Customers frequently praise the store's eclectic selection of vintage antiques, furniture, and decor, noting that staff are helpful and willing to negotiate prices. However, a recurring criticism involves the business being closed during posted hours, with no answer to phone calls, causing visitors to waste trips. Some reviewers also find the pricing inconsistent or high, while others appreciate the fair costs and unique items available in this booth rental setup.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
There is definitely treasure to be found here, but most items don’t have prices, and the pricing they gave verbally was all over the place. Very nice staff, but budget time to track someone down for pricing.
Drove very far out of my way to go here and they were closed during business hours. They ought to just remove their business hours and say “open randomly” because there’s truly no way to know if you’re going to waste your time or not by trying to visit Sandfly. I have heard from many people that they no longer even try to visit because of how rarely they happen to be open.
2nd time making the drive all the way here during posted business hours and they are closed. No one answers the phone number listed either.
When does this store open? WHO KNOWS! online says 11, showed up at 11:45 nobody there. Sign says 11 or 12-ish maybe, if lights are on I’m here. Waited for over half an hour, no one showed up. How on earth are you supposed to go antiquing if the owner doesn’t even wanna show up?
Great place to visit to find vintage antiques and more!
Great selection of all sorts of vintage and antique items. I got some nice vintage license plates for my collection and can't wait to hang them on the wall. The staff is also very friendly and helpful!
Just amazed at what was inside never know what you're going to find inside if you're in the area it's worth stopping by you may find something that you can't live without
Nice clean place bit pricey in some vendors booths but great place to find marked wrong antiques.
Great selection of furniture, decor, and other items with very fair pricing. The owners are very kind, and went above and beyond helping to load things into my car.
This was a great place with fair prices. The staff (Amber) was very nice and helpful! Also, bonus there is a seriously cute, fat, and sweet cat named George! Really enjoyed this visit!