Guardian Home Improvements logo

Guardian Home Improvements

Roofing contractor · Milwaukee, WI

4.7 ★★★★★ 515 Google reviews · 24 photos
89%five-star reviews
86%reviews answered by the owner
Nov 2026latest review

Guardian Home Improvements at a glance

Customers praise the sales process for detailed explanations, fair pricing, and professional communication regarding roofing, siding, and window services. Positive reviews highlight punctual appointments and representatives who thoroughly address concerns. However, low-star feedback frequently cites poor post-installation communication, unresolved issues, and reliance on subcontractors, with some reporting damage to property or incomplete work that remained unaddressed despite repeated contact attempts.

  • Google rating: 4.7 out of 5 from 515 reviews (89% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 515 Google reviews (469 with written comments, 20 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 86% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: November 11, 2026.
  • Service: Sunroom serving Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Data from Google, last updated November 20, 2026.

Star ratings

515 Google reviews we collected

  • 5 stars45789%
  • 4 stars296%
  • 3 stars20%
  • 2 stars41%
  • 1 star234%

Praise vs complaints

Phrases our text analysis found in 469 written reviews

  • Praise91095%
  • Complaints495%

Topic share

How often each topic comes up in the written reviews

  • Staff & attitude25426%
  • Quality & results16017%
  • Communication15816%
  • Price & value10911%
  • Speed & response10611%
  • Would recommend9210%
  • Honesty & trust808%

What customers talk about

We read 469 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.

  • “Andy Wilde is a true professional and very knowledgeable.”
    “I had to lend my own cordless skilsaw because they had a hand saw-so unprofessional!”
  • “We had a great experience and we are looking for to our new roof”
    “They did a good job with the roof, however they damaged my neighbours house, and my gutters in the process.”
  • “Guardian doesn't just give quotes, they sit down with you and explain how they came up with the numbers and what they offer that others don't.”
    “I feel like I get ghosted by the project managers repeatedly, leaving calls, texts and voicemails unanswered for weeks on end until additional communi…”
  • “The sales process for a new roof was exceptional compared to the 5 other bids we got and the price was fair.”
    “They are overpriced and do a terrible job.”
  • “Worked with me to get the right fit for my house in doors and windows and Andy made sure I got my windows on time.”
    “…ou a quote (after waiting a month with 1 cancelled appointment and 1 no show), I wouldn’t trust them to complete a job in a timely manner either.…”
  • “I highly recommend them and will be calling them for all.”
    “Nick, Bobby, and Darlene would earned Guardian 5 stars.”
  • “I feel Andy is very knowledgeable, honest, and takes his job seriously, and I would be happy to work with him in the future.”
    “However, they were not honest enough to admit that.”

People customers mention

  • Josh 24 reviews
  • Jones 16 reviews
  • Patrick 16 reviews
  • Bobby 15 reviews
  • Cody 14 reviews
  • Sonny 14 reviews

praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.

Photos

Customer reviews

4.7 ★★★★★ 515 reviews on Google · rating breakdown

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Jobs customers hired them for — from Google's service tags and the review text
Team members customers mention
Filter by topic — each topic is highlighted in the reviews in the same color
JamesLocal Guide · 40 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews James has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

We hired Guardian Home Improvements in 2021 to install new siding on our entire house. What should have been a long-term investment in our home has turned into an ongoing source of frustration and disappointment. The problems started during installation. Guardian used subcontractors, and halfway through the project, the lead installer's crew quit. Despite the disruption, the installation was eventually completed, and the siding initially looked good. Unfortunately, within several months, pieces of siding began falling off the house. Guardian returned to reattach and caulk the loose pieces. In 2022, additional sections started coming loose, and rather than repeatedly dealing with Guardian, I repaired and caulked them myself. Over the following years, I continued addressing occasional loose pieces. Fast forward to 2025, just four years after installation. We noticed bulging and discoloration in the siding on the back of our house. Upon further inspection, I also discovered significant warping and melting on the side facing a neighbor's house. Guardian came out to inspect the damage, and this was when I first learned that sunlight reflecting off energy-efficient windows can generate enough concentrated heat to warp or melt vinyl siding. Our neighbor had recently installed new windows, which apparently contributed to the damage. Guardian explained that this is a known issue with vinyl siding. My question is simple: If this is a known vulnerability of vinyl siding, why was it never disclosed or discussed when Guardian recommended and installed this product? As homeowners making a significant investment, we should have been informed of potential risks and limitations before purchasing. What followed was even more disappointing. We spent approximately six months going back and forth with Guardian trying to resolve the issues and obtain warranty assistance. During that time, numerous phone calls went unreturned, communication was poor, and there was little sense of urgency or accountability. Ultimately, Guardian directed us to the siding manufacturer rather than helping us reach a satisfactory resolution. Ironically, the manufacturer has been more helpful than the company that sold and installed the siding. Although damage caused by reflected sunlight is excluded from the manufacturer's warranty, the manufacturer has graciously agreed to provide replacement siding as a goodwill gesture. Unfortunately, receiving replacement material does not change the fact that our siding has experienced multiple problems since installation, and we are now facing the prospect of replacing siding across our home just five years after what should have been a long-lasting improvement. My biggest disappointment isn't simply that the siding failed. It's how Guardian handled the problems after the sale. Between the installation issues, siding repeatedly falling off, inadequate communication, and months of frustration trying to obtain assistance, I have completely lost confidence in this company. Based on our experience, Guardian seems far more interested in completing a sale than standing behind its work and supporting customers when problems arise. I would never recommend Guardian Home Improvements. Homeowners deserve transparency about the products being installed, quality workmanship, responsive customer service, and a company willing to stand behind its work. Unfortunately, our experience with Guardian fell well short of those expectations.

