Robert provided a very smooth experience getting an in-person replacement value appraisal for insurance. Robert was able to accommodate my schedule and was flexible when there were public transportation delays. The appraisal was quick, and my insurance accepted it immediately. Robert is a professional and credentialed appraiser who charges a reasonable fee for his time. He also kept my item in my view during the whole appraisal process for my comfort. This is unlike some more unscrupulous individuals/businesses in Manhattan and the diamond district that do not uphold professional standards and indicated they would quote me based on the value of my item and need to take my item into a back room. I am very happy I chose to get my item appraised by Robert, who made the process easy for me and provided thorough and detailed paperwork in line with my stated needs.

NYC Jewelry Appraisers
NYC Jewelry Appraisers at a glance
Google reviewers rate NYC Jewelry Appraisers 4.9 out of 5 based on 100 reviews. Customers frequently describe the appraisal process as quick, thorough, and professional, noting that staff members are punctual, flexible with scheduling, and transparent about pricing. Positive feedback highlights the clear communication and detailed explanations provided during in-person or remote evaluations for insurance or estate purposes. The primary criticism found in low-star reviews concerns a lack of responsiveness, where clients reported not receiving replies after submitting photos for appraisal.
- Google rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 100 reviews (97% five-star).
- Reviews on this page: 100 Google reviews (90 with written comments).
- Owner responses: the business replied to 1% of reviews.
- Most recent review: September 15, 2025.
- Service: Real Estate Appraiser serving New York, New York.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Photos
Customer reviews
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Very smooth process. Robert was super professional and friendly, everything was provided quickly and effectively. Would recommend to anyone
Robert Bunda nice gig you got going. I don't care if this man had a1000 positive reviews. He was a disaster. ITS A SMALL ROOM he sits at his desk comparing your pieces to what's on 1st bids and other auction sites (brilliant) He also uses google images which everyone does already. You don't need him. As far as the knowledge he claimed to know he couldn't recognize the stamps on my peices and claimed there worth scrap. One pair of earings he said was worth just the small amount of gold I sold for $7000, I was going to call him on the spot but decided to leave an honest review instead. I nearly scrapped it but i met am honest man in diamond district who looked at the stamp and told me where to go to sell it. Instead I got FREE quotes in the diamond district and the brands he didn't know they did. He claimed one piece I had was valuable and to go to Bomhams. They looked at it and said I got bad advice. Another gold diamond motif brooch he said was scrap....I did scrap because he said brooches are out of style I went online to a facebook group to have them identify it for free and one person immediately recognized it. I'm afraid I lost $3000.00 because he was more interested in squeezing as much time to charge me than actually give me sound advice. I recommend you join a free face book jewelery experts page and save yourself from paying an ameture who just sits at his desk using Google and auction sites to find comparisons wich any child can do. Or just get different quotes. Telling them your not ready to sell just figuring out a ballpark value And you'll get all the free advice you need. Plus there 100× more knowledgeable with brand names and fakes. What a disaster, waste of time, waste of money And he was rushing me. For someone with such a great reputation I was shocked all he had was a computer and a Guage to size up your diamonds. I left so disappointed and more confused than when I came. Turns out all the help I needed was free right from my Facebook page I'm using now. And people in the industry....as long as you make it clear your ot selling just getting quotes. Your truly, I hope i save at least one person money or worse.....losing
We were so lucky to find Robert Bunda! He exceeded our expectations in every way. We recently inherited some jewelry that no one in the family wanted and we were having trouble getting it appraised and finding a buyer. We did a bunch of web searches and got quotes from a number of appraisers, and they were all much higher than we expected. Then we found Robert. What a refreshing discovery! He inspected the items, told us what they might be worth, and guided us through the whole process of finding a buyer and selling. Robert is an exceptional resource. He is impeccably honest, trustworthy and direct. His fees were very fair and he really seems to care.
I was in contact with the team about receiving an appraisal for a set of rings and never heard back from them after I sent in photos of the pieces. If they were not able to accommodate, a response back would have been courteous.
Robert Bunda went out of his way to help me with appraisals of watches and jewelry. I would definitely go back. Highly recommend.
Excellent experience with Robert Bunda. He responded promptly and thoroughly to my initial email inquiry and we scheduled an appointment soon thereafter. The appraisal experience was transparent, informative and interesting. Mr. Bunda took a lot of time with me explaining his methods. I received the appraisal document via email before I walked out of the office. Highly recommend.
Robert was totally clear and thorough in his appraisal, even pointing out some minor errors from my last appraisal many years ago. The appointment was easy, relaxed, and professional.
I highly recommend Robert Bunda for jewelry appraisals. I hired him to appraise about 50+ pieces of jewelry. We sat for two 1-hour sessions. He is thorough, clearly experienced, easy to deal with, generous with his time, true to his word. Thank you Mr. Bunda!
Efficient quality appraisals. Thank you!
Business details
- Address: 745 5th Ave #500, New York, NY 10151
- Phone: (212) 489-6553
- Website: nycjewelryappraisers.com
- Service area: New York, NY