How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%88+48Reliability 24%84+20.4Value 14%94+13.3Replies to reviews 7%25+1.8Craft & service penalty81−1.9Experts Score= 81Grade A: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.81SCORERochester Colonial Manufacturing
Rochester, NY · Grade ALetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #25Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 35 window replacement services · 4.8★ from 383 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other window replacement services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: momentum and value; weakest: replies to reviews.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Rochester Colonial Manufacturing for 8 kinds of job.
Rochester Colonial Manufacturing for general door installation
Clear ✕All 86 Google reviews tagged “General door installation” · showing 80
Very professional and great care taken to make sure the job was done right.
Top quality product, and top quality sales and installation teams
The 2 workmen showed up on time. Got right to work, didn't chit chat, worked up a sweat, no breaks except lunch, cleaned up. An excellent job for this door that was very difficult to install. It opens and closes beautifully. Swings nice, new threshold. We could not be happier. We are a threepeat customer. This is…
Rochester Colonial did fantastic work! We love our new doors and are getting lots of compliments on their look. They were punctual and cleaned up after them selves. We are just sorry we didn't get the new doors and windows sooner. Highly recommend.
I had a new sliding door installed on August 18,2026, and the experience was excellent from start to finish. Jacob's team did the installation and it went smoothly with no issues at all. They were professional and did great work. I'm very happy with the results and highly recommend Rochester Colonial to anyone looking for quality door installation.
Rochester Colonial did an amazing job installing my new door. They were so knowledgeable, friendly and extremely clean.
Everyone I worked with at Rochester Colonial regarding the installation of a new storm door was wonderful to work with. The finished product was perfect. I would work with this company again in a heartbeat. When I met with the gentleman who provided the initial estimate I was pleasantly surprised when he informed…
Their storm door is outstanding. They installed it within the time frame given. The installers were professional. I absolutely love the door. I had them installed all my windows are my previous house and would highly recommend them.
Beginning with the salesman, right down to the guys that did the installation of the storm doors, the total experience was exceptional. Would highly recommend, without hesitation.
Rochester Colonial is the very best in the business! Quality is outstanding. Customer service is equally outstanding. We will never go anywhere else!
Rochester Colonial is simply the very best in the business. Quality is outstanding. Customer service is equally outstanding. We will never go anywhere else.
We had a new fiberglass front door installed and it is beautiful. Wish we had done it years ago!! The install crew was great.
Our whole experience with Rochester Colonial was effortless, from Sales to Installation. Kind, thoughtful, professional and the finished product beautiful!! Thank you all. Looking forward to working with you all again.
Arrived on time. Did a beautiful job. Cleaned up when they left. That’s just what I wanted.
I had 5 doors, 3 storm doors and 6 windows installed. The installation crew, Erich Ennslin, Jacob Wolf, Earl Norway, Bill Berube, Dylan Emerson and Nicholas Kuhn, worked tirelessly for 3 days straight- especially Erich. They were very professional, took pride in their workmanship, cleaned up thoroughly after each…
The installation and quoting process was very easy and smooth. Everyone involved was very helpful in ensuring a smooth process. They did a great job!
They arrived on time and were here about an hour. They vacuumed up and left everything in perfect order. The storm door looks great.
Rochester Colonial installation crew did a great job putting in 2 Windows and 2 doors in our garage. The finishing details of wrapping the window trim was well done and they left the job site very clean.
Rochester Colonial made the process of installing a door simple from start to finish. The showroom has many styles to look at and the salesperson was very helpful in helping us make a decision. Communication was great and the guys who installed the door were super!!
Good product, excellent installation. Friendly and efficient workers who cleaned after themselves wonderfully.
Rochester Colonial personal have been great and professional from sales to every installation they’ve done over the years. Their service is amazing also. :)
Installers were very professional. The door looks fantastic! I will definitely use Rochester Colonial again in the future.
