Robert Medinger, Keller Williams Preferred logo

Robert Medinger, Keller Williams Preferred

5.0 ★★★★★ · 99 Google reviews · 24 photos
Real estate agent · Orland Park, IL

Robert Medinger, Keller Williams Preferred at a glance

Google reviewers rate Robert Medinger five stars based on 99 reviews, with the owner replying to 97% of comments. Clients frequently cite his responsiveness, market knowledge, and ability to close properties quickly, often above asking price. Recurring themes include clear communication, efficient handling of buying and selling processes, and effective marketing strategies. No significant criticisms appear in the provided excerpts, as all available reviews are positive.

  • Google rating: 5.0 out of 5 from 99 reviews (100% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 99 Google reviews (99 with written comments, 5 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 97% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: October 21, 2026.
  • Service: Real Estate Agent serving Orland Park, Illinois.

Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.

Photos

Customer reviews

5.0
★★★★★
99 reviews on Google
5★99
4★0
3★0
2★0
1★0

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Sarah Whicher7 reviews
★★★★★

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars – Rob Medinger Is Absolutely Amazing! We cannot say enough wonderful things about Rob Medinger! From beginning to end, Rob went above and beyond to help us find the perfect home for our family. Buying a home is such a huge milestone, and with our move to Indiana, there were plenty of stressful moments along the way. But Rob was there every step of the process, answering questions, offering guidance, reassuring us, and making sure everything went as smoothly as possible. What truly sets Rob apart is that he genuinely cares about the families he works with. We never felt like just another transaction. He was patient, honest, knowledgeable, and dedicated to helping us find a place we could truly call home. Thanks to Rob, we are now settling into our beautiful home on seven acres in Hobart, where our family can grow, make memories, and begin an exciting new chapter of our lives. We are so incredibly grateful for all of his hard work, kindness, and dedication. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, Rob Medinger is the person you want by your side! Thank you, Rob, for helping make our dream a reality. Five stars simply aren't enough! ❤️🏡

  • Ease of reaching staff: Very easy
Response from the owner · 3 days ago

Thank you so much for the kind words, Sarah! I really enjoyed being your Realtor and helping your family find your new home in Hobart, Indiana. I know there were some stressful moments along the way, and I’m glad I could help make the move a little bit easier for the family. Knowing you felt supported throughout the process means a lot to me. Enjoy that beautiful home and all seven acres! I appreciate your trust and the recommendation. Please keep in touch, and know I’m always happy to help. Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
Ben Holleman5 reviews
★★★★★

Rob was fantastic in helping our son find and purchase his first condo in Chicago. He was knowledgeable, responsive, patient, and always willing to answer questions and walk us through the process. He made what could have been a stressful experience much easier and helped our son find a place that was a great fit. We really appreciated Rob’s professionalism and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a realtor!

  • Ease of reaching staff: Very easy
Response from the owner · 3 days ago

Ben, it was my pleasure working with you and your family to help Benson buy his first condo in Chicago! There’s a lot to work through with a condo purchase, and I’m glad I could help answer your questions and make things easier along the way. I appreciate your trust and the recommendation! I hope he’s enjoying his new place, and please reach out anytime if you need anything! Keep in touch and thanks again, Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
April Balough1 review
★★★★★

Rob was absolutely amazing! He was able to get my property listed very quickly with an extremely fast closing time. He was a pleasure to work with and was able to answer all of my questions. We received many offers and closed over asking price!!! I am very Impressed and will definitely use Rob in the future!

  • Ease of reaching staff: Very easy
Response from the owner · 3 days ago

Thank you, April! Getting multiple offers and closing above asking price is always a lot of fun, and I’m glad we were able to make it happen so quickly! I really enjoyed working with you and appreciate you trusting me to sell your property. I’d be happy to help again anytime! And I am looking forward to your next purchase which we are working on! :) See you soon, Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
BadBeagleSoapCo5 reviews
★★★★★

I was referred to Robert by a mutual friend. Ironically met him twice before we even discussed putting our home up for sale. He made the process so easy. Complete walk through on what to expect, the process and finally the closing. He came to the house and within a few hours I knew that he was the only one I wanted to work with, he knew his business inside and out. Everything he told me happened exactly as he said it would. In this world and time we live in every dollar matters, Robert did everything to get us the most out of our sale. We listed on a Wednesday night, Thursday we had 5 showings, Friday we had 6. By Saturday we had several offers already come in and an additional 6-7 showings. Sunday there were more offers and more showings! Monday came and more offers. Bidding war began and Robert looked out for our best interest and guided us appropriately. Thank you for everything. You helped my family start on a new journey.

