Google reviewers rate MaximuM Comics 4.8/5 based on 365 reviews, with the owner responding to only 4% of comments. Customers frequently praise the store's clean environment, extensive selection of modern comics, and friendly, knowledgeable staff who provide helpful service. Common criticisms include the store's small size, limited inventory of vintage or graded books, and negative experiences regarding comic buyback policies and return refusals.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Awesome shop, super friendly staff. First time visiting and will definitely be back.
Thank you, Johnnie! You made our day with your kind review, Have an awesome day yourself!
When you call and ask these guys if they buy comics, they’ll say yes! So you’ll load everything into the car and haul it across town just for them to buy absolutely nothing. Do not waste your time with these guys.
Julia, I apologize if you had a negative experience at our shop, it is not our intent to cause anyone problems or headaches. We definitely do buy comics, however we do not buy all comic collections that are offered us. The comics you have are very recent and therefore are comics we have plenty of. I do know we relayed that information to you, that we do consider collections, however in future we will do better about clarifying that we may not buy all collections, to clear up any potential confusion. We hope you were able to find a buyer for the collection and wish you the best--Jay
Great atmosphere and selection! The staff are all very knowledgeable and very helpful as well!
Wooo! Thank you, Elisha. That makes our day. We hope to see you and chat comics soon.
Horrible Customer Service. "Claim"... "I'll take it, send me an invoice", means I'll take it and will purchase it. I wasn't asking to anyone to "Hold It". Just needed time to park at a safe location. What a disappointment.
Called about some comincs I found in a storage locker I bought. They priced them out for me and even gave me a respectable offer. Great staff, friendly and knowledgable. Store was full of good stuff.
Thank you for visiting us and for the kind review. We definitely look forward to helping you with your comics needs in the future. Have an awesome day!
Awesome selection, really cool store. Jay is very knowledgeable and is very passionate about what he does.
as a girl theres very few times when you’re able to find a place as inviting and kind as the staff here are. the customer service is amazing, never mansplain & are very knowledgeable. They have the best selection and fair prices.
Clean store. Extremely helpful staff. Great selection. Definitely coming back.
The staff here is always helpful. Store is clean and organized.
Clean, well organized, and extremely nice staff!