Mills Catering LLC logo

Mills Catering LLC

4.9 ★★★★★ · 47 Google reviews · 13 photos
Caterer · Noblesville, IN

Mills Catering LLC at a glance

Google reviewers rate Mills Catering LLC 4.9 out of 5 based on 47 reviews, highlighting consistent praise for the quality and variety of food served at weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Customers frequently cite the team’s punctuality, responsive communication, and professional setup as key strengths, noting that the pricing offers good value for the service provided. The primary criticism from a single low-star review involved a specific dish lacking flavor, though this did not reflect the broader sentiment regarding the overall catering experience.

  • Google rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 47 reviews (96% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 47 Google reviews (40 with written comments, 4 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 0% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: October 14, 2026.
  • Service: Caterer serving Noblesville, Indiana.

Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.

Photos

Customer reviews

4.9
★★★★★
47 reviews on Google
5★45
4★1
3★0
2★0
1★1

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Lynnette Goodwin4 reviews
★★★★★

Great experience and great food! dealing with Anne was a pleasure. We had 150+ at a wedding a few days ago and everything went perfectly!

Review from Google · view on Google
Ella Palmer2 reviews
★★★★★

Mills Catering was SO INCREDIBLE for our wedding! We received so many compliments on the food from our guests. The food was so so delicious; the pasta was warm, tender, and perfectly cooked. Not only was the food incredible, but their service was absolutely beyond our expectations. They were more than willing to go above and beyond to make sure that everything was how I wanted it. They walked my husband and I through the line and brought our plates to our table; they also did the same thing with our grandmas who had a hard time walking on their own- without us telling them to. I would highly recommend Mills Catering to anyone who needs a caterer in the Indianapolis area!

Review from Google · view on Google
Bridget Murray8 reviews
★★★★★

Matt, Anne, and the whole Mills Catering team were so lovely to work with for our wedding! My husband and I are big foodies, and Matt worked with us to create a special passed apps menu that represented some of our favorite dishes from different eras of our relationship. When our parents went to the tasting, they were so impressed by Anne's experience and knew we were in good hands. Plus, the food & bar was incredible!! The team even worked through a power glitch on our wedding day without us even knowing anything had gone wrong. Food got out on time, and folks loved it. Thank you Mills for making our day that much more special.

Review from Google · view on Google
Jon MillerLocal Guide · 22 reviews
★★★★★

Matt and his staff rock. Great place for your catering needs. Highly recommend.

Review from Google · view on Google
Laura Schroeder3 reviews
★★★★★

Anne was terrific to work with in planning our event--very quick to respond to our questions, helpful, and kind. The staff at the event were efficient and responsive and took excellent care of us and our guests. They made everything go so smoothly through the whole event. When it was time for them to start putting the food away, noticing that I hadn't had time to eat anything, they kindly filled a to-go box for me. I 100% recommend Mills Catering!

Review from Google · view on Google
Stephanie JonesLocal Guide · 39 reviews
★★★★★

We used them for a business catering event and the food was amazing and they offered the utmost in customer service.

Review from Google · view on Google
Melody Petty8 reviews
★★★★★

Mills Catering went above and beyond for our annual shareholders meeting! From start to finish their service was EXCEPTIONAL. The food was delicious and the team who delivered, set up, and served was not only professional but incredibly friendly and helpful. During the planning phase, Mills was quick to get me all the info I needed, and their communication was excellent. They arrived right on time and took care of every detail making the entire experience stress-free. Look no further for a catering company that delivers amazing food with top-notch service. I highly recommend!

Review from Google · view on Google
RNLocal Guide · 16 reviews
★★★★★

Anne at Mills Catering provided great customer service and was very helpful in making sure all of our catering needs and wants were in order. We loved that Mills has a a diverse menu to choose from and that we were able to provide our guests with meal options and a range of passed hors d'oeuvres, entrees, and desserts. Everything was delicious and affordable. The table set ups and caterers were wonderful the day of our wedding, and we are so appreciative of the hard work, professionalism, and dedication in making sure we and our guests were taken care of! We would highly recommend Mills to cater your event.

Review from Google · view on Google
Angelina Finnegan8 reviews
★★★★★

I would highly recommend Mills Catering! They catered our son's graduation party; the food and service was outstanding!!

Review from Google · view on Google
Jacquelyn Leggett8 reviews
★★★★★

We loved working with Mills Catering for our Harrison Center Porch Party at COhatch Polk Stables! Huge shoutout to Anne (amazing sales associate), Matt (fantastic owner), and Bert, who was so kind and set up the entire display beautifully on-site in record time. The staff was incredibly friendly, the food was fresh and beautifully presented, and the lemonade, made with love, is an absolute must-order! Thank you for making our event such a hit. We can’t wait to work with Mills Catering again for our next event!

Review from Google · view on Google

Mills Catering LLC on Google Maps →

Business details