How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%94+51.3Reliability 24%91+22.1Value 14%100+14.1Replies to reviews 7%100+7.1Experts Score= 95Grade A: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.95SCOREMcCormick Quality Tires and Lube
Fort Collins, CO · Grade ALetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #152Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 1092 auto repair shops · 5.0★ from 552 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other auto repair shops (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: value and momentum; weakest: reliability.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired McCormick Quality Tires and Lube for 8 kinds of job.
McCormick Quality Tires and Lube for tires
Clear ✕All 100 Google reviews tagged “Tires” · showing 60
I’ve been having my vehicle serviced for a few years its always top notch & the guys at the desk are incredibly helpful & friendly.
Fast, friendly, honest service, fixed the problem, no pressure. Thomas did a great job on our Leaf as always, very happy with our sevice as always!
Went in to get a nail out of my tire and was happy to hear they offered complementary service! Thomas got it fixed up real quick, walked out feelin good as new!
Great experience at McCormick! I came in to check and adjust my tire pressure, and I was good to go in less than ten minutes thanks to my technician, Ty! Super quick and professional team—I will be back!
I’ve taken my vehicle here several times over the last year and have always had a great experience. It’s a fairly new shop with a friendly, approachable vibe. Kind of the opposite of the typical dealership. Quality work at a fair price.
I had a slow leak in my tire. I brought it in and they plugged the nail hole free of charge. Great customer service. It was super fast and I was back on the road in like 15 minutes. Great experience!
This is definitely my new auto repair shop. Thank you Thomas and Marty. Recently moved to Fort Collins. Came here with a tire that needed proper mounting and they took care of it in a few minutes, while showing the professionalism and client-centricness that very few places can equal. They also have another shop…
Had a possible slow leak in a tire but I wasn't sure. They were able to take me as a walk in, check the tire, and confirm there was no puncture. In and out in 20 minutes, and no charge! Will definitely come back for future tire needs.
Fixed a tire quickly.
Best place in town for automotive services. Upfront, honest, friendly, and great pricing. Had 4 new tires installed & oil change done. Very satisfied. Wish I knew about McCormick sooner. Will definitely get all my services done by them in the future. Many thanks to Marty & the rest of the team!
They checked out and fixed my tire after multiple tires were deflating to flat when I had these tires rotated the day before at Discount tire. I appreciate their attention to detail, kindness, and ability to fix the problem.
I am unsure how this place has a 5.0 star reviews. I just went in to get my tire patched and got quoted over 70 dollars to patch one tire.(my tires are not specialty tires nor they were flat. It was a slow leak) Never in my life I paid more than 30 dollars to get my single tire patched. Went to Big O tires instead…
I had such a great experience here! They did everything they could to help me with my tire repair and were able to get me in the same day, which I really appreciated. The service was friendly, kind, and genuinely had that small-town feel—like dealing with people you can actually trust. Ty was my mechanic, and he…
This is Dusty Neil of the Dusty Neil Band. guys. Thank you so much for airing up all my tires in my car. You guys are so awesome. I will bring more business to you always. 👊😇🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🙏🙏
Fast, effective, and friendly.
I didn’t have a plan of getting 4 new tires put on my car today, but the quality work Jared gave made it a little less painful.
The team got me in and out. Thomas was thorough and did a great job. I’m back on the road and ready for next another adventure! Thanks dudes
I am new to this tire shop, they have a great location, a clean quality shop and their kindness and work ethic to back up the look. I will certainly make this my go to in the future. They offer great support to the community, and truly stand out!
Great service! They fixed my tire for free in just 10 minutes. Very fast, kind, and professional. I really appreciate their help and highly recommend this place!
Kevin worked on my tires...was done timely and perfectly and everything is reset.
Great work from Kevin!
Thank you Kevin for the quick work on my tires and oil change!
Marty is a great rep for McCormick's quality tires. We really appreciate his help getting my son's flat tire fixed on graduation day!!
Jason is the best
Have been going to this shop for awhile now and they do a great job, getting me in and in a timely manner. Wesley did a great job and everyone else is so welcoming. Highly recommended this shop for any service on your vehicle
Very friendly! Super honest, quick, and efficient. Kyle did an amazing job with the tire patch job. Highly recommend this shop!
McCormick was great to work with and offered me multiple options to fix the leak in my tire. I would come back again!
Took my car in for a flat to see if it could be repaired, they examined the whole car and gave me advice due to my breaks being loud instead of trying to upsell me they recommended I skip unnecessary parts that are high cost and gave me a clean answer on what the absolute bare minimum fixes would be. This saved me…
These guys are the best. My daughter's car is a big POS and they always get her in right away. They diagnose the problem and give her a clear estimate on fixing it. They have been a life saver. Thanks guys Shawn in Gillette wy
This place was amazing, everything was so professional and friendly. Kevin was able to diagnose and solve our problem in just a blink of an eye. The 5 star rating is well deserved.
