Google reviewers rate JakesCakes ATX five stars based on fifty reviews, noting that the owner responds to all feedback. Customers frequently praise the bakery for accommodating same-day and last-minute orders with efficient communication and delivery. The protein cookie cakes are highlighted for their high protein content, gluten-free options, and detailed custom designs suitable for various events. One reviewer mentioned a specific instance where an oven malfunction affected the quality of a batch, though they still gave a positive rating.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Jake was able to make me a cake in such a short notice of time and it was the most delicious cookie cake ever! The design was perfect and looked amazing! I will definitely be ordering from Jake again!
Thank you, Morgan! Glad we could help on very short notice! And happy that you and your boyfriend loved your protein cookie cake! Thank you for supporting us.
My wife really enjoyed her Reese’s cookie Birthday Cake. Thank you Jake!
Thank you, Chris! Glad your wife loved her protein birthday cake! Thank you for supporting us!
If anyone is looking for a great protein cookie, look no further than Jake's Cakes! You can tell he has passion for what he does, and it translates into his creations. A+++++++
Appreciate the kind words and support, Michael! Glad you enjoyed your Reese's protein cookies!
OMG! I tried Jake’s cakes at my favorite coworker place and fell in love with these delicious cookies. They don’t taste like your average protein bar or protein cookie instead there actually tasty and you’ll be blown away by how much protein is packed in these little treats. I wish every coworker space or company office had Jake’s cakes. I think more people would go to work if they did. Best cookie ever!
Haha thank you, Heather! We agree with you and believe more people would show up to work knowing theirs JakesCakes protein cookies awaiting them in the break room!
I was able to order with the same day even squeezed in last minute time they’re delicious pack a great amount of protein. I highly recommend going with Jake’s Cakes for your sweet endeavors.!
Thanks Christian! Glad we were able to make your order happen quickly so you could get your protein cookies in to power up your moving day💪🏼
Jakes Cakes is incredible. I'm a person who loves a tasty treat, especially in the evening, and now I can have cookies without the guilt. Jakes Cakes are packed with protein, gluten-free, and made with clean ingredients. Plus, they actually tastes good. We are setting up an office here in Austin and I will definitely be stocking up with these amazing cookies to keep the team running strong.
Thanks Kevin! We're ready to supply your office with protein, gluten free cookies through our Corporate Cookie Program! 💪🏼🍪
The fact these cakes are loaded with protein is insane, they are delicious and the decorations for everyone so excited. I highly recommend for any party you have coming!!
Thanks Andrew! We're glad you and the rest of the boat party loved our protein packed cookie cake!
Best damn cakes in Austin! Love the cookies for a great protein snack, truth the cakes are incredible - the gluten free cake totally surprised me and will likely become my default order moving forward.
Thank you so much, David! Your review truly means a lot to us. We're thrilled you and your girlfriend loved our gluten-free cake and that it's earned a spot as your new favorite! We work hard to create desserts that taste incredible without compromising on quality, whether it's our custom birthday cakes, cookie cakes, or our high-protein cookies. Thank you for supporting a local Austin bakery and for sharing your experience. We can't wait to make your next celebration even sweeter!
He did an awesome job making our cookie cake. We had a really intricate design that we wanted of a cowgirl on a horse and he nailed it. I wish we would have gotten a picture but it was perfect. It was also so much easier having him deliver it, took one more thing off our list to prep for the party. Highly recommend.
Thank you so much, Maddie! It was a pleasure creating your custom cookie cake, and I'm so happy I could bring your detailed cowgirl and horse design to life. I know intricate designs can be a challenge, so hearing that it turned out just as you envisioned means a lot. I'm also glad that our protein cookie cake delivery made party planning a little easier for you. Thank you for trusting JakesCakes with such a special celebration, and I hope to create another custom birthday cookie cake for you the next time you're celebrating a special occasion!
Not only is Jake awesome, but so are his cakes… the cookie cake of course! He’s talented and efficient! This is my second time ordering from him and I’ll be doing it again and again! He customizes and is very aware of current trends in the world! He’s a Jake of all trades!
Thank you so much, JaCorey! It truly means a lot that you've trusted JakesCakes for a second time. I'm so glad you loved your custom birthday protein, cookie cake and that I could bring your vision to life. Every custom cake and cookie cake is made from scratch, and I always strive to create unique desserts that fit each celebration. I really appreciate your support and look forward to making your next birthday cake or custom dessert here in Austin. Thanks again for the amazing review!