Analyzing 5,667,2995.7M ReviewsFor 15,56715.6K Experts
Google reviewers rate Lost4toys 4.9 out of 5 based on 90 reviews, highlighting a large selection of toys, comics, and collectibles at fair prices. Customers frequently describe the staff as friendly, knowledgeable, and welcoming, noting that the store accommodates both casual shoppers and serious collectors. While most feedback is positive, two identical one-star reviews criticize an employee for being loud, argumentative, and angry when asked about pricing. The owner replied to only 7% of the total reviews.
Data from Google, last updated October 27, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We read 69 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“Great store and the owner is extremely knowledgable and friendly!”
“Highly recommend as I bought vintage toys and will be back for comic books and figures when I set up my display.”
“Comics have a good price range from around $1-$50 depending if they are collectable.”
“I had a great experience and found a lot cards and toys that I was looking for!”
“Website easy to use, shipment fast, and the product was more than I expected.”
“Great store in long island and a spot you could honestly look at all the pop figures and comic book stuff he has for hours if that's what you're into.”
“Staffs also easy to talk to.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Great store and the owner is extremely knowledgable and friendly! Would recommend this spot to anyone.
large selection .. nice place
Best store great items great prices
Awesome items Welcoming team Encouraged to bring own items for resale Great location
First time going there yesterday with a buddy of mine 6/13/26 we got some great things yesterday. I do love the atmosphere going in there. It’s like a little sanctuary for all geeks of all generations. Got myself a few Pokémon cards. And looking forward to getting some comic books over there and maybe some more Pokémon cards in the future. If you’re a geek of pop culture, then this is your place to check it out.
What a pleasant surprise. This store is full of great finds with a great variety of toys and collectable items. The gentlemen inside are welcoming and engaging. I admire a business where its obvious thay they love their store and take pride in their business. We'll done!
Thank you for the amazing and friendly customer service I received from Gavin and Nick during my visit to the Lost 4 Toys store. I appreciate the advice they gave me as I recently started collecting figurines, etc. If you are in the area, definitely checkout this store. All the Best.
Cliff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. I had a great experience and found a lot cards and toys that I was looking for!
Great staff and AMAZING owner! A variety of collectibles and toys. Great place to be at and support. Thank you for all you help!
Came in here on a whim with my 3 year old looking for cars and from the moment we walked in the staff was so friendly, helpful and kind. We spent a lot of time there browsing before my son finally decided on his cars and never felt rushed or unwelcome. Truly a gem to find and they had so many collectibles, figurines and other toys.
Analyzing 5,667,2995.7M ReviewsFor 15,56715.6K Experts