Cynthia Huth7 reviews
Very burnt small pizza sub. I would have been ashamed to send it out!
Review from Google · view on Google
Lakeshore Teresa's Deli & Catering
Lakeshore Teresa's Deli & Catering at a glance
Customers frequently praise the large, meaty subs and affordable party pizzas, noting that catering orders typically arrive fresh with good communication. However, recurring complaints highlight inconsistent sandwich quality, including burnt or under-filled items, alongside limited evening hours and occasional phone ordering issues. Several reviewers also express dissatisfaction with recent management changes, citing perceived price increases and reduced portion sizes compared to previous ownership.
- Google rating: 4.6 out of 5 from 811 reviews (79% five-star).
- Reviews on this page: 811 Google reviews (557 with written comments, 17 with photos).
- Owner responses: the business replied to 90% of reviews.
- Most recent review: October 25, 2026.
- Service: Caterer serving Erie, Pennsylvania.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Photos
Customer reviews
4.6
★★★★★811 reviews on Google
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Cheryl HarbaughLocal Guide · 31 reviews
We love their subs, always plenty of meat, cheese etc... ! Was very good 👍
- Order type: Take out
- Meal type: Dinner
- Price per person: $20–30
- Reservation: Reservations not required
Review from Google · view on Google
Faith in God Changes EverythingLocal Guide · 14 reviews
* I don’t like giving bad reviews* but someone is cutting corners and not doing their job .The pizza was good, and usually everything is! Must have been a bad day the nightmare hoagie we got was missing half of what it should have. Disappointed- mostly just had canned mushrooms and peppers. It was gross and I got sick real quick. I hope it was a fluke because we love this place .
- Meal type: Dinner
- Price per person: $40–50
Response from the owner · a month ago
We are sorry for the inconvenience, if you would like to contact the store and give your information we would love to contact you to resolve the issue
Review from Google · view on Google
Brenda Fisher6 reviews
Tried ordering over phone on a Saturday evening and no one picked up.than ordered in person and was told they were short handed and not answering phone.aa I'm waiting for my food.the phone just kept ringing and ringing.
- Meal type: Dinner
- Price per person: $1–10
Response from the owner · 4 months ago
Hello Brenda we are sorry about your experience we were really short staffed today and wanted to focus on the people in front of us and in return we were unable to answer the phones and again we apologize for the inconvenience.
Review from Google · view on Google
Carol Fedei3 reviews
How dumb is it that you close at 7pm. A lot of us work for a living and have families that are busy. I mean 7pm on a Friday and Saturday night!! Really!!! Maybe some realistic hours of a pizza parlor. I mean people like pizza. Makes no sense.
Review from Google · view on Google
David SaiaLocal Guide · 118 reviews
Teresa's Deli knows what good food and good service is about. Thanks everyone.
- Meal type: Lunch
- Price per person: $10–20
- Group size: Suitable for all group sizes
Review from Google · view on Google
terence beckettLocal Guide · 25 reviews
Went as a group of 6 for our first ever US Italian deli Sub/hoagie experience... Boy did this place come up trumps.. Exactly what I hoped for... The staff are helpful and friendly, accomodating our needs.. 3 sizes of subs.. from large to massive! Great choice... I was brave and had the large combo nightmare... Hands down the best flavour and largest sandwich I have ever seen, and coming in at over 4lb way way to big for 1 person.. although I tried..! I got half way before I had to admit defeat.. But packed with fresh ingredients and big on flavour. Also had their brownies and Italian lemon cake.. Everyone enjoyed their choices (6 of us) Theresa's is the real deal!
- Meal type: Lunch
- Price per person: $10–20
- Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, Hoagie, Roast Beef, Sausage
- Group size: Suitable for all group sizes
Response from the owner · 2 months ago
Thank you so much for the generous review! We are so happy you had a great experience and we hope to see you again!
Review from Google · view on Google
Paige RhodesLocal Guide · 85 reviews
What a great local gem! All of their food is incredible, but what I can speak most highly of is the incredible deal of their party pizza! Anytime I have an event that I need to feed a lot of people, quickly and easily, this is always a great answer. They always can have one or two ready within a reasonable amount of time and the price is great for a huge pizza!
Response from the owner · 2 months ago
Thank you so much for your kind review!
Review from Google · view on Google
Dustine PerniceLocal Guide · 171 reviews
Been coming here for 46 years! Never had a bad meal.
Response from the owner · 2 months ago
Thank you so much for the generous review!
Review from Google · view on Google
Joe BargielskiLocal Guide · 529 reviews
Outstanding sandwiches. Not so great customer service. Tried to add to a order, but service was slow so we just skipped the additional items.
- Meal type: Dinner
- Price per person: $40–50
- Recommended dishes: Hoagie
- Group size: Suitable for all group sizes
Response from the owner · 7 years ago
Joe thank you so much!!! It’s a pleasure to serve you!!
Review from Google · view on Google
Business details
- Address: 5360 W Lake Rd, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 833-6913
- Website: teresasdeli.com
- Service area: Erie, PA