How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%97+52.9Reliability 24%96+23.3Value 14%100+14.1Replies to reviews 7%32+2.3Experts Score= 93Grade A: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.93SCORECarryl Tire Co.
Jacksonville, FL · Grade ALetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #11Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 110 oil change services · 5.0★ from 610 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other oil change services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: craft & service and value; weakest: replies to reviews.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Carryl Tire Co. for 8 kinds of job.
Carryl Tire Co. for oil change
Clear ✕All 113 Google reviews tagged “Oil change” · showing 100
Family run business you can always count on to give you exceptional service and honest assessments. Only folks I trust with my truck 👍
There’s no where I would recommend more than Carryl Tire. Their team does a great job explaining what they’re working on, what issues there may be, and what the costs are before they start. If you need a place where you can trust them with your car and money - go to Carryl.
Great customer service! Fast and fair prices. This company is built on honesty and integrity.
They were very polite and professional.
Carryl Tire is my go to oil change place !!! My car's steering was moaning n groaning.... Carryl Tire got the front end fixed n it drives Fantastic now....
Beautiful facility with top-notch service and personable service writers. John and Tyler know how to satisfy their customers.
I will never take my car anywhere else. Honest business with incredible turnaround time. S d their new shop is very nice and welcoming!
Being going here since they had the old smaller location across the street. Love their service, always helpful, and prices are ACTUALLY affordable for the average person nowadays. Their new location is super nice, and even has a work room for customers to use, and a kids corner if you got children with you while you wait.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I can’t say enough good things about Carryl’s Tires! They’re family owned and operated, and you can truly feel that the moment you walk in — they treat everyone like family. I got new tires and some front end work done, and the whole experience was smooth, honest, and affordable. They took the time to…
Thank you, so much! For the service you provide, taking care of my vehicle. It’s the care you give me and peace of mind when my vehicle runs smoothly.
Trust is the essential word to compliment Carryl Tire upon. The confidence of work properly and responsibly accomplished is always their goal and is always attained.
Great service and employees great.
Very pleased with the service we have received from Carryl Tire. My family has now had tires put on 4 vehicles and my other family members have also had some auto repair done. All at reasonable prices with excellent customer service. It’s great to work with a locally owned and operated shop.
Good work done honestly and with integrity. Very pleased with all of my visits.
Carryl Tire co takes excellent care of my car and always so nice to me. I feel confident in the decision making about what my car needs and the work as completed. I highly recommend for ALL the service your car needs, not just tires, but they did a great job with my new tires a few years ago.
Friendly, knowledgeable and first class environment and shop!
Great personal service. They are prompt and professional. They follow up with details and help their customers understand the issues.
Carryl Tire team is extremely experienced efficient and timely.
Oil change and the staff interaction was great very professiona.
Excellent service.
Very pleased with Carryl’s Tire Company!!! They did a wonderful job servicing my car, very professional, and reasonable price.
These guys treat me like family. They truly go above and beyond.
Outstanding as usual. Kind, courteous, & professional staff. An extremely well run business. Highly recommend.
We have been extremely happy with Carryl Tire and take three of our vehicles up there. The team is always transparent and provide very clear and detailed explanations and options for us. We never feel like we haven't received the best service, and their offices are genuinely a pleasant place to enter. Jonathan and…
Beautiful facility, professional personnel, great pricing! I highly recommend Carryl Tire for all automotive needs.
Took my truck in to get the oil changed and tires rotated. Also had the serpentine belt replaced. They do quality work at a reasonable price. Been going here for several years. Great service and friendly staff.
Always very knowledgeable and polite. The whole team goes above and beyond to make sure the customer is informed and given excellent care.
Clint Hendrix is an asset to your company. He is excellent
Carrly tire did an excellent job with my car alignment! They are friendly, professional and ready to answer any questions. I highly recommend them for your car needs.
1) Make an appointment for an oil change (thank you for this convenience) 2) Drop off or wait for the service (appointment time is honored) 3) Car has been serviced and given a quick rinse (thank you for getting all that dust & pollen off of it, a nice surprise!) 4) Cost is reasonable for the service provided,…
Professional, courteous and knowledgeable. Clean and fast. And the price is right. A new customer and client
The new shop is convenient and spacious. Have had work performed on our 3 cars and have been very satisfied every time. Friendly, timely and transparent service. Wish we had known of them sooner.
I have had so much confidence in the service and the experience at Carryl tire, I wouldn’t go anywhere else! They save me money and headaches over the dealership!
Great family run operation. Always trustworthy and honest. They always take the time to get to the root cause and communicate well with customer. Highly recommend. Love their new space plenty of room to work. Just need a bar top near an outlet for my laptop. Had them look at my wife’s AC and they tipped off the Freon and had it blowing cold.
