Google reviewers rate Lizzie's Grove Street Bakery 4.8 out of 5 based on 282 reviews, praising its custom cakes, doughnuts, and cinnamon rolls for their taste and reasonable pricing. Staff are frequently described as friendly and helpful in handling special orders. However, several low-star reviews criticize recent inconsistencies in product freshness, specifically noting stale cookies or undercooked fritters, alongside complaints about unresponsive communication for advance orders.
Google rating: 4.8 out of 5 from 282 reviews (89% five-star).
Reviews on this page: 282 Google reviews (184 with written comments, 18 with photos).
Owner responses: the business replied to 15% of reviews.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
KM
Kate Mester2 reviews
★★★★★
Showed them a photo idea for a double layer cookie cake in the shape of a 50 for my parent's 50th anniversary with icing in their wedding colors. They said they would need to hand-make it and quoted a deeply reasonable price. The finished product exceeded our expectations. It was super delicious, the cookie layers were moist and a great combo of chewy/crunchy. Fantastic artistry and service - definitely have them make your cookie cakes!!!
Love this bakery! They do some amazing things here! From doughnuts to cinnamon rolls to sugar cookies, everything is incredibly delicious. I love the pillowy dough and the icing on their doughnuts. The filled ones are completely filled!!! The cinnamon rolls taste handmade and the icing is generously applied, which I appreciate! Top tier in my opinion. The banana foster doughnut was spectacular and I wish it was a common staple. By far my favorite! Come check this place out. Won’t be disappointed!
Lizzy's Grove street bakery is delicious and so worth the trip. The staff she has working there are so nice and helpful. Today i tried the lemon coffee cake and a large cinnamon roll. Everyone loved them. Ill be back
Meal type: Breakfast
Price per person: $1–10
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Roll, Twist Donut, Custom Sugar Cookie Order, Coffee Cake, Scone, Danish, Long John
I went in knowing they had amazing cookies and donuts. However I needed a special specific cake for a friend's 50th birthday. I popped in and talked to Chris who took my order and ended up making my cake. Chris was wonderful but I was still a little apprehensive as to how it would turn out. When I picked it up I think I literally gasped it was spot on and I was thrilled! Chris can't thank you enough. You are very talented! Everyone loved the cake and I had several people ask where it was from. Birthday girl loved it and tasted amazing!
While Grove Street Bakery always has the most amazingly delicious sweet treats, they are also the kindest, most considerate people! A heartfelt THANK YOU to Wyatt and Chris for helping me out after I made a mistake with my order (again). Your bakery is such a blessing to our community! ❤️
Amazing! A friend ordered custom cookies for me last minute and Grove Bakery pulled thru with the most DELICIOUS and adorable cookies. Would order with them again and again and again!!! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
10/10 no notes! I reached out about a fairly large order for custom made sugar cookies- they were able to assist without an issue. I met Lizzie when I picked up the order, she was so kind. The cookies looked perfect everyone loved them. #supportlocal
