Is Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee any good?
Our verdict: a strong choice — #13 of 90 plumbers, better than 86%. Customers single out its reliability and satisfaction; track record is where it trails.
Reliability — better than 99% of peers
Satisfaction — better than 94% of peers
Accountability — better than 71% of peers
Momentum — 39th percentile
Value — 31th percentile
Track record — 8th percentile
Price $$$$: 123% above typical
Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee for toilet installation
Clear ✕11 customers reviewed a toilet installation job here and rated it 5.00★. Most paid $1,000+ (category typical: $514–$1.2k). For this job it ranks #18 of 66 plumbers we track.
Prompt and thorough communication from staff on schedule and expectations, and Tyler was very helpful and detailed with our toilet installation. Will definitely use Optimal again!
Excellent and honest communication and thorough work! It's so nice to find tradesman you like and trust. Absolute go-to.
Tyler did an outstanding job with installation of a new toilet and faucet. Would definitely hire Optimal Plumbing again.
I've had Optimal Plumbing complete a number of jobs in the last 3 months: dishwasher installation; toilet repair; new kitchen sink installation; backwater valve installation after the April '26 flood; complete replacement of the pipes under my basement floor; sump pump installation. Tyler Wenzel, the owner, and his…
I have been looking for a lifelong plumber since I moved to Milwaukee. I found that with Optimal Plumbing! I needed to have a toilet replaced so I called Optimal. They were courteous and scheduled my appointment for two days later. Day of, Tyler (plumber) was super communicative about when he would arrive, and he…
I have 5 businesses, I worked with many plumbing companies in the past 20 years, Optimal Plumbing is the best! Reasonable pricing, best service. Owners Milto and Jeff are very friendly and professional. Update 6/15/2026 : Milto installed 2 water fountains at our commercial property today. He did a great job.
Optimal Plumbing did an excellent job replacing my cold water pipes to my bath and kitchen. The price was lower then I expected for the time spent on my project. I will definitely call them again for any future needs.
The entire crew at Optimal Plumbing has been great to work with. Great communication. Flexibility with our projects. Projects completed on time. The 3 best things a GC can ask for. We have done full home renovations, basement bathrooms, kitchen renovations and so much more with this team. We will continue to us…
As a child care center director in Milwaukee, WI, ensuring our facility is safe and functional is crucial. Tyler did an outstanding job upgrading our bathrooms and kitchen to meet health standards. His professionalism and efficiency made the process smooth, with minimal disruption to our daily activities. Thank you,…
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Questions about Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee
Is Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee good?
Yes by most measures: 5.0★ from 301 Google reviews and an Experts Score of 73/100 (grade B), #13 of 90 plumbers we track. 0% of reviews in the last two years were 1–2★ (category average 2.6%).
How much does Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee charge?
Customers reported a typical bill of $1.1k (middle half $554–$1.9k), 123% above the plumbers median of $480.
What do customers hire Optimal Plumbing — Milwaukee for?
Mostly plumbing pipe repair (32), faucet installation (17), toilet repair (17), plumbing leak detection (16).
Does the owner respond to complaints?
The owner replied to 100% of 1–3★ reviews (category: 82%).