Close to estimate, told everything they found. Let you decide if you wanted to do it. They worked with me and helped me greatly!!!! I highly recommend you at least ask them to give you an estimate. Tyler and John are quality people. I can't say enough good things about them. I do hope the new bigger garage fills…
Took my car in for a oil change. Also had an appointment. They got right on it. Mechanics are really good. Can't beat the price. Highly recommend. If you need something call Tyler.
Not only is the new building, incredible and clean, but the staff is always so easy to deal with
We had the best experience at Carryl Tire! These guys are so easy to work with and they really do care about every customer that walks in their door! You're treated like family, like it used to be back in the day! Honesty, quality and integrity is their foundation and what makes them stand out above the rest! Thank you Carryl Tire!!
Excellent service, good prices, great experience!
Always top notch service! My family loves Carryl Tire!
Another great experience with Carryl service center. Saved a fortune on tires and the oil change was quick and their rotate and balance that comes with the oil change keeps my rigs running smooth.
We love Carryl Tires! They are great! My husband brought his truck in for an oil change. They were very honest! Did not say everything needed to be changed or replaced! Thank you so much! Use them! You will be very pleased!
Carryl Tire is the best tire and auto shop around. They do great work, charge a fair price, and you never have to wonder if you're getting the runaround. It's just a good, honest shop run by people who take pride in what they do.
Excellent service from excellent people!
Very professional and fast!!! I was in and out in 1.30 hrs with 2 new tires,,oil change and a quote for future services its been 1 yr since I started going to this shop. And I would never change it not even for better prices!! They are professional and treat you like family. Waiting room is clean
Fast, friendly and professional oil change service. They got me in and out right away ,I highly recommend Carryl Tire Co.
The best surprise is no surprise in this industry and that is exactly what I experienced with Carryl. To my surprise and trust you I am happy about this surprise, there were no changes. I received the same excellent service honesty and transparency. The atmosphere was friendly and welcoming and I always save the…
Absolutely hands down the best car repair experience I've had! Every detail was explained to me so I was well informed about the exact issues needing repaired. That alone was worth its weight in gold! And they are HONEST, a very rare thing. Check out Carlyle’s for your next car service needs!
I love the People and the work that they do here!
I recently had my transmission fluid, coolant, and oil changed. After comparing options, I found that Carly Tire Company offered the best price. I was in and out an hour earlier than I expected. I highly recommend Carly Tire Company for all your car service needs!
Tyler and the crew did an excellent job! They checked my coolant system and found no issues. I liked hearing that! Also, new Ball Joints and an Alignment have my truck riding like new. Honesty, Great Work and a Fair Price! I highly recommend!
Carryl Tire has been extensively professional and they work with the highest form of expertise and care when it came to my car. There hasn’t been any experience or confidence in knowing the job will get done 110% anywhere else. The only place I will ever recommend!
attention to detail congenial the best
Love this place, the garage is super clean and professional, looks like an F1 garage! Super honest and do excellent work. I won't take my vehicles anywhere else, these guys are awesome!
My son has used Carryl’s for many years and recommended them to me. Now I know why! I made an appointment to have an oil change, tires rotated and brakes checked and my SUV was serviced on time…no long wait! Friendly and honest clientele and the building is clean and well kept inside and out! Carryl’s will…
Excellent attention to all my concerns.
Jon and his team at Carryl are the best in the business. They always treat you with respect and they truly care about you and your vehicle needs. They never try to upsell or sell you services that you don’t need. We will never take our car anywhere else!
Carryl Tire is top-tier. They are professional, efficient, and honest. I wouldn’t take my car anywhere else!
Tyler & John are always so great! Very transparent and honest.
Always very professional and friendly staff! Trustworthy also. They explain what service(s) they did and/or what may be necessary in the future-but without pushing me to get a service prematurely.
The folks at Carryl Tire always do great work. They take time to explain the work, do great quality work and offer fair prices. 10/10 always recommend them!
Outstanding service! The crew at Carryl Tire Co. is knowledgeable, courteous, and efficient. Wouldn’t take my car anywhere else.
As our history indicates we appreciate the customer service at Carryl’s along with the car repairs and tire services. We followed Mike Carryl when he provided tires and service all along Park St and immediately started with them once they opened on Blanding. May years of happy service from this family!
The folks at Carryl Tire are always a pleasure to deal with. I take my vehicle there for all their services. The staff is friendly, professional, and knowledgeable.
Work was completed ahead of schedule.
Delivered on time!
Carryl tire took my car on short notice and had it turned around in less than 24 hours. They were professional and thorough. I will definitely be back!
Best mechanic experience I’ve ever had! Inexpensive, professional, clean and prompt! Family run.
Best service center in town! Great people who work there and they provide an excellent service. Highly recommend.
Experts in their field; honest to the penny, only replaced front brakes because the rear breaks were ok; thoroughly check the vehicle for problems and let me make the decision to repair. That is why I have been with this tire center since it opened, and many years before with the owner family.
