It was great service! Really made moving so much easier thank you again.
Thank you for the review! We hope you enjoy the new home in Westfield!

Google reviewers rate John Mitchell Moving 4.8 out of 5 stars based on 221 reviews. Positive feedback highlights punctual arrivals, careful handling of furniture, professional demeanor, and competitive pricing compared to competitors. Customers frequently note efficient service and helpful office staff during the quoting and scheduling process. Criticisms in lower-rated reviews focus on poor communication regarding schedule changes, unexpected additional charges, and instances where crews arrived with insufficient trucks or failed to complete the move.
Data from Google, last updated November 1, 2026.
Score per factor (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: momentum and value; weakest: craft & service.
Bar = this company · dark tick = category median.
221 Google reviews we collected
Phrases our text analysis found in 199 written reviews
Price verdicts customers left with their Google review
Middle half of what 34 customers paid ($556–$1.3k) · gold mark = category median.
How often each topic comes up in the written reviews
We read 199 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“They were professional, courteous and very careful with our furniture.”
“When I engaged about our deposit refund and once again explained we cannot extend our move date to accommodate THEM AND THEIR MISTAKE She hung up on me!”
“They called ahead, arrived on time, handled and protected our household furniture with care.”
“We highly recommend John Mitchell Two Guys and A Truck!”
“Would stay away from this company!”
“Chris, Christian, Bill, Blake and Gary did an outstanding job moving us today.”
“BUT I'm not alone in the horrible customer care experience with this company!”
“They completed the move below the estimate and at a great price.”
“The owner came to my house last time to give me a quote and left his business card.”
“And again, they were friendly and professional and answered all our questions.”
“I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a moving company you can truly trust”
“Do NOT use this company and certainly do NOT trust them!”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Customers hired John Mitchell Moving/Two Guys & A Truck for 5 kinds of job. Pick one to see what they paid and said.
Christopher & crew couldn’t have been better carefully moving and placing furniture where we wanted! They were very courteous and accommodating. We highly recommend John Mitchell Two Guys and A Truck!
Chris, Christian, Bill, Blake and Gary did an outstanding job moving us today. They were professional, courteous and very careful with our furniture. It was obvious that they are skilled movers. They completed the move below the estimate and at a great price. I highly recommend Two Guys & A Truck to anyone looking for a great moving experience.
All the employees that we interfaced with at John Marshall Moving were very accommodating, friendly and professional. Gary and Bill who moved us yesterday were excellent. They called ahead, arrived on time, handled and protected our household furniture with care. And again, they were friendly and professional and…
The guys were fast, safe, courteous, hardworking and easy to work with. Great experience and highly recommend.
Updated review as I was partially reimbursed which got me closer to my estimated cost. Up front communication around change in the number of movers and trucks needed would have been nice to avoid the experience I had with additional charges.
Our guys were awesome. Chris , Lamont, Cody and Zach worked well together and finished moving us in record time! No broken or scratched pieces.
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Local moving | 41 | $569–$1.5k |
| In-state moving | 15 | $786–$2.3k |
| Oversized-item moving | 11 | $228–$677 |
| Moving-related storage | 6 | $295–$986 |
| Furniture assembly | 2 | $271–$1.1k |
4.8 ★★★★★ 221 reviews on Google · rating breakdown
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
It was great service! Really made moving so much easier thank you again.
Thank you for the review! We hope you enjoy the new home in Westfield!
Christopher & crew couldn’t have been better carefully moving and placing furniture where we wanted! They were very courteous and accommodating. We highly recommend John Mitchell Two Guys and A Truck!
Chris, Christian, Bill, Blake and Gary did an outstanding job moving us today. They were professional, courteous and very careful with our furniture. It was obvious that they are skilled movers. They completed the move below the estimate and at a great price. I highly recommend Two Guys & A Truck to anyone looking for a great moving experience.
Thank you for allowing us to help in your move! Enjoy your new home in Greenfield!
All the employees that we interfaced with at John Marshall Moving were very accommodating, friendly and professional. Gary and Bill who moved us yesterday were excellent. They called ahead, arrived on time, handled and protected our household furniture with care. And again, they were friendly and professional and answered all our questions. We would highly recommend them.
Thank you for recognizing our guys hardwork! We were happy to help with your move from Carmel to Fishers!
