Analyzing 5,468,0865.5M ReviewsFor 14,73714.7K Experts
Google reviewers rate Thrifty Treasures 4.5 out of 5 based on 110 reviews, with the owner replying to 8% of them. Customers frequently describe the store as spacious with a wide variety of vintage clothing, jewelry, and household items at fair prices, often noting ongoing sales. The owner is repeatedly characterized as friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. However, several low-star reviews highlight recurring issues with inaccurate posted operating hours, specifically regarding early closures or closed days, as well as a complaint about a non-refundable deposit on a held item.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
We read 63 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“She was very patient with my gold buying wheeling and dealing boyfriend too.”
“Prices are fair, not to mention that she's ALWAYS running a sale of some sort, plus a loyalty program!”
“Great service and awesome prices!”
“…has a heart of gold that is not just out for the almighty dollar she honestly wants to know every one of her customers and the stories behind them I…”
“10/10 recommend.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
We're from out of town, and like to find the local thrift store wherever we go. This place was a great find! It's huge with a great selection of clothes, jewelry and hostility household items. Very friendly service too.
Was told I could donate certain day and time. Showed up, nobody there, store closed, door locked, sign off, yet it says there hours are til 4, it was only 3:30.
We were lucky to stumble upon the treasure trove of a vintage goods thrift store. Her vintage clothing selection was incredible, the prices were amazing AND it happened to be a half off sale. What?! She was very patient with my gold buying wheeling and dealing boyfriend too. I’m still thinking of a vintage 80s wedding gown I saw there. Should have bought it. Think she’d stuff it in a box and mail it for me? 🤩 We live in Madison but will surely be back to this gem. Mandatory stop.
Says it’s open on Mondays at 10 am, drove 20 minutes to come check it out only to have it say closed Mondays. Very disappointing
Didn't find anything i needed But good variety
Great place to shop
Thank you so much!
One of the cutest shops in our area! Always a joy to stop at.
I absolutely loved this place. Such a big collection of new and old. THe lady who ran it was excellent. I bought one of her pieces of art and I am so excited to display it. I will be back for sure when I am in the area.
Thank you so much for your kind words! Look forward to seeing you next time your in town!
Such a charming and surprisingly huge place! Tons of stuff, and a lot of hidden gems - from handmade to high fashion brands. Ruth is the real treasure, though - extremely helpful and knowledgeable!
Thank you so much for your kind words!
Unique amazing treasures at every turn. Love them. Update:I've made an amazing friend with the owner, she's absolutely amazing,and super helpful! Prices are fair, not to mention that she's ALWAYS running a sale of some sort, plus a loyalty program! Who could lose shopping here? No one I know looking for clothes and a great price tag.
Analyzing 5,468,0865.5M ReviewsFor 14,73714.7K Experts