  • Price assessment: Overpriced
  • Price: $40,000–45,000
  • Services: Service not listed
Victoria Akampa3 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Victoria has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

I paid for roof and gutter repairs; they cancelled the first appointment they set with me, then came out and did the work and didn’t even communicate, but didn’t do everything. They only gave me a new roof and left my gutters the same yet I was charged for those too. I have tried several times to get in touch with them and have it rectified and all times they just keep putting my call on hold claiming they are getting the general manager. It’s been over 5 months already and no amends made.

  • Price assessment: Overpriced
  • Price: $5,000–10,000
  • Services: Gutter repairs, Roof installation
Don Cort2 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Don has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

We had a great experience and we are looking for to our new roof

  • Price assessment: Reasonable price
  • Price: $20,000–25,000
  • Services: Roof inspection
Mary Krepps3 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Mary has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

Andy has been extremely informative when covering the product, the costs, the time expectations. Thank-you Andy

  • Services: Roof repair for storm & wind damage
C LakshmiLocal Guide · 66 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews C has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

They did a good job with the roof, however they damaged my neighbours house, and my gutters in the process. I've called and texted multiple times with no response from someone to come and look at the gutters and discuss repairs. It's very frustrating!! If not for this part I would have been happy with the work but this has put a very bad taste in my mouth, and I'm a pretty easygoing person about honest mistakes. The lack of follow-through after makes this feel very intentional of not taking responsibility for their mistakes and refusing to discuss fixing it. (I don't have pics of the roof, just the damaged gutter) Update: upgraded my review following contact from the company and repair of the damage. They were very apologetic for causing damage and took care of the repairs. It sounds like there was internal confusion regarding if the repairs had already been made which led to them not returning my calls, but did respond after I left this review. Updated again because I was able to get up there to check out the "repair" work... which was pretty half-assed. There's pieces of flashing just placed in there, where you can still see large gaps where the soffit should have been replaced. The end of the damaged section wasn't closed up, so it's also still wide open to the elements. They just bolted it through the roof they themselves just replaced, through their own work like that! Lastly, the gutter is pitched toward the house instead of laying flat like it's supposed to. Incredibly disappointed that this is their idea of repairing the damage caused by not properly securing the gutters after they replaced my roof. The company that installed the gutters quoted me at $2.5k to fix Guardian's mistake, on top of the money I paid to replace the roof in the first place! This has been so frustrating

  • Price assessment: Reasonable price
  • Price: $20,000–25,000
  • Services: Gutter repairs, Roof installation
Response from the owner · a month ago

C Lakshmi, could you please call our main office so that we can get this resolved. We would reach out to you directly, but unfortunately, looking through our system we cannot find any record of you. If this is in fact something we did, we absolutely want to make sure that we get this take care of, but none of our project managers recognize the house or images you have posted, and we can't find you anywhere in our system. If this is something we did, we will certainly take care of it. However, if you are possibly confusing us with another company, we want to get that straightened out. Our main office number is (414) 226-5619. We look forward to talking to you soon.

Tom Schildt5 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Tom has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

Andy Wilde is a true professional and very knowledgeable. It was a very good experience meeting with him. Tom S.

Stephanie Babe6 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Stephanie has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

10/06/26 Our project has been completed bit of an update thats important to share Communication rating: started at a 5 went to 2.5 because of the lack of follow through from Josh Overall project:5 stars We had a mixed experience with our project. In the beginning, everything went so smoothly, and Josh was fantastic at keeping us updated every step of the way. However, toward the end of the project, we hit a major communication hiccup regarding our sunburst gable accent. After multiple unanswered calls and unreturned texts—even though they were marked as read—we were essentially ghosted right before our deadline, forcing us to coordinate with other team members(John, Caroline) just to get confirmation. While we appreciated the initial great service, the lack of follow-through and communication at the finish line was very frustrating. Thanks again to Tommy and Drew for putting up the sunburst. John was very thorough when explaining our project. He worked really hard to create my Starburst to one of my peaks

Response from the owner · 6 months ago

Thank you, Stephanie! We’re so glad to hear you appreciate that John took the time to walk you through every detail of your roofing and siding project. He truly enjoys bringing unique ideas to life—your custom Starburst detail is an awesome touch! We appreciate the opportunity to work with you and are excited for you to see the finished result.

