Google reviewers rate Total Wine & More in Carmel, Indiana, 4.7 out of 5 based on 439 reviews, with the owner responding to 98% of feedback. Customers frequently praise the store's extensive inventory, competitive pricing, and helpful staff who provide product recommendations and tastings. Common criticisms include inconsistent pricing across items, inventory discrepancies between the online app and physical stock, and dissatisfaction with store layout or specific product quality issues.
Data from Google, last updated October 26, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Good prices, great selection. You won't beat either anywhere else.
Norm - thanks so much for the kudos about our Carmel wine store and a 5-star rating on our selection and prices!🍾🥂
Huge selection!
Gary - thanks so much for the 5-star rating about our product selection! We are always striving to have the best selection around. Let us know if there’s anything else you’re looking for!
If this place doesn't carry, it's probably not available! We were looking for a specific brand of beer from a specific Caribbean country. We checked with 5 or 6 other liquor stores, and none of them carried it. However several of them suggested Total Wine & More. Of course, Total Wine & More not only had what we were looking for, but they also had multiple other brands from the same country! This will be our go-to store from now on, our first and only stop. Like we said, if they don't carry it, it's probably not available anywhere!
Chuck - thank you for the fantastic review! We’re thrilled we could help you track down exactly what you were looking for—and even give you a few more options to explore. We truly appreciate the kind words and are honored to be your new go-to store. We look forward to seeing you again!
I love this store, very good pricing, about the most unlimited variety of stock you'll ever find, and the staff is extremely helpful, and always very enjoyable to interact with
Thomas - thanks so much for the 5-star rating about our product selection and helpful staff! We are always striving to have the best selection around. Let us know if there’s anything else you’re looking for!
Un buen trato todo limpio y ordenado
Rogelio - thanks so much for the 5-star rating! We look forward to serving you again at our Carmel wine store during your next visit!
Great selection of everything
Mikhail - you're too kind! Thanks so much for the 5-star review. Cheers! 🥂
Great place. They have anything you could possibly be looking for.
Thanks so much for the 5-star rating! We look forward to serving you again during your next visit!
Does what it says on the tin. Superior selection, reasonable prices, excellent staff.
Quincy - thanks so much for the 5-star rating about our product selection, prices, and staff! We are always striving to have the best selection around. Let us know if there’s anything else you’re looking for!
You guys never have Frontera Chilean red wine ( merlot, cabernet) when I stop there! What's the deal?
Shannon - we aim to have the best selection around on wine, beer, and spirits, and we're sorry we didn't have in stock what you were looking for. There are limitations to what we can and cannot carry due to what we're able to order from our local distributors. While we can't guarantee we'll be able to stock this product, we'll share it with our buying team so they can see if we can add it to this location's selection. If you have any other concerns, please call our Customer Care Center at 855-328-9463.
Great store for a wide selection of drinks. Lots of imported drink options too which is great!
Amy - thank you for the amazing 5-star rating! It's great to know that our product selection was up to your standards and that you had an all around great visit. We hope to see you very soon!