Sweet and Savory Catering logo

Sweet and Savory Catering

4.9 ★★★★★ · 147 Google reviews · 24 photos
Caterer · Noblesville, IN

Sweet and Savory Catering at a glance

Google reviewers rate Sweet and Savory Catering 4.9 out of 5 based on 147 reviews, frequently praising the quality of food, professional service, and smooth planning processes for weddings and other events. Customers often highlight the staff's kindness, flexibility with dietary needs, and reasonable pricing compared to other vendors. However, a small number of low-star reviews cite poor communication as a recurring issue, specifically noting delayed responses to emails and phone inquiries regarding quotes and availability.

  • Google rating: 4.9 out of 5 from 147 reviews (95% five-star).
  • Reviews on this page: 147 Google reviews (136 with written comments, 11 with photos).
  • Owner responses: the business replied to 26% of reviews.
  • Most recent review: October 25, 2026.
  • Service: Caterer serving Noblesville, Indiana.

Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.

Photos

Customer reviews

4.9
★★★★★
147 reviews on Google
5★139
4★3
3★1
2★0
1★4

Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).

Dominic Desalvo
★★★★★

Greet food, great planning, great people. Would recommend for any event

Review from Google · view on Google
Siera Stuart
★★★★★

We had SUCH a positive experience with Sweet and Savory for our wedding! We had a poutine and taco station, and the food was absolutely delicious. So many of our guests told us how unique and awesome the food was. It was a huge hit! The planning process was smooth and stress-free, and their wait staff was awesome. They even brought us a plate of our cocktail hour appetizers, which was such a thoughtful touch. Sweet and Savory truly made our wedding night so memorable. We couldn’t recommend them more!

Review from Google · view on Google
Valerie Priar3 reviews
★★★★★

My husband and I are so thankful for the S&S team. They were kind, accommodating, and easy to work with. I want to give a shout out to Amanda with the day of staff and Jade with the planning staff for their exceptional service. They helped make our day special and simple. Food was delish with several guests raving about the menu. Everyone’s food came out hot and the buffets went smoothly. 1000/10 experience. Thank you S&S

Review from Google · view on Google
Kim Scheid1 review
★★★★★

Sweet and Savory was an absolute pleasure to work with as always. They have been our caterer for all three of our children's weddings at three different venues! That should say something when we kept coming back. They are very reasonably priced as compared to other vendors. All of the guests raved about the food especially the appetizers! My son's bride wanted an international theme and they were more than able to accommodate her special request. They also wanted gelato served which they hadn't done before. They went above and beyond to make that happen from the kids' favorite Gelato place in Indy. Everything was easy and smooth....we are so grateful. It is a blessing to have a vendor that you don't have to worry about! They were also familiar with the Sixpence venue. They were just wonderful and flexible!!

Review from Google · view on Google
RussellTheBrand6 reviews
★★★★★

Had such a wonderful experience with Sweet and Savory! The food was great, service and communication was fabulous and the servers were so kind.

Review from Google · view on Google
Bob KobekLocal Guide · 29 reviews
★★★★★

One phone call, 3 emails later and it was done. The food was excellent and was exceeded by how easy it was to do business with this group.

Review from Google · view on Google
Allison HeinigerLocal Guide · 11 reviews
★★★★★

Sweet & Savory was an amazing addition to our wedding and rehearsal at Westwood. I had so many people tell me about how much they loved the food and how amazing the service was. Cheryl was our team lead and she was so attentive with our needs and our guests’ needs. Constantly checking in and making sure everything was going smoothly. I appreciate their dedication and commitment to making our day truly special. I would absolutely recommend them for any wedding or catering event because the staff goes above and beyond.

Review from Google · view on Google
Allie Stiffler9 reviews
★★★★★

We booked Sweet and Savory for the catering for our wedding and we loved it. We did a few of their stations (Indian, paella, and poutine)and had an around the world dinner theme, all of our guest loved it and commented on how unique it was. I am also vegan so I was very adamant on having vegan options at all of the stations and the vegan options were super yummy. If you need dietary accommodations they are insanely helpful and willing to work with you.

Review from Google · view on Google
Tia Echols3 reviews
★★★★★

Spent months looking for cater for our wedding. We’re really excited about sweet n savory because they appetizers we loved !!! I emailed trying get bar packages options. Waited week no response. Then I put inquiry website assuming they have full inbox still 3 days later no response. I decided send text then realized it 3rd attempt on communication with them decided they have poor communication and wasn’t worth the thousands dollars we were spend. Could simply as having it on website. Clear they need more staff or better structure in place we will be passing for our wedding date I wlll searching new cater. Updated : the receptionist never spoke she left voicemail I didn’t see till later .By I was updating my fiancé the overall situation starting new cater stating new budget dealing with our toddler. Looking at new catering . I did in send email that on their website. copy & pasted from website . I sent review that’s when I finally got response. Overall I never got experience like this is we’re considering coming back over but the fact family straight to defense overall then not sure cut off phone off or blocked . They also assumed based off my review I don’t wanted bar service only when I never stated this we ask for full service. I wouldn’t recommend after this experience was stressful liked we loved food but hopefully someone else will have better experience then we did I left email below.

Response from the owner · Edited 2 months ago

Hello! Just checked with our receptionist, as she is very responsive- just checking to see what happened, and we have one website submission from yesterday (not 3 days ago) and a text from about an hour or so ago. She said she spoke to you about 30 mins ago. We have no emails from the one you provided other than the website submission, so could you have sent it to the wrong email? We are happy to help in any way we can, and getting a 1 star review is pretty alarming for us, as we really pride ourselves on our service. Edit- The screenshot you added is not our email. Our email is: [email protected], not [email protected] that you sent this to. I believe she assumed you were looking for bar service because we never received this email. I hope you understand the concern in receiving a public negative review for not responding to correspondence that we never received. We are of course going to look into it to try and figure out why you did not receive a response. We hope you find the perfect fit for you.

Review from Google · view on Google
Makenzie Gillam6 reviews
★★★★★

We went through Sweet and Savory Catering for our July 2026 wedding and it was an amazing experience! All staff that we encountered were helpful, professional, and very friendly. Emails were responded to in a timely manner for the most part! On our wedding day, everything was set up beautifully. The food tasted great, and we have only heard positive feedback from all of our guests about the food! We decided to do the Italian buffet! A couple of staff members even carried my husband and I’s plates up to the buffet and plated our meals for us which was so sweet! Overall they were awesome and I would recommend them over and over for all catering needs! 😊

Review from Google · view on Google

Sweet and Savory Catering on Google Maps →

Business details