Response from the owner · 3 days ago

Thank you for such a thoughtful review, Patrick! I’m so happy that we connected at the benefit a while back, and that we had the chance to get to know each other before listing your home. Those first few days on the market certainly kept us busy! It was great to see all that interest, and I’m glad I could help you work through the offers and make the most of your home sale. I appreciate the trust you put in me from the start as your Realtor. Wishing you and Melissa all the best with what’s ahead in your news home state! Cheers, Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
Nestor Rodriguez3 reviews
★★★★★

Rob did an exceptional job, you can tell he loves doing what he does and with tons of experience. As a first time buyer I had a previous agent and was very stressful and felt as if I was stuck in the mud. So I went in search of someone else to help me and Rob showed how’s it’s supposed to be done. Great communication, bunch of listings, very prompt quick and efficient with his work. In this market today, we got out bid the first time but second time around got a deal in Minooka. His team was very helpful. I will definitely be going to Rob again in the future.

Response from the owner · a month ago

Thank you so much for the thoughtful review and for trusting me to help you and Lorena through your first home purchase, Nestor! I know how stressful buying a home can feel, especially as a first-time home buyer in a competitive market, so I’m really glad we were able to turn the experience around and make the process smoother for you. It was a pleasure being your buyer’s agent and helping you navigate the search, showings, negotiations, and ultimately secure a great deal on your new home in Minooka, Illinois. Getting outbid on the first one was disappointing, but you stayed patient and we kept moving until we found the right opportunity! Congratulations again on your new home, and thank you for the recommendation. I truly appreciate it, and I look forward to helping you with any future Illinois real estate needs! Keep in touch, Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
Shirley Mobley-WebbLocal Guide · 73 reviews
★★★★★

I was referred to Rob by a realtor I typically work with, as I was looking to purchase in Indiana and she wasn’t licensed there. She assured me that Rob had extensive industry experience and would be able to get the job done and she was absolutely right. From the very first conversation, Rob took the time to sit down with me, understand my goals, and get clear on the type of investment property I wanted to add to my portfolio. He provided a wealth of information throughout the process, making sure I had everything I needed to make confident decisions. When an unexpected issue came up with my financer, Rob didn’t miss a beat. He stepped in, helped turn the situation around, and connected me with someone who was able to secure financing for me even faster. Rob also negotiated a $4,000 credit and saved me an additional $10,000 off the purchase price something I truly appreciated as an investor. If you’re looking for an agent with deep knowledge, strong experience, and a genuine commitment to his clients, do not hesitate to contact Rob.

Response from the owner · a month ago

Thank you so much for the incredible review and for trusting me with your investment property purchase, Shirley! As an Indiana buyer’s agent and real estate investor myself, I understand how important it is to look beyond simply finding a property and make sure the numbers, financing, condition, and overall investment make sense. It was a pleasure helping you find and purchase your investment property in Hammond, Indiana. I’m especially glad we were able to work through the unexpected financing issue, keep the transaction moving, and negotiate an additional $10,000 off the purchase price plus a $4,000 seller credit. Those savings can make a meaningful difference when building a real estate portfolio. Thank you again for the recommendation and for allowing me to be part of the process. I look forward to helping you continue growing your investment portfolio in Hammond and throughout Northwest Indiana! Keep in touch, Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
Melissa Staples11 reviews
★★★★★

I have worked with many realtors over the years, and no one has impressed me more than Rob! He undoubtedly went above and beyond with advertising our home via numerous social media sites, using a professional photographer to take exceptional photographs along with drone footage. Rob was super responsive 24-7 to our many questions throughout the process and even provided us with a timeline of each aspect of getting to closing day. Thanks to Rob and his hands on professionalism, we had multiple offers and sold our house in West Town (Chicago) for $175k over asking. There is a reason he is one of the top realtors in his field! Use Rob! You won't be disappointed! Thanks Rob!

Response from the owner · 2 months ago

Melissa, Thank you so much for this incredible review and for trusting me to sell your home in West Town, Chicago! It was truly a pleasure working with you throughout the entire home-selling process. Your amazing property deserved a comprehensive marketing strategy to show off how beautiful it truly was, so I was proud to showcase it through professional real estate photography, drone footage, targeted social media advertising, and extensive online exposure. I am thrilled that our strategy generated multiple offers and ultimately helped you sell your West Town home for $175,000 over the asking price! This is something I am very proud of, and I am so happy for you both that I was able to get you over asking price in a matter of days! Clear communication and careful preparation are extremely important to me. I am glad the customized transaction timeline, consistent updates, and hands-on guidance helped make the process easier to understand as we moved from listing preparation and showings through contract negotiations and closing day. Thank you again for recommending me as a impressive Chicago Realtor and a great real estate agent. Helping homeowners successfully market and sell their properties for the strongest possible price is one of the most rewarding parts of my business! I truly appreciate your confidence, your kind words, and the opportunity to represent you! Good luck in the future and keep in touch! Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
Michael Fritsch2 reviews
★★★★★

