Google reviewers rate Vestals Catering 4.9 out of 5 based on 169 reviews, noting that the owner replies to 68% of them. Customers frequently praise the quality of the food, professional communication, and the team's responsiveness during planning and events. While many highlight smooth execution for weddings and corporate galas, some lower-rated reviews cite inconsistencies between tasting and event day, missing specific items, or insufficient service attention for dietary needs.
Data from Google, last updated October 25, 2026.
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Our event was SO much more wonderful with the quality and loveliness of Vestals' Catering for our brunch! Thank you for the superb way you helped with the event hosted by Care Church on Saturday, October 10! We are very grateful and want everyone to know what a tremendously brilliant way you came through!
We absolutely LOVED Vestals Catering. They did EVERYTHING for us! We had hors d’oeuvres, full service meal and late night snacks! All of our guests have continuously raved about how great the food and service was. Everything from the initial tasting consultation with Shelby, up until the wedding day, was perfect. Shelby was always readily available to answer any questions, I or my planner had, and was always able to help in any way. We cannot recommend them enough! Great food and just all around great people working there!
Vestals Catering did a beautiful job for our daughter's wedding. Highly responsive, great communication and follow through, and many guests complimented the excellent food!
Vestals catered our wedding this past Sunday and everything was phenomenal! The food was so good, everyone loved the lil appetizers, and the service was outstanding, too
Shelby has been THE BEST vendor / manager we have worked with in our wedding planning process! We've prayed for someone that recognizes our needs, listens to us and can guess what we want or what our preferences are, and someone that goes ABOVE and BEYOND and that's EXACTLY what she has done! The food has been phenomenal and every experience we've had at Vestals has been top tier. Confident we will have guests saying it's the best wedding food they have ever had!
We loved working with Vestals! They were so accommodating to all our ideas, and we're so helpful in finding what would be the most cost effective for our guest count. We had SO many compliments on how great the food was at our wedding - we went with an italian buffet. We had a few guests who were gluten free and we were easily able to get them their meals - and they also said their meal was great! Not only is the food great with vestals, but their team is amazing and so helpful. I could not recommend them enough!!!
The team at Vestals is world class! Very professional and goes above and beyond to make sure your event is unforgettabke!
Thank you for the kind words. It is our privilege to help create unforgettable events, and we are so glad the experience reflected that. We appreciate you trusting Vestals and we can't wait for the next one!
We had an AMAZING experience working with this Vestals for our 300-person corporate gala, which included a buffet-style dinner and three bar setups. The food was amazing, and we received so many positive comments from our attendees. Our team was also very happy with the bar service - there were no long lines, and everyone was able to grab a drink quickly. Brittany was incredible to work with. Her pre-event communication was excellent, and I truly felt well taken care of throughout the planning process. Having her on-site during the event was amazing, and she even set up a text chain between her team and ours so we could quickly communicate any needs or timing adjustments in real time. That level of coordination made everything run so smoothly. We’re so grateful for the care their team put into making the event such a success, and I would absolutely love to work together again in the future!!!
Thank you so much for your kind words. It was truly a pleasure to be part of your corporate gala. We are so glad to hear the food, bar service, and overall flow of the evening created such a positive experience for your guests. Events of that scale take a great deal of coordination, and it means a lot to know our team helped everything run smoothly. We will be sure to pass along your thoughtful feedback to Brittany. She will be so grateful to hear it. Thank you again for trusting Vestals with such an important event. We would love to work together again in the future!
As a wedding planner, I'm always grateful to partner with vendors like the Vestals team! In addition to their delicious food, the team is always a joy to work with. They go above and beyond to make sure couples are taken care of, are always flexible when small pivots need to be made, and always have a positive attitude!
Thank you so much for your kind words. It truly means a lot to hear this from a fellow wedding professional. We are so grateful for the opportunity to work alongside planners like you who care so deeply about creating a wonderful experience for couples. It is always our goal to support the entire vendor team while making sure our couples feel well taken care of every step of the way. Thank you for your partnership and trust in the Vestals team. We always look forward to working together!!
First off, I'm not one to write a review so me writing this is a big deal. Shelby was AMAZING. In my opinion, she should be running the WHOLE company with all the knowledge she has. She made me and my husband's experience more then fabulous. She was more than kind and very personable. Would only book again if Shelby was there.
Thank you so much for taking the time to share this. It truly means a lot, especially knowing you do not usually write reviews. Shelby will be so grateful to hear your kind words. She cares deeply about the couples and clients she serves, and it is wonderful to hear that her knowledge, warmth, and attention made such a positive impact on your experience. We are so glad she was part of making your event feel so special. Thank you again for trusting Vestals with such an important celebration!