Experts Reviews
Perrys Pizza logo

Perrys Pizza

4.8 ★★★★★ · 215 Google reviews · 24 photos
Pizza restaurant · Erie, PA

Perrys Pizza at a glance

Google reviewers praise the thin crust, creative toppings, and friendly service at Perrys Pizza, often highlighting the unique atmosphere and baked wings. Recurring themes include the minimalist ingredient style and reasonable pricing, though some customers find the portions small. A common criticism among lower-rated reviews is that the pizza can be undercooked, lack sufficient cheese or sauce, or arrive lukewarm, leading to disappointment regarding the value for money.

  • Google rating: 4.8 out of 5 from 215 reviews (93% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 215 Google reviews (165 with written comments, 27 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 5% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: October 18, 2026.
  • Service: Caterer serving Erie, Pennsylvania.

Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.

Photos

Customer reviews

4.8
★★★★★
215 reviews on Google
5★199
4★5
3★4
2★1
1★6

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Nicholas Mihaly6 reviews
★★★★★

Fantastic as always!

  • Order type: Take out
  • Meal type: Dinner
  • Price per person: $50–60
Review from Google · view on Google
Jake Holdsworth3 reviews
★★★★★

Best Pizza in Erie! Friendly owner and staff. Will definitely be back!

  • Order type: Dine in
  • Reservation: Reservations not required
Review from Google · view on Google
Emily Ashcraft5 reviews
★★★★★

Out of towners here. I don’t ever leave reviews but this place was the top rated in the area. Had no idea what we were ordering. Got the 14” cheese, pepperoni, honey and Hazard. Did not care for any, must be a local thing. Small, paper thin, crust tasted like cardboard.

  • Order type: Take out
  • Meal type: Dinner
  • Price per person: $60–70
Review from Google · view on Google
Kyle Ball5 reviews
★★★★★

If you’ve never tried their wings, you’re doing yourself a disservice. Absolutely incredible. Fantastic customer service and a unique atmosphere. 10/10 highly recommend the Carolina BBQ wings.

Review from Google · view on Google
T CLocal Guide · 73 reviews
★★★★★

Excellent thin crust pizza. We really liked the sauce. I love a foldable nyc type pizza. Crust was crisp but still chewy and great flavor.

Review from Google · view on Google
Bill NelsonLocal Guide · 11 reviews
★★★★★

I was hoping for a good, local, Italian pizza but this was not it. Crust was good but sauce and topping were not great.

Review from Google · view on Google
jason aguirre7 reviews
★★★★★

Perry’s is top tier if you’re into quality ingredients, flavorful tastes, and thin slice pizza. If you’re looking to pig out on regular type pizza, this aint the spot. Quality over quantity here. Regular size pizza feeds 2 or 1 if you’re really hungry. Customer service is always great and the atmosphere is colorful and inviting. Looking forward to more orders from here.

  • Order type: Take out
  • Price per person: $10–20
Review from Google · view on Google
Katherine Stankiewicz4 reviews
★★★★★

We love this place! Super high quality pizza you can’t get anywhere else in Erie. Fun toppings. KILLER caesar salad is a must try.

Review from Google · view on Google
Dale Miller4 reviews
★★★★★

First time going to Perry's Pizza. Very friendly staff and the Pizza was spot on.

  • Order type: Take out
  • Meal type: Dinner
  • Price per person: $10–20
Review from Google · view on Google
Ryan RussellLocal Guide · 46 reviews
★★★★★

Great pizza, great service, great employees. The Honey Bear pizza is just immaculate and honestly the best tasting pizza in Erie

Review from Google · view on Google

Perrys Pizza on Google Maps →

Business details