Jason HLocal Guide · 17 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Jason has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

Absolute trash. My mother hired this company to do her sun roof. After months of calls and e mails with no one responding I finally got a text from someone who was never involved to begin with saying they would not fix any of the issues. They hire 3rd party crews. No one that does the work is actually working for Guardian. Nails through the roof. Crappy patch work. Thoughtless and no regard for someone’s home. We have contacted an attorney to address this. The fact that they show no remorse or care is absolutely mind boggling. Look at the photos. They speak for themselves. Luckily we have fox 6 and channel 4 willing to meet with us. I’d think twice before hiring this company.

  • Price assessment: Reasonable price
  • Price: $5,000–10,000
  • Services: Roof repair for storm & wind damage
Response from the owner · a month ago

Jason, we appreciate you reaching out regarding this matter, and we are more than willing to take care of any actual warranty issues. However, we do need to make sure everyone is on the same page as far as what was done and what the outstanding issues are. First, there seems to be some misunderstanding in what your mom originally purchased. Your mom's contract was for a new flat roof on the 3 season room, but nothing for any interior work. While Google does not allow us to upload photos on our end, we would be happy to review that contract with you to show you that no interior work was included in the project. The interior work that our project manager completed at your mom's home was done completely for free to simply help your mom as she explained to our project manager that money was very tight and she needed help. So, we did it completely for free. The fact that this free work is now being used against us in this review as way to extort more free work is quite disturbing. While we are willing to take care of any warranty issues for the work that was paid for, or issues that are in fact our fault, we looked through our pictures and see that in the most recent pictures that the shingle portion of your mom's roof has been replaced by a different contractor after our flat roof work was completed. Since these issues, shown in the pictures you provided, were never brought up at the time of the final walk-through of the project, and that shingle roof crew would have had to have walked on the roof that we replaced, it is very possible that the panels coming loose on the interior, that we installed for free, were very well knocked loose by them walking or dropping bundles of shingles on the roof, which would be their responsibilty for the damage, not us. Again, we are more than willing to take care of issues that are the result of any of the contracted work that we did, so please call us and we can discuss.

Gabriel Conger4 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews Gabriel has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

The team at Guardian did an amazing job to meet all of our goals on both price and a very short timeline while being fantastic people to work with through the entire process. Incredible. I’d recommend them to anyone—and already have!

  • Price: $45,000–50,000
LuzCeleste Font Gretzinger4 reviewsTotal number of Google reviews LuzCeleste has written across all businesses on Google Maps, not just this one.
Review from Google · view on Google
★★★★★

We paid for an update of our roof called CERICADE. We were dissatisfied with the company from day one. Workers didn't have the right tools. I had to lend my own cordless skilsaw because they had a hand saw-so unprofessional! They changed a few shingles in front and back of the house and when sprayed the Cericade, the color over the new shingles was lighter and brighter than the rest. Also, they sprayed Cericade over debris on a valley which took them two years to show up to fix. They are terrible returning calls, promises not kept, cancellations, and one excuse after another. And their final answer after we requested a re-do of the Cericade was "sorry, you need to pay for a new roof". We now have to eat it and to live with these ugly uneven discolored areas of our roof which definitely devalue our home. Terrible company!

Response from the owner · a month ago

Thank you for sharing your concerns. We are disappointed that, despite our continued efforts, you remain dissatisfied with the appearance of your roof. We want to be transparent about our efforts so far. Our crew has returned to your home five times to address your concerns, and we regret that those visits haven't resolved things to your satisfaction. We also recognize that scheduling and communication haven't always been what they should be, and we're taking that feedback to heart. It is also important to provide some context regarding the appearance of the roof. Prior to the Cericade application, significant repairs were completed that required new shingles to be installed. When Cericade is applied over shingles of different ages and conditions, some variation in appearance can occur. Older shingles naturally experience granule loss and weathering over time, while newly installed shingles retain their original granule coverage. As a result, repaired areas can sometimes appear lighter, brighter, or otherwise different after application. We understand that this explanation does not change your concerns about the finished appearance. Although we have already made multiple return visits to the property, Guardian remains committed to customer service and is currently exploring additional options that may help address the concerns resulting from the original installation. We appreciate the opportunity to continue working toward a reasonable resolution, and will be reaching out in the coming week to discuss those options.

Guardian Home Improvements on Google Maps →

Business details