Google reviewers rate The Nicotra Law Firm, PC 4.9 out of 5 based on 277 reviews, noting that the owner responds to 78% of feedback. Clients frequently describe the staff as professional, helpful, and communicative, often citing successful case resolutions for motorcycle and other personal injury accidents. However, a few low-star reviews criticize the firm for unprofessional conduct, specifically alleging delays in releasing client files and engaging in aggressive outreach or spamming.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
The Nicotra Law Firm was incredibly helpful and very supportive with everything that I went through and my case involved. I appreciate absolutely everything they had done for me and overall I had a great experience with them!
We really appreciate this, Hannah! Thank you for trusting our team and taking the time to share your experience.
Absolutely the worst law firm! I couldn't begin to tell you how unprofessional this place is. I believe they bought their reviews from AI.
We stand behind our team and the care we put into our work. We do not need to buy reviews or make them up, and we do neither. Our firm is not the right fit for everyone. We treat people with respect, and we expect the same respect for our attorneys and staff. Professional obligations prevent us from discussing specific details in this public forum.
Has been a great team since day one I was a terrible client, but they stuck with me through and through. They have an amazing team. They will make sure they reach out to me. I was hard to reach for a little while and they called my doctor. Highly recommend
Thank you for trusting our firm with your claim. We will always be here for you if you need us!
Great lawyers and very helpful staff. Friendly and professional. Highly recommended.
Thank you for the wonderful review, Dave! We really appreciate your kind words about our lawyers and staff. Thank you for recommending us!
I highly recommend this is my overall favorite law firm they are very helpful & never left me unsatisfied with their services to me & my family at hard times never they never gave up on me and that why Nicotra law is my favorite place 10 out of 10 highly recommend where ever you are !
This means so much to us! Thank you for trusting us and for recommending us to others. We truly appreciate you, Georia!
Was very helpful and understanding
Thank you, Olivia. We're glad we could help and appreciate you taking a moment to leave a review.
This Guy and his staff are Great right there with how top dog songs make you feel somebody did you wrong call Nicotra’s Law
Thanks Andreia ! Love your review and taking the time to share your experience with our firm and your injury accident. Thank you and your family for continuing to trust us over the years. We are still always here for you if you need us or have any questions.
Great law firm everyone is very helpful I really appreciate them for helping me with my case it was very difficult case but they got it done for me and I will forever be grateful
Thank you for trusting our team through a challenging situation, Barbara! Seeing you come out the other side made all the hard work worthwhile, and we're truly grateful for your kind words.
Good service. Built good relationship through constant communication. Happy with result. Will stay in touch. highly recommended.
It was a privilege to represent you. We appreciate your kind words and look forward to being a resource for you whenever you need us in the future.
Mr.Rick Nicotra was the best to work with, handled my case very professionally and I had zero issues working with these people.
Thank you for the thoughtful review. It was a pleasure getting to know you, and we're grateful we could help you navigate this chapter with confidence.