Analyzing 5,454,0725.5M ReviewsFor 14,69014.7K Experts
Google reviewers rate the bakery 4.5 out of 5 based on 95 reviews, frequently praising the moist texture, beautiful decoration, and accurate execution of custom design requests for cakes and cookies. However, several low-star comments criticize the pricing as high relative to portion sizes, note that some items lacked flavor or moisture, and mention that the staff was unfriendly or that specific orders did not match provided reference photos.
Data from Google, last updated October 27, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We read 73 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“The owner is one of a kind she is a great and truly caring person.”
“The lady at the counter called me "honey bun" the whole time which I found very unprofessional.”
“10/10 would munch here again when I’m near 👁️🫦👁️”
“They do an excellent job at decorating to my liking and I have never had a better cake than from here.”
“Cake was absolutely beautiful but it was terrible to eat.”
“It was a beautifully crafted, delicious cake that was very reasonably priced 😊 Thank you Ms.”
“Went out of their way to help me out and made me cookies for that same day!”
“We love you guys, from the dependable plumbing crew!”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Slightly disappointed by the design/effort put into our shower cookies. Was not too wowed by taste. We will be going with different options for our wedding.
Cake was absolutely beautiful but it was terrible to eat. No taste. The raspberry filling was bland. Very disappointed for a $100 cake.
My sister called them a few weeks before my daughter’s first birthday party, and they said they would try their best to do something similar to the photos we sent as inspiration. When I saw how they turned out, I was so impressed!! They did a beautiful job, and they tasted amazing!! Thank you so much! Will definitely use again for next event!
They have the best cakes and cookies!
Excellent place to pick up your goodies!!
Awesome people and the cake was delicious as always! This cake was decorated beautifully. It turned out better than the picture I showed them.
Owner was rude and pushy. 4 bucks for a cookie with barely any frosting? No thanks. Ill stick with Belmar bakery across the street! Their cookies are 3 dollars, taste much better, and are loaded with frosting. Ms. piggys cookie left something to be desired.
I just picked up a $60 cake from here, and I am not impressed. I sent a inspo pic and the cake looks absolutely nothing like it. I wanted the font in all lower case like the pic I sent however is not lower case. I’m super disappointed and feel like it was such a waste of money.
Amazing service and beautiful cake. I ordered from out of town and sent a photo of what my niece wanted- they nailed it! I didn’t get to try it, but in her words: “Sooo sooo good”. Thanks for making her day so special!
First time ordering from Ms. Piggy’s for my sons birthday party and this was a true work of art and tasted delicious!! We will certainly be coming back
Analyzing 5,454,0725.5M ReviewsFor 14,69014.7K Experts