Jake and Earl did an amazing job installing my front and screen doors; I highly recommend them. Bernie and Laurie Holmes
Great experience. Total pros. The crew who did the install were top notch. Love my new doors
Rochester Colonial installed a door and replace a window for us. They were ahead of schedule. The team arrived on time, was very efficient, fast, professional and clean. We are extremely happy with the result. We will not look anywhere else for future window replacements and we can recommend Rochester Colonial without hesitation.
Installation crew did a very thorough and detailed job.
We have worked with Rochester Colonial for many years. We have always been extremely happy with, Sales, Service and Installation.
The team did a fantastic job installing two new external doors and matching keyed hardware. The team was onsite exactly on time and work was completed incredibly timely. They were nice and respectful and the work is well done!
Excellent service and follow through during the entire process.
From the salesman to the installers the experience was flawless! The door looks great.
sliding door looks great, on time and cleaned up well. One minor issue fixed promptly
My house was built in the late 1800s not much is level. The workers from Rochester colonial did a fantastic job replacing the door. The door closes with a one finger push. Extremely happy with Rochester colonial.
They were all very easy to work with, professional, honest, thorough in every detail. The installers kept the area completely covered and clean.
Great experience, from sales to install. The installers did an outstanding job, efficient and clean. Very happy with the quality of the door.
Had our storm door replaced. High quality door and outstanding installation.
Great company! Needed new doors and windows for my daughter's condo. Reached out to 3 vendors and chose Roch. Colonial. Used them 12 yrs ago for complete window and door replacement at my home and was very satisfied then. Excellent experience once again. Professional service in all respects. Patient, diligent, and…
Their team did a great job installing our new exterior doors and screens.
Rochester Colonial is an outstanding company. They have skilled installers and excellent products. When we ordered windows for our house last year we investigated several different window manufacturers and installers. We picked Rochester Colonial and are very happy that we did. The windows replaced older worn-out…
I have just had a new custom storm door installed by Rochester Colonial. From my initial visit to pick out a door to the appointment for installation I was kept up to date on the progress. The installation went smoothly, and my door is beautiful. I must say my old storm door was also from Rochester Colonial and was…
Excellent Service Mike was very knowledgeable and very professional. The door was installed perfectly. The installers were very neat and did a great job. Matched the molding perfectly as well. Highly Recommend them.
Great quality storm door installed professionally. Very happy with the product and the service
Door installation was top-notch. Very skilled and professional. Thank you.
Excellent service, punctual and very courteous installers! After having our new steel door installed, we had a slight issue with our reinstalled existing screen door closing. It was resolved quickly with no additional service fee, they want you to be 100% satisfied with the product and service, which we are. Highly recommend Rochester Colonial!
I so love my new windows & doors! They did a great job with the installation.
From the salesman to the installers, working with Rochester Colonial was a pleasure. Very patient in answering all of our questions. Friendly and having a good sense of humor and skilled craftsmen who installed our door. The choices of doors out did the other businesses by far. We are very satisfied with Rochester Colonial.
We are pleased with our new doors. The installers did a great job.
Over the years Rochester Colonial has helped many of my family members. The Rochester Colonial team are kind, diligent professionals every step of the way - from estimate to final measurements to installation scheduling to installation prep to installation to post-installation cleanup. Rochester Colonial is…
Awesome experience. The guys were great and the door looks awesome.
As usual professional, knowledgeable and polite staff from the quote through installation. Thanks
Replaced 3 exterior doors and our sliding glass door in one day. The installers did a great job and cleaned up after themselves. One door was in a difficult area, but they knew what they were doing and got it installed. High quality doors installed by professionals at a fair price.
We ordered a storm door from Rochester Colonial. The ordering process was simple and the installation was great! The 2 men that installed the door were very professional, very clean and knowledgeable about the product. Would not hesitate to order from Rochester Colonial again and would recommend them to friends and family.
