Is Amstill Roofing any good?
Our verdict: mixed — #64 of 70 roofing contractors, better than 9%. Customers single out its track record and accountability; value is where it trails.
Track record — better than 99% of peers
Accountability — better than 98% of peers
Satisfaction — 12th percentile
Reliability — 12th percentile
Value — 4th percentile
Price $$$$: 44% above typical
Amstill Roofing for attic venting installation
Clear ✕50 customers reviewed a attic venting installation job here and rated it 5.00★. Most paid $20,000+. For this job it ranks #1 of 17 roofing contractors we track.
All 50 Google reviews tagged “Attic venting installation” · showing 40
I had a new roof estimate done. David was very thorough. He explained everything and even had samples to touch to understand each price option. I was very impressed with the warranty offered by this company. I went with Amstill to put my new roof on my house. During the installation they went above and beyond to…
Trust this review, Amstill Roofing is the best choice for your project. Danny A. and John Mi. did an amazing job from start to finish. The price was very reasonable for the exceptional work performed. The process was simple and easy. I had my entire roof replaced and my home is now ready for the next thunderstorm.…
David was knowledgeable and pleasant, patient and willing to answer questions. He was willing to work with me to get the best price.
Amstill Roofing somehow managed to make getting a new roof a pleasant experience for us. Everything from scheduling the introductory appointment to the completion of the roof and clean-up afterwards was seamless, with all personnel being so knowledgeable and considerate. The roof was completed in one day with…
The Amstill team was great! From the initial roof inspection and follow-through to the day of service, they were all top-notch! I would highly recommend them.
Jose Lopez him and his crew did a magnificent job. I am very please.
Justin is amazing!! He was very thorough in the inspection and explained everything to us in detail. We have signed to get some work done. Will provide updates here after work is completed.
Honest, professional team, with great customer service! Curt Schaefer spent a lot of time and care in (not 'selling') helping me understand my roof as a system. After getting several roofing estimates, Amstill Roofing was the clear answer. From office staff to Rigo, the project manager, the project was expertly…
Great information on what I need done and very thorough.
Arrived on time and got straight to work. Finished quickly and it looks great.
Great service from the first meeting until the finished job and excellent clean up
I had a great experience with my sales guy, Alex who spent a lot of time with me explaining the process and later on with the project manager John Mitschke who was present all day during the installation. The crew (all 16 of them ) were very professional and did a great job. My hat off to all of them. Can highly recommend this company to anybody.
Very professional through the entire process. Would definitely use again.
Tanner was great and thorough with the roof quote. His presentation of all the benefits and products included in our BEST package pulled me from the fence against 2 other competitors. He's genuine and pleasant to talk to without all the BS. I will recommend him and Amstil Roofing to my family and friends.
My experience with Amstill Roofing was a joy from beginning to end. They provided me with first class service throughout, from interactions with Will Gavrelos, a highly gracious, respectful & knowledgable sales & product specialist & his strongly, organizationally supportive manager, Clark Hillegeist, & Amstill’s…
Will and the whole staff from the office and the actual roofing team did an excellent job. The on site team fixed a problem that the builder overlooked when the house was built years ago that was causing a major roof problem. Turn key job … new roof, soffits, paint and clean up. Done in one day and I have a very…
Curt Schaefer guided us expertly through the process of doing our Reid taking the time to share information options and come to our final decision. We really appreciated the whole process with the onsite team being very responsive and mindful. They left our house spotless and the neighbors certainly appreciated that…
Amstill Roofing did an amazing job on my roof. My neighbor had highly recommended them, so when I needed an opinion about the status of my roof, I requested that they inspect it. Adam inspected it and showed me the video. The roof definitely needed to be replaced -- all over the roof there were numerous cracks…
Isieron my buen trabajo en 6 horas terminaron todo. They did an amazing job from start to finish in an incredible time (6hrs) and cleaned up everything leaving no nails, trash etc. They were organized and very professional. Definitely will be recommending to family and friends. I can say the whole experience was…
Amstill Roofing specialists were professional, courteous, and knowledgeable, who quickly diagnosed two problems we have and quoted us a reasonable price to effect the repairs to stop a leak at our chimney through flashing and address a super hot attic problem that kept turning out our water heater pilot light. The…
Richard Martinez is a great agent for Amstill Roofing. Very friendly, detailed everything I needed to make my decision for a new roof. Highly recommend.
