Analyzing 5,408,2915.4M ReviewsFor 14,54914.5K Experts
Google reviewers rate the store 4.8 out of 5 based on 235 reviews, noting that the owner rarely replies to feedback. Customers frequently praise the knowledgeable staff, friendly atmosphere, and extensive inventory of rare punk, hardcore, and metal vinyl. While some shoppers appreciate the curated selection and condition of records, others criticize the high pricing and mention issues with record storage that can affect playback quality.
Data from Google, last updated October 27, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We read 153 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“And he is just super knowledgeable about the genres and subgenres that the store is specialized in.”
“Found a conway record at a good price and the owner was a very nice guy”
“Ridiculously overpriced.”
“The owner is also really knowledgable and friendly, highly recommend a visit!”
“To top it all off the service was friendly, fair, and honest.”
“They package and inventory so nicely with their tags, the quality of what’s for sale is top notch.”
“The owner is very knowledgeable, their records go quick so make sure to follow them on Instagram, so you'll have an idea of what they got in.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Lovely, cozy store with a very friendly owner! Went with a friend and both really enjoyed the chill experience!
Ottimo negozio di dischi e vinili situato nell’East Village. Tante le edizioni limitate che si trovano in vendita. Merita una visita.
Great selection, but as their name implies, I was only allowed to buy one album.
Hi Alex! Thank you for stopping by the shop! We hope you're just kidding cause you can definitely buy more than one item in the shop. If you couldn't, that would be a bad business model! We can't wait to see you in the shop again soon. Next time you can buy as many as you like..
I go here every time in NY no matter how little time I have. By far my favourite record store.
Kristian is always getting great albums. Rarities. And he is just super knowledgeable about the genres and subgenres that the store is specialized in. It's always worth stopping in. Only downside is I always leave with more than I intend upon getting! But that's not really a bad thing, now is it?
Planqué dans un sous sol du East village, ce magasin de disques est une véritable pépite! Incroyable sélection de vinyles rares, notamment en rock/punk/hardcore. Le tenancier est en plus super sympa et d'excellents conseils !
“Rare vinyl, specializing in Punk, Emo, HC…” If that’s what you’re looking for, that’s what you’ll get at Limited to One. Great shop, great selection, great owner, great community.
Muy especializado.Poca variedad en pop rock y precios caros
This record shop is geared towards the record connoisseur, one that comes with deep pockets, and an acquired taste for the finest punk and hardcore. I was impressed with the quality of the records, most seemed untouched, but this is reflected in the price. If you are looking for some obscure titles and willing to dish out the dough. This would be the record shop for you. Staff is friendly and willing to search their catalogue. Take a look, it might not be for everyone, but it definitely has some gems.
Place isn't huge, but good things come in small packages. Don't they. Go to limited from astoria... that should say it all
Analyzing 5,408,2915.4M ReviewsFor 14,54914.5K Experts