Google reviewers rate Stella's Tap 4.6 out of 5 based on 142 reviews, describing it as a classic Chicago dive bar with a retro atmosphere, pool table, and dog-friendly policy. Customers frequently praise the friendly staff and casual vibe, noting that the establishment accepts cash only. A recurring criticism in lower-rated reviews concerns high drink prices, with one patron specifically noting that a can of beer costs five dollars while a bottle costs three.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Classic Chicago dive. Cash only. No notes.
The sweetest girl I've ever met, if you are looking for a quiet cocktail this is your place, 🥰
Bartender was a really nice older woman. Loved the bar. Great place to toss darts or shoot some pool. The honey liqueur was delicious Cash only
The dimly lit room has a great retro feel, with plenty of booths for conversation. We managed to snag one, though it felt a bit cramped for two. Still, the drinks were good, and the atmosphere perfect for a date night escape.
I love Stella and her bar! Perfect spot for eating peanuts, drinking beer, and playing games with friends :)
Just Go. Bring Cash. No Cards.
the monday nights are my favorite. if you’re t4t come through
Stevie was super nice! Drinks were way too expensive
The best people 💖
Perfect dive bar experience, super chill vibe