Google reviewers rate Jennie Weller Catering 4.7 out of 5 based on 50 reviews, with the owner responding to 14 percent of them. Customers frequently praise the company for professional staff, punctuality, clear communication, and delicious food served at weddings, corporate events, and private gatherings. Recurring themes highlight flexible menu options and reliable service execution. However, low-star reviews identify pricing concerns, specifically citing high costs and retained deposits, alongside isolated complaints regarding the freshness of specific food items.
Google rating: 4.7 out of 5 from 50 reviews (92% five-star).
Reviews on this page: 50 Google reviews (29 with written comments, 1 with photos).
Owner responses: the business replied to 14% of reviews.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
SM
Skylin MillsLocal Guide · 13 reviews
★★★★★
Jennie Weller Catering did an amazing job catering the wedding! The food was delicious, the presentation was beautiful, and everything added such a special touch to the day. Weddings are such meaningful occasions, and having a caterer who helps make everything feel seamless and special makes all the difference. I would absolutely recommend Jennie Weller Catering to anyone planning a wedding or special event. Such a wonderful experience! 🤍
Jennie Weller Catering is a great catering company that I use all the time when placing large food orders. The staff is very professional, organized and on time!!
In my experience,Company is extremely over priced for their serviced. Your wedding will fund another couples tasting and thus another couple will fund yours.
However, if you are unable to move forward with your plans, they will keep at least $1000 of your money and say that the cost is due to a tasting that was technically already sponsored by another couple.
Beware, $1000 is a lot of money for one meal for 2-3 people.
Was so impressed with the JWCE staff for the wedding we worked together! Besides bringing delicious food, they brought a level of professionalism that sets them apart! Amazing.
We used Jennie Weller for a business convening of 35 folks from across the county which took place at The Legacy Meeting room. I worked with Melissa first for preliminary dates and menu. Then Martha took over and finally we had delivery from a gentleman whose name I cannot recall. Each of these folks were just amazing to deal with. I felt perfectly confident in their communication that we would be taken care of which was really important as I am based out of Chicago. Friendly, prompt and professional all in one. The delivery guy was amazing. He has been with the company for over 15 years. He was the perfect mix of friendly, efficient and professional. He even stepped outside with the ice because he didn’t want to disturb our meeting. Oh yes, the FOOD!!! Wow, the food was absolutely delish!! My personal fav was the Kale salad. (We actually had leftover and it was great the next day). If I lived in Montgomery I would have to find reasons to use Jennie Weller for all dining occasions :):). Thank you!!
Our law firm used Jennie Weller Catering for a reception we hosted last week, and as expected, the food was delicious, the service impeccable, the set up beautiful and the pickup flawless. Jannah coordinated the menu with us weeks in advance, and we gave her a headcount two days before our event. The cost was exactly as quoted, and we had lots of yummy leftovers we're still enjoying. We couldn't be happier and have never had less than a stellar experience with Jennie Weller Catering!
Response from the owner · 3 years ago
Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us this great review and share your experience with potential clients! We appreciate you!
We used Jennie Weller to cater our daughters wedding. I am not even sure the word awesome would cover it. The food was outstanding. Our daughter wanted to have a sit down meal after the wedding. The kale salad oh only if I had the recipe. The steak entree was phenomenal. So very favorable and could be cut with a fork. The serving staff was was awesome. The were spot on, kind and polite. Jennie worked with our event planner so very well. If you are planning an event get Jennie. Jennie if you ever need a personal testimony we are here for you. Thank you for helping make it an event to remember.
Response from the owner · 4 years ago
Oh this absolutely made our day! Thank you so much for your sweet review. We are so glad you were happy with the food and service!
