight the team's market knowledge, ability to streamline transactions, and availability to address client needs without pressure. While the overall rating is high, a small number of negative comments criticize the website's usability and allege specific instances of unprofessional conduct or lack of loyalty toward clients.
- Google rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 67 reviews (96% five-star).
- Reviews on this page: 67 Google reviews (52 with written comments, 1 with photos).
- Owner responses: the business replied to 15% of reviews.
- Most recent review: September 11, 2026.
- Service: Real Estate Agent serving Montgomery, Alabama.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Photos
Customer reviews
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
I cannot say enough good things about my experience working with Catherine Holcomb at First Call Realty. She is the definition of a dedicated professional who genuinely cares about her clients. She went above and beyond to help me buy my home, making a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. Her real estate knowledge is top-notch, and she always took the time to find the answers to any questions I had. Over the course of this journey, she became much more than just my realtor—she became a true friend. Whether you are looking to buy or sell, you want Catherine in your corner!
Lyle was great listening and looking for homes that fit our needs. Always available to help resolve issues. We would recommend Lyle and First Call Realty of Montgomery to anyone buying or selling a home.
Working with Lyle at First Call Realty was such a great experience. From the start, he was super easy to talk to, really knowledgeable, and just genuinely helpful throughout the whole process. What I appreciated most was how responsive he was. Anytime I had a question (and I had a lot), he got back to me quickly and explained everything in a way that actually made sense. I never felt out of the loop or pressured into anything, which made a huge difference. He really stays on top of things and makes sure nothing falls through the cracks. He handled everything smoothly and made what could’ve been a stressful process feel way more manageable. If you’re looking for someone who’s reliable, easygoing, and knows what they’re doing, I’d definitely recommend Lyle. I’d happily work with him again!
I highly recommend Catherine Holcomb at First Call Realty. She is a woman of her word, trustworthy, dependable, and kind. When she told my husband and I she would sell our house we thought it would take at least a few months. We definitely weren't expecting her to have it sold within a few hours. Catherine is very good at her job and definitely knows what she is doing. I can't recommend her enough.
Lyle did a great job helping us through the entire process of selling the property.
Lyle and Kennedy did an excellent job! Highly recommend
Lyle Wilks is a great guy and agent! He's very knowledgeable on the housing markets and gives great advice. Definitely will use him again in the future!
I was planning a move, returning to Alabama after 30 years away. Montgomery has changed a lot and I was at a loss to know where to begin looking, but when I told a First Call Realty agent what I was looking for, she honed in on area, pricing, size and types of homes that suited my need. I found one within days that spoke “home” to me instantly and we were able to secure a contract and closing in a matter of weeks! It was the easiest and most comfortable real estate transaction I’ve had in 50 years and 10 real estate purchases! First Call also gave me guidance and area referrals for set up of utility services and other associated new community information to make my move easier. Great job, First Call!
Bought and sold 2 properties in Montgomery before buying a 3rd in Wetumpka. First Call was my first call every time! They really walked us through the entire process, explaining every step fully so I knew what I was getting into! Forever grateful for their expertise and the genuine care that was given to my home purchase!
Business details
- Address: 2951 Zelda Rd, Montgomery, AL 36106
- Phone: (334) 593-8414
- Website: firstcallrealtyofmontgomery.com
- Service area: Montgomery, AL