We booked this company 1 day after their "estimator" came to our business office. We scheduled the date, paid the deposit, I emailed the "estimator", Shawn our exact move date and that we are booked. 1 day before our Booked moving date, I heard nothing. So, I called to confirm. I was greeted immediately by the female who answered with my name and the female stated, someone called you and left a message to confirm your move. As I had NOT received this voicemail, I stated as such. No voicemail received. The female stated, "oh, I'm sorry". I don't see you on my system, but that doesn't mean anything. I can't always see it." I indicated our move date. The female kept putting me on hold. She finally came back indicating a date for our move as a MONTH later than our actual move date. She made ZERO apologies and offered a move date 4 DAYS after the move date needed. I indicated that we cannot extend our SCHEDULED move date 4 days later. This female stated, sorry but she didn't know what they could do about it. I said, honor the move date I scheduled. She stated they can only go by Shawn's notes. O stated My email to Shawn has the correct date. She put me on hold again. I hung up. Talked to a different female. She reiterated the same as the previous and made ZERO apologies for THEIR mistake! When I engaged about our deposit refund and once again explained we cannot extend our move date to accommodate THEM AND THEIR MISTAKE She hung up on me! We had to email the evidence and make an additional phone call to get our deposit back! We did find movers last minute! Thank goodness! Do NOT use this company and certainly do NOT trust them!!! I'm sure they will try and deny this VALID review. BUT I'm not alone in the horrible customer care experience with this company!!!! UPDATE and reply to owner response: I expected the denial and dishonesty from this poorly managed company. I never indicated October and after my call on 9/9/2026 to their customer service representative with whom I booked 9/29/2026 for our move and deposit paid, I emailed Shawn with 9/29/2026 as our move date and 8:45am arrival. The fact that I had to provide this evidence should have been enough to acknowledge their mistake, but it sadly was not. We do record our phone calls that will also confirm the facts as I have stated them and that we 100% booked 9/29/2026 for morning arrival 8:45am. You admit in your reply that YOU MADE A RANDOM ASSUMPTION, randomly changed our move date without our knowledge, AND DID NOT THINK TO CALL YOUR CUSTOMER TO CONFIRM, especially after I emailed the correct date/the date we actually booked to Shawn! Once again, your mistake. Continuing to defend your poor service and actions only confirms this VALID review.
Kimberly. This is Shawn. I am going to follow up on this. This is not like us at all. I apologize for this. As a family owned company I take complaints and concerns VERY seriously. *UPDATE* I looked at the estimate you were provided, as well as the information on the computer and from the office staff. During the 1st conversation with the office, you stated a tentative move in October. During our on-site estimate, this was again stated and "October" listed on the estimate itself. When you called in to book, "the 29th" was taken as October 29. When you called yesterday, we apologized and tried to find a spot to move your office this week, offered Friday, but were told it had to be Tuesday or Wednesday. As we were not able to accommodate, we refunded the deposit. Unfortunately, Kimberly yelled at 2 of the office members here, and when she refused to stop (after repeatedly being asked to do so), we had no option but to stop the conversation. David, Kimberly's manager, later called, which gave us an opportunity to again apologize for the miscommunication and let him know the deposit was refunded.
The guys were fast, safe, courteous, hardworking and easy to work with. Great experience and highly recommend.
Updated review as I was partially reimbursed which got me closer to my estimated cost. Up front communication around change in the number of movers and trucks needed would have been nice to avoid the experience I had with additional charges.
Hello Austin. To update this review we sent $500 refund for the overage on the move vs estimate. We have reached out to several concrete companies for suggestions on repairs. They advised these are surface scratches and the only option would be cosmetic with a powerwash of the drive. I believe the office requested a powerwash company to reach out and schedule. If this has not happened, please let us know. Also, we take the allegations about our team's professionalism very seriously. After the office received descriptions we followed up with each crew memember.
The office staff helped make the quoting and scheduling process stress free. The crew was professional and handled our items with care. I would recommend them for any moving needs.
Thank you for the recognition of our team. Enjoy your new location in Indianapolis!
They were amazing from the beginning. We were in a pinch and they squeezed us into their schedule. They were fast and efficient and incredibly nice guys. We had a great experience and will definitely use them again.
It was our pleasure to help you with your move! Enjoy your new location in Fishers!
Shawn came out and gave me an accurate quote amid a house full of chaos. If you are hands on- do all the packing and stage items to be removed efficiently & you can save on labor time. The Crew manager, Christopher, was phenomenal and all the guys were polite and professional. We had two bed frame legs that were left on the truck and they returned the items within 24 hours. This was the best moving company/process we have experienced. Family owned and operated and Shawn even stopped by to check in before the trucks left for our new home. Don't overthink and use this company for your move.
We are very proud of our team! Many have been with us 10+ years. Thank you for the review and enjoy Fortville!