Rob is a great realtor to work with. He knows the Oak Lawn area very well and has a great marketing campaign to draw attention to the home. Everything happened on time from the staging of the house, to the pictures, to the day it went on the market. We had several offers within a few days of the house being on the market and a contract within 4 days! The winning offer was over the asking price as well. It was very easy to communicate with Rob and he is very responsive to requests and questions. He also suggested a real estate attorney to represent us which also went great. The whole process of listing to closing took only 30 days! -Update 2026 Rob has helped me sell another house in Crestwood and the experience the second time was better than the first! I think the key is Rob's ability to accurately set the listing price and to get people in the door. The neighbors could not believe how many people came through the house! (Over 20 showings the first weekend!) The showings led to a bidding war with multiple bids and the house ended up selling for over list price. Thank you Rob!

Response from the owner · 2 years ago

Mike - thank you so much for your review! It was great to reconnect and I am happy that we were able to get your Parents full price for their house in Oak Lawn! Keep in touch and Happy New Year to the entire family! Rob

Review from Google · view on Google
The Perez familyLocal Guide · 14 reviews
★★★★★

As first-time homebuyers, we had a long journey finding the right home, and Robert helped us navigate the process from start to finish. We were introduced to him through his brother, Matthew, who handled our mortgage, and we also had a family member who had worked with him before. We looked at several different areas before ultimately settling on Oak Forest. Throughout the process, Robert was responsive, easy to get ahold of, and kept us informed every step of the way. Even when he was busy, he always made time to answer our questions and schedule showings. What we appreciated most was his honesty. Robert is straightforward and gives his honest opinion, which was especially helpful as first-time buyers learning the market. When we found the house we wanted, he helped negotiate a significant seller credit for repairs on an AS-IS property and guided us through a multiple-offer situation that ultimately worked out in our favor. He was also a good resource for recommendations on inspectors, contractors, and other services we needed during the process. In addition, he shared helpful advice about homeownership and real estate investing. Overall, we had a positive experience working with Robert and would recommend him to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and hardworking real estate agent.

Response from the owner · 3 months ago

Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! It was truly a pleasure helping you both purchase your first home, and I’m honored that Matthew’s recommendation and your family’s trust led us to work together. Helping first-time home buyers is one of the most rewarding parts of being a Realtor. I’m glad we took the time to explore different communities before finding the right home in Oak Forest. Every buyer’s situation is unique, and my goal is always to provide honest advice, clear communication, and the information my clients need to make confident decisions throughout the home buying process. I’m especially happy we were able to successfully navigate the multiple-offer situation and negotiate a substantial seller credit, even on an AS-IS property. Protecting my clients’ interests during negotiations is something I take great pride in, and I’m thrilled everything came together so well for you. Thank you as well for mentioning my recommendations for inspectors, contractors, and other professionals. I believe my job as a real estate agent doesn’t end with finding the right house. Whether it’s answering questions about homeownership, sharing real estate investing advice, or helping clients prepare for life after closing, I’m always happy to be a long-term resource. Congratulations again on becoming homeowners! Thank you for trusting me with such an important milestone and for recommending me to others looking to buy a home in Oak Forest, the Chicago South Suburbs, or Northwest Indiana. It means more than you know, and I’ll always be here whenever you need anything in the future. 😃

Review from Google · view on Google
Real Region Rentals1 review
★★★★★

Sharing the success of my second investment property purchase with Rob Medinger. First home I purchased with Rob is absolutely crushing it and so I went back to Rob Medinger Realtor to help with my second investment. Here’s to many many more. Thanks Rob! Easy process.

Response from the owner · 3 months ago

Thank you so much for your continued trust! It has been a pleasure helping you purchase not just one, but now two investment properties. Seeing your first investment perform so well makes this second purchase even more exciting, and I’m grateful you chose me again to help you grow your real estate portfolio. Working with real estate investors is something I truly enjoy because every investment property requires careful analysis, strong negotiation, and a long-term strategy. My goal is always to help my clients identify opportunities that align with their financial goals while making the buying process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Thank you for your confidence in me and for allowing me to be part of your real estate investing journey. I sincerely appreciate your business and look forward to helping you purchase many more investment properties in the years ahead. Congratulations again, and here’s to continued success with your growing real estate portfolio!

Review from Google · view on Google

Robert Medinger, Keller Williams Preferred on Google Maps →

Business details