Carter's My Plumber
Speedway, IN · Grade ALetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #33Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 44 leak detection services · 4.9★ from 2,947 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other leak detection services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: momentum and replies to reviews; weakest: value.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Carter's My Plumber for 8 kinds of job.
Carter's My Plumber for plumbing leak repair
Clear ✕All 98 Google reviews tagged “Plumbing leak repair” · showing 40
The plumber was excellent. He explained every possibility that could be the problem. The issue was a simple solution, and the least expensive. He was honest, and not trying to gouge me.
Had a great experience with Carter’s plumbing. From the call to schedule to the repair. Called in the morning and John T. Was there within 2 hours. He found the leak, explained what had happened and had it fixed quickly, even providing pictures of the issue. Highly recommend!
This is the second time I have used Carter’s. Both were emergencies. They were prompt, came to my home when they said they would, fixed the problem professionally and didn’t add services I didn’t need. I highly recommend them!
Gabe explained what needed to be done and did a great job.
I had issues with my kitchen faucet. Carter’s My Plumber came ~ cleaned out the kitchen faucet lines and replaced the nozzle head and a filter. The faucet works perfectly now. The kitchen area was clean which I was very pleased about.
Great same day service to fix a leak in my crawl space and phenomenal customer service!
Repair was quick and well done!! Thank you so much for your very quick response to this issue!!
Quick response and fixed fast. Perfect service!
Gabriel was honest, knowledgeable, energetic, and pleasant. Not only that, but he thoughtfully wore disposable booties in my house. I was very impressed with Gabriel’s workmanship and would not hesitate to recommend and/or use Carter’s My Plumber again. - Chuck Walton
I have had Joshua out to my small business several times now. Carter 100% stands behind thier work. I never hear any dumb sales pitches. They have performed multiple different tasks, jobs, installs for me. (even some speciality stuff for my particualar business). Price is right, price is fair. Good company to work with.
The bathroom sink started to leak, we called Carters Plumbing and less than two hours later a technician was at our home. The technician explained the problem and our choices for a fix. He completed installation of a new sink and faucet the same day. Carter’s is a great choice.
I had a spigot, leaking into my crawl space, and the shut off valve was broken. Wes came out in fixed, my broken shut off valve and replaced my spigot. Very thankful for the prompt response and a great job.
I had valves/faucets replaced for a new washer hookup.
Alex was extremely helpful and was able to help me resolve my issues with the leak under my Kitchen sink.
I cannot say enough good things about Carter's. I had used them in the past. So when I had a recent emergency (involving several issues), I called them again. The office staff was so friendly. And the technicians were very helpful and responsive. First, I worked with Harry Miller. He was very nice and professional.…
The gentleman was very professional and very kind. He was able to come in and repair the leak and he did his repair very timely. We did paperwork and he was so very kind . Thank you for being prompt and considerate.
good service. from first call to job done in less than 4 hrs. reasonable cost as well.
I had two new faucets and shut off valves installed.
Quick service and very easy to work with. The technician quickly diagnose the issue had parts available immediately and made the entire process painless. We appreciate their professionalism and great service! Kelson was great!
Alex Parkhurst was our technician. He did an amazing job at changing out our toilet and tub drains. He was very thorough and professional. He explained everything he had completed and made sure we were satisfied. We highly recommend Carter and specifically Alex.
So glad I called Carter's my plumber. The leak I had that was coming from under my refrigerator and the water was oozing up in between the planks of my flooring was just about to drive me crazy. It made me so nervous and upset that I ended up getting a fever blister above my upper lip in the center. So glad they…
Always professional, on time, efficient and reasonable on price. Every technician does a great job not only diagnosing and resolving the issue but educating the homeowner. Thanks again!
Technician was great. Not sure how I feel about paying $245 for a water valve install.
Words can not express how happy I am with Carter's My Plumber. They have completed several jobs for me at two houses and also my office. They show up when they say they will, send text and call when on their way, they diagnosis the problem fast and complete the work promptly. They are affordable, knowledgeable,…
Very knowledgeable & efficient gentlemen who obviously knew what they were doing.
The exterior water line repair was handled with skill and attention to detail in a timely manner. However, I was disappointed that I had to pay $2000 to fix a fitting that they had installed only 3 years ago when they repaired a leak in that same water line for $2600 with a 2-year warranty. An underground water line…
Carter's is the only plumber I call. Fast, quality service every time.
I was very impressed with Alex R., he assessed our shower leak quickly and efficiently. He was professional, knowledgeable and very polite. His co-worker came out to assist and she was also very professional and helpful. Thank you both, I appreciate your hard work!!!
Our water softener had a melydown. It sent the beeds from it's innards thru our whole water system. John had to clean them out from every water line. This service was as good as it gets. John was professional, courteous, friendly, knowledgeable and an overall great guy. His professional knowledge was excellent and…
Show up early and finished in a timely manner. Would call again for sure.
Alex from Carter's was quick to check on our plumbing leak (responding within hours of calling) and was able to replace all of our under house piping within a day. They were also quick to respond to a follow up issue and always professional as well as reasonably priced.
I've called Carter's twice to repair leaks, most recent one last week. Both times they were very quick to respond and repair the leaks. Very professional and knowledgeable!
I had a leak from my spigot in my crawl space. Peyton installed a new spigot and sealed up the hole that was around it. Good work, done quickly.
Not cheap, but a professional and complete job that resolved my plumbing problem. The technician was polite and took the time to ensure the job was completed correctly and without issues. Appreciate the attention to details.
Really appreciated the service and friendliness that Brandon provided; he was quick and answered all of our questions.
I call them and they told me that the water is leak 445 Gal in hours. They leave without fix and they told me to call be back later but did not call be back. I have to call another plumber and fix. I pay them $380 and did not fix anythings. didn't recomand this service...
Very helpful
Thought I had a leak, pressure would drop to a small trickle when flushing toilet and using faucets in another room….. Gabriel service tech asked a couple question then verbally explained what exactly was going on. We replaced our water softener system due to the 22 year old system breaking down…. New system price…
I have used several plumbers in the past, but I will now say Carter’s My Plumber without hesitation. Had a leak under the slab. They correctly diagnosed the issue, explained what the repair process would be and executed the plan. Very thorough and extremely professional. Thanks to everyone at Carter’s My Plumber.…
3/25/25 Update. Andrew and Ryan were out today to replace our water heater. They did a great job and were in and out with no mess and no fuss! The rest still applies ! Very responsive! Joe and Keith were great to work with! I can not say enough good things about the service Carter's provided. Thank you for the help! Bill
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater installation | 240 | $1.2k–$2.5k |
| Plumbing pipe repair | 181 | $322–$1.1k |
| Toilet repair | 147 | $176–$656 |
| Drain cleaning | 137 | $161–$493 |
| Plumbing leak detection | 124 | $78–$630 |
| Plumbing leak repair | 98 | $227–$807 |
| Faucet installation | 89 | $292–$593 |
| Faucet repair | 81 | $166–$529 |