We recently had all new windows and one door installed through Rochester Colonial and could not be happier. Replacing windows is a big decision and took us time to make our final selection. Ripley, our sales manager never pressured us at all. We had multiple quotes from a variety of companies, but the…
From our initial consultation to the final installation, the customer service was outstanding. During the first meeting, they highlighted details that might otherwise be overlooked and that ultimately made a noticeable difference in the finished product. The installation was handled with care and professionalism.…
High quality products and trained professionals to install!
Staff both in the store and the installation crew, were friendly and professional. We are happy with our new door and the those we worked with.
Our Provia storm door was just installed. We are very pleased with our new door Your installers were very professional and courteous. We definitely recommend Rochester Colonial. We have used your products and services in the past and have always received top notch sales and service.
Rochester Colonial provided us with beautiful, high quality doors. The installers were awesome! Professional, knowledgeable, respectful. The work is meticulous. Thank you!
Very professional staff. Installation of door, custom windows fantastic. Timely, clean and efficient. RCM have replaced all windows and doors in my 1954 Ranch home. Highly recommended.
I’m very happy with the job the two men did with my new door.💖 The light that it gives is wonderful.
If you're looking for a high quality front door that is handled from start to finish in a very professional way, without the pressure of upselling, I would highly recommend Rochester Colonial. From the design to the installation phase they were proactive and stuck to the schedule and the price agreed upon. I am…
The 2 gentleman that installed our door were very professional and helpful. I’ve not had this type of customer service in a very long time. These two guys deserve recognition at company level due to their expertise, problem solving techniques and kind nature. Thank you
Top notch experience across the board. From start to finish, my project was handled with attentiveness and professionalism. Highly recommend!
Just wanted to pass along our appreciation for the great job on the windows and door we had installed. Installers were polite, cleaned up and made sure that it was to our satisfaction. Salesman (Nick) was great wasn’t pushy and if I needed anything else this is the place I’m going to come back to.
I have had Rochester Colonial replace a kitchen window, patio door, repair a window and replace my front door and screen. They did a wonderful job. They always on time and did a professional job. Plus, they cleaned up after the work and I didn't have to do anything after they left; just enjoy the work they did.…
Rochester Colonial was fantastic! It started when we dropped in the Lyell Ave showroom to look for a new exterior basement door. The selection was excellent and our salesperson knowledgeable. The price was comparable but we feel the quality was superior. We were so impressed we ended up buying 3 doors (two exterior…
Our experience with Rochester Colonial was top notch from how we were greeted as we walked into the showroom to the completion of the installation of our beautiful front door. Kudos to everyone involved in making our experience one of the best. Their professionalism is 100% top class. We both highly recommend…
The people at Rochester Colonial know their products well and are expert at helping customers make right choices. Installation is top notch and the service techs don't leave until everything is just right. I feel totally confident making a purchase to upgrade my home.
Rochester Colonial installed a 9' sliding glass door on our home in July 2021. Matt, the salesperson, was very helpful and friendly. The installers were very professional and did a great job. I felt bad for them because it was pouring rain, but they never complained! The door gets very frequent use because that's…
We had Rochester Colonial install 2 Marvin sliding glass doors and 2 custom Marvin windows. The quality of the Marvin products is excellent. The installers did a great job and took more time than originally planned as they made changes to the install and decorative appointments to make sure things met our needs.…
Rochestet Colonial and Installer, Matt Foley have exceeded my expectations. They are the best.
Love working with Rochester Colonial. We always turn to them when we need upgrades or replacements. Mike Gionta is so helpful with options and designs. Highly recommended.
Bob the installer just left. he did a great job and i am very happy with the new door! very pleased
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Rating only, no written review.
Price
Not enough reviews with a price yet.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| General door installation | 86 | — |
| Window installation | 73 | — |
| Custom doors | 26 | — |
| Custom windows | 23 | — |
| General door repair | 7 | — |
| Window repair | 6 | — |
| General window replacement | 4 | — |
| Double pane window installation & replacement | 3 | — |
