Brandon RaatzLocal Guide · 165 reviews
Friendly staff, very clean
- Price assessment: Reasonable price
- Services: Property insurance
- Quote wait time: Within 24 hours
- Ease of reaching staff: Very easy
Review from Google · view on Google
Martz Insurance Agency, Inc.
Martz Insurance Agency, Inc. at a glance
Customers frequently cite friendly, knowledgeable staff and efficient service when handling auto, home, and other insurance policies. Many reviewers note that the agency offers competitive rates and provides clear explanations of coverage options, including assistance for independent contractors. However, one recurring criticism involves the agency allegedly setting coverage limits below statutory requirements, which led to higher premiums compared to other providers.
- Google rating: 4.8 out of 5 from 44 reviews (91% five-star).
- Reviews on this page: 44 Google reviews (24 with written comments).
- Owner responses: the business replied to 2% of reviews.
- Most recent review: September 8, 2026.
- Service: Insurance Agent serving Wautoma, Wisconsin.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Photos
Customer reviews
4.8
★★★★★44 reviews on Google
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Todd FriedelLocal Guide · 29 reviews
I am new to the area but my family is not. I had an insurance agency I was pretty happy with. Seeing how Martz insurance has taken such good care of my family over the past almost two years I couldn’t help but switch. I feel good about paying premiums to a group of people that has supported my family over the past 16 years. 5 stars and 2 thumbs up.
Review from Google · view on Google
Teena BennettLocal Guide · 13 reviews
Buyer beware this company picks how much they want to insur you for ! I have been paying way to much for car insurance due to the fact they don't insur whats only required by law ! Check you're policy and also shop around ! I saved $500 + yrly dropping this company ! So please re check you're policy.....Next move is my homeowners policy !
- Price assessment: Overpriced
- Services: Vehicle insurance
Review from Google · view on Google
Steve Piha2 reviews
I stopped by 6 months ago to get information about estate planning. While they don't have that service, they gave me suggestions and we spoke like family friends for 10 minutes. When it came time to renewing my policies, I went back in and decided to switch all my insurance needs to them (home, auto, RV, SxS, boats, & snowmobiles). Ron was assigned to me and was personable, thorough, and diligent to address my needs. Process was painless. Rates were much lower with better coverage. Thanks
- Price assessment: Great price
- Services: Boat & watercraft insurance, Property insurance, Vehicle insurance
Review from Google · view on Google
Mary SpillerLocal Guide · 188 reviews
Love Jeff
Response from the owner · a year ago
Thanks for the love! We're thrilled to hear you enjoy working with Jeff. If you need anything else, feel free to reach out.
Review from Google · view on Google
Bill Marks11 reviews
Martz is the best! Great customer service. Better policies AND better rates! Thumbs up to Jeff!
Review from Google · view on Google
Theresa CLocal Guide · 34 reviews
I had called about comparison quotes for my 19 year old Daughter. Ron was very good at explaining what effects the cost. Driving record, age, car, where a car is garaged, etc. It was very nice not to have to be put on hold, press a long list of numbers. Good ol' customer service . Honest, professional and friendly still exists.
Review from Google · view on Google
Lisa McCauleyLocal Guide · 14 reviews
Ron is wonderful very helpful and very knowledgeable give him a call always cheaper than the others.
Review from Google · view on Google
Mary AndersonLocal Guide · 42 reviews
Friendly and helpful. A pleasure to work with.
Review from Google · view on Google
Jeffery Hotzel3 reviews
Took care of me and gave me the best advice needed for my home insurance
Review from Google · view on Google
Business details
- Address: 573 S Cambridge St, Wautoma, WI 54982
- Phone: (920) 787-2900
- Website: martzinsurance.com
- Service area: Wautoma, WI