Analyzing 5,890,1035.9M ReviewsFor 16,26616.3K Experts
Google reviewers rate Skyline Catering 4.9 out of 5 based on 81 reviews, noting that the owner replied to 65 percent of them. Customers frequently praise the punctuality, communication, and professional staff during events such as weddings, corporate lunches, and reunions. The food is described as delicious with strong options for dietary restrictions, while pricing is considered competitive. One low-star review criticized specific items, mentioning dry sandwiches, chewy meat, and poor bread quality.
Data from Google, last updated October 28, 2026.
Score per factor (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: craft & service and value; weakest: momentum.
Bar = this company · dark tick = category median.
81 Google reviews we collected
Phrases our text analysis found in 75 written reviews
How often each topic comes up in the written reviews
We read 75 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“And the staff that did drop-off/setup and pickup were smooth and efficient, we didn't have to do anything.”
“The people at Skyline were all great, super helpful, and professional.”
“We definitely recommend them to anyone planning an event in Milwaukee.”
“Andrea and Elyse handled all the logistics with such professionalism and attention to detail that it gave me complete peace of mind.”
“Offerings from menus were exactly as described, reasonably prices and service was great.”
“They were always responsive, providing clear and timely communication, which made the entire planning process a breeze.”
“Skyline Catering is incredibly dependable, fast, and one of the best companies I have worked with.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
My family had a catered lunch. It was delicious and the vegan boxed lunch was amazing.
The bread was terrible. Roast beef was chewy chips were very scarce sandwich was dry. Cookie tastes like grains in the sandwich. I’m aggravated.
Skyline Catering was amazing! They were able to accommodate us at the last minute. The staff helped us put together the perfect menu for our pub birthday party. The delivery was right on time and seamless. Most importantly everyone raved about the food especially the chicken fingers. Highly recommend Skyline Catering!
We used Skyline Catering for our wedding last weekend and we were very impressed. We decided on a large appetizer spread - instead of dinner - for our cocktail party wedding, and Skyline delivered with three huge tables of charcuterie, veggies, and both cold and hot appetizers. Our guests are still commenting on…
I cannot emphasize enough how much I adore Skyline Catering! I order from them fairly frequently for work events and they have never disappointed! The food is always fantastic (we have tried many options!); the staff is always so friendly, helpful, and professional; the delivery and set-up are always seamless & on…
They catered my daughters baby shower brunch and it was a huge success, everyone commented how the wonderful the setup and appearance was but also the food was delicious! everyone went back 2 or 3 times. The staff is so helpful and so kind and helpful! My son is also using them for his wedding in November! Thank you…
4.9 ★★★★★ 81 reviews on Google · rating breakdown
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Love the Greek chicken wrap! So much food and so delicious!!
Thank you Kim! We are really happy that love the Greek chicken wrap! Thank you for leaving a review! Ernie
My family had a catered lunch. It was delicious and the vegan boxed lunch was amazing.
Thank you Lauren! We are very happy to hear that you had a great experience with Skyline catering! We appreciate that you took the time to write a review!! Ernie
The bread was terrible. Roast beef was chewy chips were very scarce sandwich was dry. Cookie tastes like grains in the sandwich. I’m aggravated.
Thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear that your lunch didn't meet expectations. We take a lot of pride in the quality of our food, so it's disappointing to hear that the sandwich, chips and cookie were not up to our standards. We'd love the opportunity to make this right! Please reach out to us directly and we'd be happy to provide you with a complimentary lunch and learn more about your experience. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention.
Skyline Catering was amazing! They were able to accommodate us at the last minute. The staff helped us put together the perfect menu for our pub birthday party. The delivery was right on time and seamless. Most importantly everyone raved about the food especially the chicken fingers. Highly recommend Skyline Catering!
Hi Suzanne, Thank you so much for the glowing review! We were so happy to be able to help you out with this event. We will be sure to pass these kind words onto the team members who helped make your order possible. Please reach out if you are ever in the area and in need of our services in the future! - Elyse, Ernie and the Skyline Catering team
We used Skyline Catering for our wedding last weekend and we were very impressed. We decided on a large appetizer spread - instead of dinner - for our cocktail party wedding, and Skyline delivered with three huge tables of charcuterie, veggies, and both cold and hot appetizers. Our guests are still commenting on the great food! The people at Skyline were all great, super helpful, and professional. They helped us pick the perfect array of food and calculate the amounts needed. And the staff that did drop-off/setup and pickup were smooth and efficient, we didn't have to do anything. We definitely recommend them to anyone planning an event in Milwaukee. Thank you again for helping us celebrate!
