Is Amstill Roofing any good?
Our verdict: mixed — #64 of 70 roofing contractors, better than 9%. Customers single out its track record and accountability; value is where it trails.
Track record — better than 99% of peers
Accountability — better than 98% of peers
Satisfaction — 12th percentile
Reliability — 12th percentile
Value — 4th percentile
Price $$$$: 44% above typical
Amstill Roofing for attic venting
Clear ✕43 customers reviewed a attic venting job here and rated it 5.00★. Most paid $20,000+ (category typical: $638–$5.2k). For this job it ranks #4 of 36 roofing contractors we track.
All 43 Google reviews tagged “Attic venting”
David (salesman) and Rigo (project foreman) were both amazing. The entire process was outstanding. From David coming by for the quote to the removal of old roof and installation. I was blown away by how fast the installation was. I was able to see my finished roof with drone footage. Highly recommend.
Team arrived at 6:30 a.m to get a head start on the heat. Got everything done 12 hours later including a derail pick up and clean up. Observed excellent attention to detail, especially around exhaust vents with extra screws and caulking applied. Jose Lopez great job as team supervisor. Very pleased overall.
Justin is amazing!! He was very thorough in the inspection and explained everything to us in detail. We have signed to get some work done. Will provide updates here after work is completed.
Honest, professional team, with great customer service! Curt Schaefer spent a lot of time and care in (not 'selling') helping me understand my roof as a system. After getting several roofing estimates, Amstill Roofing was the clear answer. From office staff to Rigo, the project manager, the project was expertly…
Great information on what I need done and very thorough.
Amstill replaced our roof in 2021. I recently thought there may be an issue and called. They sent John Mitschke the same day (I had told them that IF there was an issue, there was rain in the forecast and I needed someone asap). He came out, did a thorough inspection, made sure everything was sealed properly and…
Over the past several years, Amstill has been our go-to roofing company for roof repairs. Two years ago, they honestly evaluated the condition of our roof, even denying themselves the opportunity to replace our roof because the roof was still good. I've recommended them to several people including a sister and a…
Tanner with Amstill was excellent. He was very knowledgeable. He took his time to answer all my questions. He was honest about the pricing and all my different options. We are excited to get our roof done!
My experience with Amstill Roofing was a joy from beginning to end. They provided me with first class service throughout, from interactions with Will Gavrelos, a highly gracious, respectful & knowledgable sales & product specialist & his strongly, organizationally supportive manager, Clark Hillegeist, & Amstill’s…
Isieron my buen trabajo en 6 horas terminaron todo. They did an amazing job from start to finish in an incredible time (6hrs) and cleaned up everything leaving no nails, trash etc. They were organized and very professional. Definitely will be recommending to family and friends. I can say the whole experience was…
Amstill did by far the best roofing job I've ever had. From end to end very professional, courteous. and dependable. Roof looks fantastic and no leaks !
Amstill Roofing employees did a great job of communicating from the beginning of scoping the project and throughout the project. They delivered what they promised promptly and professionally.
Amstill Roofing specialists were professional, courteous, and knowledgeable, who quickly diagnosed two problems we have and quoted us a reasonable price to effect the repairs to stop a leak at our chimney through flashing and address a super hot attic problem that kept turning out our water heater pilot light. The…
I love the experience with Amstill Roofing. Everyone was very efficient and polite. I never had a problem with anyone of them.
this is the 2nd review i posted today... The man is great! if you don't believe me... read the first review!! it's even better lol Till the cows come home!! LOL
From the very first time that I called Amstill Roofing and considered using their services, it has been an absolutely great experience!!! I can't possibly create the proper wording to express the highest order of service the staff has shown me. From Richard Martinez coming to my home and doing an evaluation of my…
I had to replace my roof QUICK and I am thankful to Tanner and the Amstill team for walking me through the process, giving me options amd making sure I knew what needed to do on my end with my HOA. They never left me wondering what was next. They're contributions to the military community and being a wounded warrior…
We recently completed a full roof replacement with Amstill Roofing, and the experience from start to finish was truly outstanding. We were initially impressed by the professionalism and knowledge of the team members who handled our consultation and contract. The sales process was led by Trent and Jones, who were…
Very thorough and really helped me with a chronic air flow issue I have had. Including coming to a creative solution. Highly recommend! Richard Martinez was incredibly helpful and discovered a simple solution efficiently.
David was very knowledgeable and complete in his presentation. He walked the roof and videotaped the damage and concerns he had. He offered 3 roofing options and showed me the process along with each step in replacing the roof.