FANTASTIC from start to finish! I brought my car in because it was making a weird noise and this team was great throughout all interactions. The front desk were very nice in conversation and throughout the whole process with explaining the diagnosis and what was needed right away without taking advantage of my lack…
Kevin delivered great service checking over my tires for an upcoming long road trip.
My vehicle got a flat and needed to be towed. I called in to arrange everything, the person I spoke to was very friendly and quick to help (the only reason this isn't a 1 star). Within 30 minutes the car was being towed in and arrived right at closing time. The next morning I received a call that we would need to…
Everyone was super helpful! Kevin was the one who helped me get my tire all patched up. They were super quick and kind. Definitely will be coming back again!
I had a slow leak in my tire, Jacob fixed it right up. Overall easy, smooth experience. Will be here again!
Always feel cared for at McCormick. No high pressure, just the facts. Thanks, Cory, for keeping my truck going so I can give it to my Son.
Wesley did a great job. He worked hard to get tire’s installed
Wes did a great job with my jeep. They worked with me and my budget. Highly recommend McCormick.
Fast, effective and professional. We gladly trust McCormick with our vehicle - thanks Caleb!
Excelent service, quick and easy. Thank you for making my day easier.
Very friendly and helpful!
Great service, kind and professional service, fixed my tire quickly and right away!
They were so helpful repairing a tire leak caused by a nail. Got us in fast, made sure we were good to go. Feel confident with the repair. Not trying to sell us anything. Trustworthy and reliable.
McCormick was able to replace our tires immediately and quickly, and gave us a really thorough breakdown of everything to help plan for future work on the car. Marty was so helpful and straightforward. Will definitely be returning for future repairs and work on the car!
McCormick Tires is a good place for prompt, polite and inexpensive help with tires. I made an appointment to check out a tire problem and they resolved the matter within 15 minutes, and added air to my tires at no charge. I will definitely go there again when I need assistance with tires.
Quick and effective service. Rotated and changed tires on a travel trailer in a just a few hours getting me back on the road in no time! Check them out!
Went here because I noticed a slow leak in one of my tires. They fit me into their busy schedule and had a quick turnaround of the fix. A very professional and polite customer service. I highly recommend them.
I had a slow leak in a tire and McCormicks patched it up at no charge! Thanks!
Outstanding customer service! They quickly took care of my tire leak despite my tight schedule, making the whole process effortless. I’m so glad I came here for a quick fix, and I know exactly where I’ll go for any future tire or repair needs!
Came in for a tire that was slowly leaking air for a while. They found a nail in my tire and fixed it free of charge, I'm incredibly thankful and the service was great and fast!
We were on vacation and needed help quickly with a nail in our rental car's tire. McCormick got us right in and back on the road in no time. They are wonderful!! Highly recommend.
Quick and easy tire repair! I’ve also gotten a new set of tires here and that was an easy, efficient process as well!
They were able to find the leak in my tire and patch it very quickly. Excellent service as well!
The guys here did excellent work on my car and saved me a lot of money on my tires. Cannot recommend enough!!
In early August we travelled from Canada to California. One day on the way to Fort Collins to stop for lunch, 100 miles from destination, our rear tire blew on Interstate 25. After considering our options we checked tire places in Fort Collins. The type of tire on our Cadillac CTS is 245/45 R19 which is not common…
Helped tremendously, saved me money, and got what I needed done quickly
The staff were so kind & helpful, and the work they did on my tire was beyond excellent! My family will absolutely be returning for future services!
We searched all over Fort Collins to find a place that could help replace a tire on my son's e-scooter. Motorsports places, e-bikes / bike shops, and of course tire shops. None of them could help. Only one bike shop, and the charges would have been very high. We spoke to Wesley, who at first said they wouldn't be…
Really great bunch of techs! Gave us a solid car check up and an honest take on how ready our ride was for a cross country move from CO to NC. No complaints here, definitely recommended👌
Very quick to offer me assistance with a damaged tire. Honored the warranty and replaced it with a new tire free of charge. Offered me a free loaner vehicle over the weekend until the work was completed on Monday. They were concerned that my I might need alignment work but after evaluation they were honest and said…
Price
Not enough reviews with a price yet.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Tires | 100 | — |
| Oil change | 30 | — |
| Air & cabin filter replacement | 16 | — |
| Wheel alignment | 14 | — |
| Vehicle safety inspection | 10 | — |
| Auto engine diagnostic | 8 | — |
| General repairs & maintenance | 7 | — |
| Transmission | 5 | — |