I love the experience with Amstill Roofing. Everyone was very efficient and polite. I never had a problem with anyone of them.
Fair price and quality work!!
this is the 2nd review i posted today... The man is great! if you don't believe me... read the first review!! it's even better lol Till the cows come home!! LOL
From the very first time that I called Amstill Roofing and considered using their services, it has been an absolutely great experience!!! I can't possibly create the proper wording to express the highest order of service the staff has shown me. From Richard Martinez coming to my home and doing an evaluation of my…
From the initial inspection and estimate from Justin to the final cleanup, the entire experience was exceptional. The project manager Evan kept me updated every step of the way and answered all my questions with patience and expertise. The crew worked with impressive precision and completed the job faster than…
Amstill Roofing replaced our roof in one day. Big and steep roof. Cleaned up all like they were never there. Gutters and downspouts were replaced after the painter finished. They did a great job on all.
Friendly, helpful, knowledgable staff. Easy scheduling. Prompt arrivals, both roof inspector and the roofer who did the work. Overall, very pleased with our choice to hire this company.
Amstill wasn’t the lowest quote we received but we chose them because of the high level of quality work they offered. Alex, our sales rep knocked it out of the park and Evan the project manager ensured the work was done to high standards. The roof looks great!
David was very knowledgeable and complete in his presentation. He walked the roof and videotaped the damage and concerns he had. He offered 3 roofing options and showed me the process along with each step in replacing the roof.
Crew of 14 with 2 supervisors knocked out 8200 sq ft of shingles in one day including 5 attic breeze fans. Guys worked really hard and took few breaks....did an excellent job installing and spent a lot of time cleaning up on day 2. Jose and Evan worked with the crews and coordinated materials. Chino was overall…
Jones Massey did a great job when he came to look at our potentially damaged roof. He showed me options and made suggestions to improve the integrity of our roof which I greatly appreciated. I will definitely be using Amstill roofing in the future.
We are so happy with Amstill Roofing! Jones was our rep, and from the very first meeting, we knew we were dealing with roofers who really knew their stuff! Jones walked us through every aspect of repair or replacement, the differences in materials and techniques, venting solutions, etc. The day of, I was shocked at…
Amstill gave an immediate response to my issue and had a serviceman, Griffin, out to my house within 24 hours. He was thorough with his inspection & repair. I have 100% confidence in his analysis of the condition of my roof and when the time comes for replacement I would not hesitate to use Amstill. Update: I did…
Very good experience. Large crew arrived on time and performed very professionally. Project Forman, Jose, was exceptional. Friendly, professional, well informed. We have a large, steep roof but they completely replaced the shingles, etc. in less than a day, using quality products and installing to manufacturers…
Excellent service and professionalism from every employee I had the pleasure to work with. Elliot and Evan made everything easy and reassuring. Would recommend to anyone needing services provided.
Excellent advice and very thorough. First class work. I highly recommend them!
Amstill representative Kingsley was very professional and he and roof repair professional delivered what was promised. Very easy doing business with this company!
Provided professional information to customer. Jobs well done. Thank you!
The workers and materials were on time and began as soon as the sun rose! They were professional and they took extreme care with our plants and our flowerbeds. They worked tirelessly and finished a HUGE job in one day. The cleanup was amazing. The workers went over our yards, flower beds and driveway/sidewalk…
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Questions about Amstill Roofing
Is Amstill Roofing good?
Yes by most measures: 4.9★ from 1,838 Google reviews and an Experts Score of 30/100 (grade D), #64 of 70 roofing contractors we track. 3% of reviews in the last two years were 1–2★ (category average 1.5%).
How much does Amstill Roofing charge?
Customers reported a typical bill of $15k (middle half $2.7k–$25k), 44% above the roofing contractors median of $10k.
What do customers hire Amstill Roofing for?
Mostly roof inspection (257), roof installation (256), roof repair (106), roof repair for storm & wind damage (73).
Does the owner respond to complaints?
The owner replied to 100% of 1–3★ reviews (category: 75%).
