Reviewers report a perfect 5.0 rating from 22 reviews, highlighting the team's responsiveness, clear communication, and assistance with both buying and selling properties. Clients frequently mention the agents' patience in answering questions, their ability to negotiate within budgets, and their support during complex transactions such as farmland sales or multiple closings. The owner replied to 27% of the reviews. No significant criticisms or patterns of negative feedback appear in the provided excerpts.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
I inherited 20 acres of farmland a few years ago. When I decided to sell it, I contacted Steve and Kelly. They were very helpful right off the bat. As offers came in they explained all of the benefits and possible problems with each one. Anytime I tried to contact them, I got a quick and clear response. In the end, we had a very smooth and successful sale. I highly recommend them to you.
My family and I had an amazing experience working with Steve and Kelly McCarthy. From the very start, they set clear expectations and made the entire process completely hassle-free. They listened to what we wanted, stayed firmly within our budget, and checked off every single one of our necessities. When it came down to it, they negotiated hard on our behalf and absolutely exceeded our expectations. Their professionalism made what could have been a stressful move an incredibly pleasant experience. I can’t thank them enough and highly recommend them.
Working with the Steve and Kelly team was an amazing experience! They made the sale of my property a simple and pain free experience. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Yuba-Sutter area.
Kelly and Steve made the selling process so easy. Kelly took the time to answer every question I had (even the silly ones). They listened and were responsive without delay. I highly recommend Kelly and Steve for your selling or buying needs! Stellar level for real estate needs!
Thank you so much Jeanne! It was great working for you. You made it so easy.
Steve and Kelly are a joy to work with. In a tough economic situation, their compassion, empathy, expertise, and guidance was essential to selling our home! They were there for us every step of the way. They are fantastic communicators, and were super responsive to our needs. I could call Kelly anytime I had a question or concerns, and she was always available to us. I know we will do more business with the McCarthy Real Estate team., and I highly recommend them to anyone seeking any type of real estate needs. They are just Great People! It was an honor working with them. We will be friends forever! We love you guys! Andrew, T, and Moon Morical
Thank you so much! It was a pleasure working for you. All of you guys are near and dear to our hearts. We love you guys as well!
Amazing. Steve and Kelly were in constant communication, handled everything for me, and removed a lot of stress during a stressful time. I can't recommend them enough.
"Steve and Kelly McCarthy went above and beyond to ensure a seamless transition from my current home to my dream home. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care turned what could have been a stressful move into a smooth and successful experience. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for dedicated and trustworthy real estate professionals!"
Thank you for your kind words, Ryan! We're thrilled to hear that Steve and Kelly made your transition to your dream home so seamless. Their dedication to providing top-notch service is truly commendable, and it's great to know that you felt supported throughout the process. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we look forward to assisting others just like you in the future!
Kelly made the selling process so easy. She was always kind and patience and very knowledgeable. She was super responsive with communication and would follow through promptly with everything! I could not have asked for a better experience!
Kelly and Steve are lovely people, and incredibly knowledgeable realtors! I can't recommend them and their team highly enough if you're looking to sell in the greater Chico area. From navigating pre-listing updates (which they had great advice and professional contacts for) to navigating offer review, inspections, negotiation and closing (three times!!), they were always responsive, professional and supportive. I may have been one of their toughest clients this year, unfortunately, as the sale of my Chico Charmer coincided with a tough wildfire season and bumpy interest rate environment. At every hurdle, Kelly had options, resources, and answers for me thanks to her extensive experience. At the end of the day, I got a fair price and the buyer's unique needs were also handled respectfully and competently, leading to a positive transaction for everyone. Kelly is a good listener, communicative, and always on top of the ball. Even though I had to move out of the area while the house was still on the market, I felt safe leaving the sale in her hands, and am so grateful to have had her representing me throughout this process. She was an excellent advocate for my interests, and I recommend her to anyone seeking a highly skilled seller's agent!
Thank you for your wonderful review, A.R.! We're thrilled to hear that Kelly and Steve provided you with exceptional service throughout your selling experience. Your kind words and detailed feedback mean a lot to us. We truly appreciate your trust and support, especially during challenging times. Wishing you all the best in your future endeavors!
Me and my husband want to take the time and thank the McCarthy Team! We want to thank you for all the fantastic work you’ve done for us. Thank you for going the extra mile for us on every step of our home buying journey! We could not have done this without you, and we are so grateful for your assistance, patience, and expertise. I would recommend this team for you needs. Steve and Kelly ensured us that no question is a dumb question. Thank you again for everything. We are extremely grateful to have worked with you as our agent. Sincerely, Veejay and Isaac