Hi Mallory, Thank you so much for the kind review! We were so happy to be able to play a part in your big day and are glad it went beautifully for you. Congratulations on your marriage, we wish you both the best! - Elyse, Ernie and the Skyline Catering team
From the minute our family met Ernie and Elyse you could tell they were the real deal with a first class venue . As hard as I try to write a review that expresses our gratitude for such an exceptional wedding reception I am not sure it will be sufficient. Our daughter Abby and her new husband Jake decided on the Bucyrus Club over two years in advance knowing it would be just the perfect place. The Bucyrus club offered all of their guests something. The extra special museum on the second floor that can be seen by all guests because the elevator if needed. The unique vintage architecture of the 1893 ballroom and the founder's room each with its own bar was just the right place for the guests to get acquainted once they started arriving from the church. The Grand ballroom all so provided a classic old time industrial feel which everyone enjoyed. With the multiple rooms their guests and relatives could dance to louder music or move to the founder's room or the 1893 ballroom to converse or catch up on old times. Not sure if Abby and Jake received more compliments on the dinner , the staff or the building. I truly wish we could give them 10 stars because that’s what Ernie , Elyse and the rest of the Bucyrus Club really deserves!
I cannot emphasize enough how much I adore Skyline Catering! I order from them fairly frequently for work events and they have never disappointed! The food is always fantastic (we have tried many options!); the staff is always so friendly, helpful, and professional; the delivery and set-up are always seamless & on time; they have great vegan/vegetarian/gluten free options...I could keep going! I occasionally make last minute and specific requests, and they are so accommodating and kind. We use them for casual lunches & for more fancy appetizers/meals, and they have consistently been fantastic. My coworkers always compliment the food and options. They even utilize reusable serving dishes and utensils that align with my company's waste management goals! I will never stop recommending Skyline to coworkers and friends :)
Flannery! Thank you so much for your incredibly kind words! Serving you and your team is truly a joy for all of us at Skyline. Clients like you make what we do so rewarding. We love being a part of your events whether it’s big or small and we’re so happy to hear that the food, service, and eco friendly touches make a difference for your team. Thank you for always being such a wonderful partner to work with! We look forward to our continued relationship with you and everyone over at the company you work with. (: - Elyse, Ernie and the Skyline team!
They catered my daughters baby shower brunch and it was a huge success, everyone commented how the wonderful the setup and appearance was but also the food was delicious! everyone went back 2 or 3 times. The staff is so helpful and so kind and helpful! My son is also using them for his wedding in November! Thank you for making this family's special days very special!!
Pattie, Thank you so much for the glowing review! We are so happy with how wonderful everything turned out on Sunday for you. It has been great getting to know your family and we truly look forward to being a part of creating another unforgettable experience for you at the wedding in November! Elyse & Ernie
Skyline Catering: A Seamless and Delicious Experience! From the moment I started planning my event, Skyline Catering was nothing short of exceptional. Andrea and Elyse handled all the logistics with such professionalism and attention to detail that it gave me complete peace of mind. They were always responsive, providing clear and timely communication, which made the entire planning process a breeze. On the day of the event, Michaela and Tegan were absolutely amazing. They were not only super helpful but also seemed to read my mind, anticipating my needs before I even had to ask. Despite the venue lacking a kitchen, they managed to make everything run so smoothly that their presence was barely noticeable. The food was absolutely incredible—fresh and delicious, as if it had just come straight out of a top-notch kitchen. What truly impressed me was their efficiency in cleaning up. They were in and out so quickly that the venue was left spotless, and I hardly noticed they were there. Their professionalism and dedication to ensuring a flawless event were truly outstanding. I cannot recommend Skyline Catering highly enough! They went above and beyond to make my event a success, and I will definitely be using their services again in the future. Hired for a Johnson Financial Group 130 person corporate event back on September 2024.
Michelle, Thank you so much for your thoughtful and glowing review! We’re thrilled to hear about your positive experience with Skyline Catering. We take pride in ensuring every detail is covered during the planning process, so it’s wonderful to know our efforts from Andrea & I brought you peace of mind. Michaela and Tegan will be delighted to hear your kind words about their work on the day of your event—anticipating needs and creating a seamless experience, even in a venue without a kitchen, is a skill they’ve perfected. We’re so glad the food was a hit and that the cleanup was swift and unobtrusive. Our team is dedicated to delivering top-notch service from start to finish, and it’s incredibly rewarding to know we exceeded your expectations. It was a pleasure catering your Johnson Financial Group event, and we’re honored to have been part of its success. Thank you again for trusting Skyline Catering, and we look forward to working with you on future events!
Skyline Catering is incredibly dependable, fast, and one of the best companies I have worked with. Their customer service is phenomenal, I work with Ernie and Elyse on a regular basis for work. They constantly impress me with how quickly they respond, and always deliver very high quality products. I would HIGHLY suggest them for any catering needs that you have!
Jacob, I can't tell you how much your review means to us here at Skyline! As you know, we do not outwardly ask our clients for reviews, but when they happen, it is very special. Our relationship with your company has been great over the last year or so and we truly look forward to any request or challenge that you send our way! Thanks again, Jacob!! Ernie & the Skyline crew
Analyzing 5,890,1035.9M ReviewsFor 16,26616.3K Experts
