How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%97+52.9Reliability 24%96+23.3Value 14%100+14.1Replies to reviews 7%32+2.3Experts Score= 93Grade A: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.93SCORECarryl Tire Co.
Jacksonville, FL · Grade ALetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #11Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 110 oil change services · 5.0★ from 610 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other oil change services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: craft & service and value; weakest: replies to reviews.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Carryl Tire Co. for 8 kinds of job.
Carryl Tire Co. for tires
Clear ✕All 162 Google reviews tagged “Tires” · showing 80
Love the new shop. These are the people I trust with my vehicles. The work needed is always clearly communicated. There is never a bait and switch. It's easy to schedule service and get updates. Truly the best.
I came in very last minute, they were able to get me in regardless, they were very efficient. I waited maybe 15 minutes. The customer service was great, Tyler was very professional and helpful. The new shop looks amazing as well!
Carryl tire went far and above what was needed to be fair to us. We wouldn’t use any other tire company in town.
They have a great team a Carryl Tire. They did an excellent job on my 81 Corvette with the alignment.
Every time I go there to get my car serviced or anything like that everybody is very attentive very knowledgeable they're very nice and take the time to explain what's needed to do for my car. 100% I would totally send people to get their cars looked at and stuff there. A+ service
Carryl Tire is the best! Super knowledgeable and helpful. Transparent throughout the entire process. The best in town no doubt!
Came in for a tire patch and the service was quick and they a great job.
Beautiful facility with top-notch service and personable service writers. John and Tyler know how to satisfy their customers.
Great service-highly recommend!
John and the entire team took excellent care of both of my trucks. Atmosphere of the new place is great and kid friendly lots to do if your waiting for your vehicle to be serviced. B&W Marine Construction
Great and honest guys. Excellent service. Would recommend to anyone
Being going here since they had the old smaller location across the street. Love their service, always helpful, and prices are ACTUALLY affordable for the average person nowadays. Their new location is super nice, and even has a work room for customers to use, and a kids corner if you got children with you while you wait.
As always great service tire fixed no problem!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I can’t say enough good things about Carryl’s Tires! They’re family owned and operated, and you can truly feel that the moment you walk in — they treat everyone like family. I got new tires and some front end work done, and the whole experience was smooth, honest, and affordable. They took the time to…
John always delivers!! Top notch service always
Carryl Tire Co is the best! I don't take my vehicles anywhere else, there's no need as nobody does it better. I've had several vehicles at different dealerships and they could never get it right, whether it was an alignment, wheel balance or some other routine maintenance. Every single time I leave Carryl I know…
Very pleased with the service we have received from Carryl Tire. My family has now had tires put on 4 vehicles and my other family members have also had some auto repair done. All at reasonable prices with excellent customer service. It’s great to work with a locally owned and operated shop.
Stellar customer service!! Completely trust what they are saying and showing with images what is going on. We Highly recommend Carryl’s to everyone!!
Repaired slow leak on tire timely and reasonable price
A real friendly neighborhood auto shop. Trustworthy and reliable service.
Carryl Tire team is extremely experienced efficient and timely.
Very nice staff take care of my family as well.
Outstanding service and support staff! Very professional!!
The message is simple…..if you want to do business with someone you trust…,,Go to Carryl’s!!!!
The team at Carryl is great. Prompt and efficient service every time. Highly recommend!
Always great service and the new tire shop is amazing so awesome
Excellent service.
Very pleased with Carryl’s Tire Company!!! They did a wonderful job servicing my car, very professional, and reasonable price.
Great experience! Competitive pricing, clean environment. Quality work. Communication and customer service was very professional and timely. Thumbs up!
Got new tires for my wife’s car and the shop turned it around quick and was competitive on pricing. Easy to work with and a good honest shop.
Great service! Staff was friendly and communicative.
Outstanding as usual. Kind, courteous, & professional staff. An extremely well run business. Highly recommend.
First time going there. Super friendly. Had an appt. Prompt service. In and out in no time. A definite “A+” experience!!!
Always professional, courteous, and prompt. I highly recommend them.
We have been extremely happy with Carryl Tire and take three of our vehicles up there. The team is always transparent and provide very clear and detailed explanations and options for us. We never feel like we haven't received the best service, and their offices are genuinely a pleasant place to enter. Jonathan and…
Always very knowledgeable and polite. The whole team goes above and beyond to make sure the customer is informed and given excellent care.
Fast and efficient. They do an awesome job. They work with you to get you in as soon as they can. Turnaround is fast. Highly recommend them. Staff are excellent.
These guys are awesome! I’ve been a customer for years. Trustworthy with fair pricing.
The staff at Carryl Tire Co. Are very knowledgeable and friendly. Most of all they are extremely honest and trustworthy. They will send pictures of all parts of your vehicle as work is needed.
I highly recommend Carryl Tire. The company I work for uses them and I use them for my personal vehicles. They are quick, efficient, well priced and you feel like you can trust them when they give you a recommendation. Their new space is also incredible. I had to bring my toddler with me and they have a kids corner…
Could not be nicer people, better mechanics and more honest car repair in Jacksonville in my experience
The Carryl team does an excellent job, they know what they are doing and customer service is top notch! Very impressive family owned business!
Always great customer care.
The new shop is convenient and spacious. Have had work performed on our 3 cars and have been very satisfied every time. Friendly, timely and transparent service. Wish we had known of them sooner.