Carryl Tire has always been highly professional and precise with handling any of my needs. They have a hard working and committed staff that you normally don’t find often. They are very fluent with time, and they always communicate exceptionally well with updates and recommendations that you may need on your…
Great service! Trustworthy and great team!
Highly recommend Carryl Tires, they are very professional and quick with their work. I have had multiple tires patched with them after nails would get in from sedan tires to big truck tires. I have also been going to them for my oil changes, tire rotation and alignments; which they have a great alignment plan for a…
As a woman walking in to get my car worked on, I’m always nervous I’m going to get bamboozled into spending more money on things my car doesn’t need. But my experience at Carryl Tire was really pleasant. Everyone was very friendly, informative, and made sure I understood what was going on with my car. They took the…
Gave great service on our 2005 BMW 330i and found a couple of issues that I was unaware of with pictures and reasonable pricing! I really like paying from my cell phone and the digital communication platform. They are breaking the automotive repair shop stereotype!
Carryl Tire Co. is a trustworthy, professional business that I highly recommend to anyone who is need of auto repair. The service is outstanding, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable.
These are my guys! Never old sold, always get what I need. They go above and beyond to explain and communicate what you need every time from simple things to the big things. Love them!
Been there four times now and the guys have done a GREAT job! Up front and honest, which is hard to find in a auto repair shop!
Great service and great guys! Really helped me get back to serving my customers quickly. My highest recommendation!
Wonderful people and great prices! I first took my Mercedes here for brake pad replacement last year, and it pained me when I realized how much I was unnecessarily spending by using the dealership all of these years. Now, I use Carryl Tire Co for my regular maintenance as well! Always a pleasant experience!
The entire Carryl Tire Co. team has been extremely helpful, professional, and knowledgable every time. They go above and beyond to ensure that their customers are well taken care of and are a pleasure to do business with.
They are very friendly and knowledgeable. Prices are great. Will be a return customer for sure!
Only taking my vehicle to this place from here on out! Good people, affordable, and honest.
By far the best service I have ever received from an auto repair business. I received detailed updates and they went out of their way to save me money. They refused to order any parts until they could diagnose the issues
I never knew getting your car serviced could be such an enjoyable experience. I really just put it right up there next to the dentist on my list of terribly awful things. This place is great and every person I encountered was so friendly and professional. They didn’t take advantage of me or try to add unnecessary…
The guys at Caryyl Tire Co are amazing! They were very responsive and helped me when choosing my new tires! They’re waiting in their shop is very clean and offered great coffee for free. I would highly recommend this to anyone, hands down the best auto shop in the Jax area!
Excellent thorough service by Jon and his crew. Speedy too! Got my oil change and tire rotation completed quickly. I really like the online invoice and appreciate the transparency. Highly recommend Carryl Tire Co. for all your full service automotive needs. Jon and his crew were awesome!
Great service and even better people!
This was the fastest oil change I have ever had! Great service and highly knowledgeable staff! Definitely will go back for any car servicing needs 👍
Great customer service experience. I came in, did not have to set an appointment (I called prior, and was advised on busiest times). Hours are appropriate, and fair. Service exceeded my expectations. Will recommend.
Awesome place! The staff was super friendly, helpful and welcoming. The space was clean and appealing. They did an awesome job changing my oil and checking my car, explaining everything they found without being pushy on any additional work.
Bringing my car to Carryl Tire Co. was the best experience I have had with a car shop. Both of the gentlemen at the front counter were very knowledgeable and personable. They were honest and I they did not try and sell me on any unnecessary parts or services. The waiting area is very clean and modern and they had…
Great place very knowledgeable. Not like most mechanics shops they will tell you what's wrong even if it not what you thought was wrong. Definitely dont just take people's money and fix things that dont need fixing. I highly recommend them to everyone.
I cannot say enough about Carryl Tire! They do excellent work at great prices. They're extremely trustworthy; their priority is serving the customer - getting the customer what they need at the best price.
This place is amazing. The team takes great care of your vehicle. A visit to Carryl tire doesn't feel like you are being ripped away from your money or painful like a root canal. They really work with you to find out what is necessary and what can wait. They truly understand what it is like to go to an auto repair…
This is the only time where I've looked forward to visiting a mechanic! The entire shop has a welcoming vibe like that of your favorite coffee spot and the entire process is easy going. Incredibly transparent and informative through out any repair or service, can't recommend enough!
Great experience, will definitely be using them with any maintenance needed! Excellent customer service!
Highly recommend! Fantastic service!
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Price
Not enough reviews with a price yet.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Tires | 162 | — |
| Oil change | 113 | — |
| General repairs & maintenance | 73 | — |
| Wheel alignment | 70 | — |
| Steering & suspension repair | 34 | — |
| Brakes | 34 | — |
| Auto engine diagnostic | 29 | — |
| Tire rotations | 26 | — |