A few months have passed since Amstill completed the work at my house. They recommended and replaced my entire gutter system and installed gutters in needed places. They removed an old satellite dish and patched the hole. Everyone from the sales team, to the install team, were very professional. My personal…
Justin did a great job of educating me on how my roof leaks were a result of the roof temperature being too high due to lack of ventilation. I felt well informed in making repair decisions from the options he presented. Highly recommend an inspection from Amstill!
We are so happy with Amstill Roofing! Jones was our rep, and from the very first meeting, we knew we were dealing with roofers who really knew their stuff! Jones walked us through every aspect of repair or replacement, the differences in materials and techniques, venting solutions, etc. The day of, I was shocked at…
I had a great experience with Amstill. They are very professional, very efficient and the materials they used are of the best quality. Trent was the best. He explained all the process really well and made it super easy for us. He was on top of all the details
Justin Thornhill did an awesome job on my inspection! I really appreciate the level of attention to detail on the ventilation! And giving some tips on roof maintenance so I can the most years possible out of the current roof! We have an active squirrel population due to the pecan trees. Justin showed us some…
If there were a Michelin guide for roofing companies, Amstill Roofing would have a three-shingle rating — and that’s the highest honor in the world of asphalt and flashing. I had them come out to inspect my roof, half expecting the usual “welp, better tear it all down and start fresh” song and dance. But instead,…
Amstill Roofing executed a perfect roof repair and solar vent installation.. Shingles matched. Initial inspection and proposal were thorough and less expensive than I had anticipated. The work was completed professionally and with great care.
Crew showed up on time and were very professional. Clean up was very good and complete. Kingsley Niemchi explained our options and answered all our questions and concerns. I strongly recommend Amstill Roofing and Kingsley.
Provided professional information to customer. Jobs well done. Thank you!
Amstill did an excellent job on our roof and exceeded our expectations. Griffin our sales rep was great to work with as well and was very knowledgeable. Thanks for a job well done.
This is a professional company who delivers high quality work. They met our needs and exceeded them. I especially appreciated the cleanup they did after the work, restoring the work area back to its regular appearance. No complaints about this high-touch relationship. Strongly recommend.
So thankful I did the research and chose Amstill to replace my roof. I had shingles flying off here and there and chose them after meeting one of their representatives Kurt. He was super professional, friendly and extremely helpful as we are newbies when it comes to home maintenance. Amstill helped us every step of…
A large crew arrived at the stated time and repaired/replaced a half dozen lead jacks in under an hour. Impressive speed and quality service for a reasonable price. They came recommended, and I can now second that.
Amstill Roofing is an excellent roofing company and delivers superior service from the job estimate through to completion and cleanup. Use them and you can't lose.
I'd recommend Amstill in a heartbeat. From the day that their very professional and knowledgeable representative, Lee Perez, came to see what we needed, to the end of the installation, everything went like clockwork. All the office staff that I had contact with, including Michelle, Brian, Kelly & Lindsey, were a…
We had a new roof installed on our house and garage. Hunter did a great job explaining everything and even came back to our home on a Sunday to answer questions that my husband had. The crew finished the job in one day. They cleaned up everything before they left and someone came after they left to check their work.
Highly recommend!! My wife and I recently contracted with Amstill for residential roof replacement. They were very responsive in all communications, on-time for every appointment as well as the install. They assisted us with the insurance claim and conversations with the adjuster. We primarily dealt with Kurt,…
Trent Hair really is a great guy ! He represents Amstill roofing with genuine knowledge respect and integrity. I appreciate Trent’s attitude towards safety in reguards to his workers the homeowner and surrounding areas. Moving forward Trent and I had a a wonderful time getting to know each other as well as several…
After our area and home was impacted by two hurricanes and the SW Louisiana gulf coast, we had extensive damage to our shingles and which compromised the integrity of our roof. Initially we were working with another company for the emergency tarping of our home, but could never speak to any representative or have…
They just finished our new roof and it looks great. Highly recommended!!!
They came, they covered and protected our plants and shrubs, they removed the old roof, they installed the new roof, they cleaned up, they hauled off the debris and we all waved goodby. You sent a great crew that did a great job.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Questions about Amstill Roofing
Is Amstill Roofing good?
Yes by most measures: 4.9★ from 1,838 Google reviews and an Experts Score of 30/100 (grade D), #64 of 70 roofing contractors we track. 3% of reviews in the last two years were 1–2★ (category average 1.5%).
How much does Amstill Roofing charge?
Customers reported a typical bill of $15k (middle half $2.7k–$25k), 44% above the roofing contractors median of $10k.
What do customers hire Amstill Roofing for?
Mostly roof inspection (257), roof installation (256), roof repair (106), roof repair for storm & wind damage (73).
Does the owner respond to complaints?
The owner replied to 100% of 1–3★ reviews (category: 75%).