Great family run operation. Always trustworthy and honest. They always take the time to get to the root cause and communicate well with customer. Highly recommend. Love their new space plenty of room to work. Just need a bar top near an outlet for my laptop. Had them look at my wife’s AC and they tipped off the Freon and had it blowing cold.
Vibration from two new tires. Carryl found problem and fixed on the first visit. Best tire shop in Jacksonville. Honest and you are treated excellently.
Close to estimate, told everything they found. Let you decide if you wanted to do it. They worked with me and helped me greatly!!!! I highly recommend you at least ask them to give you an estimate. Tyler and John are quality people. I can't say enough good things about them. I do hope the new bigger garage fills…
The best, won’t go anywhere else moving forward.
Always prompt and professional
Always polite and helpful. They don't over charge or tell you that you need work that isn't necessary
Johnathan and his team did a speedy and great job for me. I was at the of the day with a tire going flat because of a nail puncture. His team member got the job done quickly. Thank you all.
The staff was courteous and quickly worked me in for a tire replacement without trying to sell additional tires, and the office was clean and comfortable with a place to work while I waited. Highly recommend.
Another great experience with Carryl service center. Saved a fortune on tires and the oil change was quick and their rotate and balance that comes with the oil change keeps my rigs running smooth.
Very professional, shopped around, best price, great service, very happy.
Great tires, service and price
Carryl Tire is the best tire and auto shop around. They do great work, charge a fair price, and you never have to wonder if you're getting the runaround. It's just a good, honest shop run by people who take pride in what they do.
I happened upon this business a few years ago and I am so glad I did!!!! Family business, HONEST, Friendly and completely knowledgeable! GO HERE!!!!!
Quick and very pleasant people! Very affordable for the service they provided!
Very professional and fast!!! I was in and out in 1.30 hrs with 2 new tires,,oil change and a quote for future services its been 1 yr since I started going to this shop. And I would never change it not even for better prices!! They are professional and treat you like family. Waiting room is clean
Absolutely hands down the best car repair experience I've had! Every detail was explained to me so I was well informed about the exact issues needing repaired. That alone was worth its weight in gold! And they are HONEST, a very rare thing. Check out Carlyle’s for your next car service needs!
Best people and service! Highly recommend.
Top notch, professional and reasonable
I always have great service at Carryl tire. My car dealership wanting Me to get two new tires. Carryl tire was able to plug my tire for $44.
I recently purchased tires from Carryl Tire and as always the process of scheduling an appointment and getting the car back in a timely manner was great. Love my new Michelin Pilot Sport 4S tires on my Miata.
Over all fantastic. Wife got a nail in her tire while I was at work. Offered to pick her up. She was able to fill the tire to driveable condition. They offered to send someone to follow her to the shop but she made it on her own. Once she arrived they had her fixed and on the road in less that 30 min. Locally owned…
After being recommended by a friend , the guys at the shop were so nice and professional. As a woman sometimes dealing with car issues can be intimidating as I know nothing about cars. Well they explained everything detail for detail and broke down all my options. They gave me realistic expectations and were done…
I had a good experience very courteous employees when the time comes I will come back thanks
Always great service. I have been using Carryl Tire for a couple of years now on a couple of different cars. Brake work, AC work, other issues. I'm comfortable with them. I try their knowledge and appreciate the timeliness of my repairs. I don't go anywhere else.
I always trust the boys at Caryll, while I have an Electric Vehicle which can tricky it is no problem for them. My wife won’t go anywhere else with her SUV. They always provide her sound advice even when she won’t listen to mine!
Carryl tire is our trusted local shop. They are more than just tires. We depend on them for an honest opinion and recommendations.
I was recommended this shop by my usual mechanic because they don’t work on tires. It was a great experience from scheduling through actually getting my tire fixed. It was just a small nail that needed to get pulled and patched but i was in and out in 20 minutes. They didn’t try to push anything else on me and were…
Carryl Tire has been extensively professional and they work with the highest form of expertise and care when it came to my car. There hasn’t been any experience or confidence in knowing the job will get done 110% anywhere else. The only place I will ever recommend!
attention to detail congenial the best
Really nice and knowledgeable staff.
My son has used Carryl’s for many years and recommended them to me. Now I know why! I made an appointment to have an oil change, tires rotated and brakes checked and my SUV was serviced on time…no long wait! Friendly and honest clientele and the building is clean and well kept inside and out! Carryl’s will…
I don’t really think Carryl deserves a 5 star rating but that’s the highest I can go. I love the service and value at Carryls I came in late and was expecting to leave my SUV overnight but they pounced on it right away and had me back on the road just minutes before closing.
Jon and his team at Carryl are the best in the business. They always treat you with respect and they truly care about you and your vehicle needs. They never try to upsell or sell you services that you don’t need. We will never take our car anywhere else!
Carryl Tire is top-tier. They are professional, efficient, and honest. I wouldn’t take my car anywhere else!
Since Carryl Tire has been in business they have mounted around 30 tires for me and I have always had excellent service will never go anywhere else they are like family
Fantastic service! They got me a set of 4 new tires on my fleet work truck (managed by enterprise) when other tire shops could never get new tires approved. Will definitely be doing all of my future auto appointments with Carryl Tire!
Price
Not enough reviews with a price yet.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Tires | 162 | — |
| Oil change | 113 | — |
| General repairs & maintenance | 73 | — |
| Wheel alignment | 70 | — |
| Steering & suspension repair | 34 | — |
| Brakes | 34 | — |
| Auto engine diagnostic | 29 | — |
| Tire rotations | 26 | — |
