Google reviewers rate the agency 4.7 out of 5 based on 28 reviews, with the owner responding to 61% of them. Customers frequently praise the team for prompt communication, efficient email responses, and helpful guidance on auto, home, and health insurance policies. Recurring themes highlight friendly, knowledgeable staff who provide clear coverage explanations and competitive rates. However, a pattern of criticism in low-star reviews indicates that some clients experienced difficulty reaching the office by phone or receiving timely quotes.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
If you like prompt communication and streamlined support, Kyle and his team are for you. I couldn't be happier with how they treat me.
Thanks David!
Great experience with this company for both my auto and home insurance. Whenever I email with a question, I get a fast response - never left waiting around. The team is always available and happy to help, whatever the question. Highly recommend if you want an insurance provider that's actually responsive!
Jerry, thank you for the great review and awesome words about our team. Much appreciated!
Switched agents to get with McGreath i recommend everyone to switch best AMFAM agent and I have many policies and they keep it straight 💯 Pete Gervais Greenville WI
Thanks Pete, it's always a pleasure working with you as well.
I am new to the area and I contacted this office a few weeks ago to ask some questions about moving forward with their insurance. I spoke to a wonderful associate named Michelle. She was so knowledgeable and her customer service was amazing.
Hi Hailey, thank you for the wonderful review and comments about our team member. Customer service is one of our top priorities. Thanks again.
Great experience each time I have a question or a concern with my policy. Timely responses.
Thank you for the great review. It's always a pleasure working with you.
Kyle and has staff are great. They take care of your needs and are very friendly. I would recommend them and give them a 10+.
Hi Julie, Thank you so much for the kind words.
Very helpful. Knowledgeable and professional employees at this location.
Very respectful and responsible Agent and staff.
It was time to compare rates. American Family insurance came thru. Saved me money. Give them a call
Dan, we know that you have options and we are happy to welcome you to the Kyle McReath Agency. It's good to hear that Am Fam came through for you. We work hard to learn what our customers need and to suggest products to best protect their dreams. Thank you for the great review.
Great agency to work with! Very prompt and easy to get a hold and get along with!
Thank you so much for the kind words. We love to hear things like this.
Kyle McReath Agency LLC American Family Insurance on Google Maps →