Analyzing 5,408,2915.4M ReviewsFor 14,54914.5K Experts
Reviewers frequently praise the store's extensive, well-organized vinyl collection spanning diverse genres and note reasonable pricing. Customers often highlight the welcoming atmosphere, knowledgeable staff, and helpful service when browsing or purchasing records. However, several low-star reviews criticize the staff for being unwelcoming, unresponsive, or hostile, particularly regarding interactions with customers seeking assistance or selling records.
Data from Google, last updated October 27, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We read 155 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“Top address, incredibly fair prices, and a very friendly owner.”
“When we asked for help with the vinyl player, we got no words — just a rude gesture to move aside.”
“This was our favorite , great vibe , music selection, people and prices were reasonable .”
“If you're in the area or just looking to buy some records, I'd highly recommend visiting this spot for good conversation and great finds!”
“proper selection of used House gems and amazing service!”
“They were responsive, timely, and professional at all times.”
“I had a great experience communicating with Second Hand Records NYC.”
“Honest and good staff.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Top Adresse, enorm faire Preise und ein sehr sympathischer Besitzer. Absolut empfehlenswert.
Dope shop!
Great finds and an extensive collection. The cashier was kind and helpful. Love how each section is broken into specific genres. Don't records even had post it's with suggestions on them which was helpful. Would you again!
Why does it seem like the handful of minorities that have visited this store received the 💩-iest service? I have three crates of records to sell but based on some of these reviews I’d probably be better taking my business elsewhere.
Hello wst u waiting for
Great place for vinyl, very peaceful environment and owner is knowledgeable.
I always make a point to visit when I'm in the city... best shop around~~
Best people, incredible records, lot of love poured into this space and it’s always a treat to spend a day digging there :) 10 stars
proper selection of used House gems and amazing service! A+++
best record store i’ve been to ever
Analyzing 5,408,2915.4M ReviewsFor 14,54914.5K Experts