Analyzing 7,234,1467.2M ReviewsFor 20,51020.5K Experts
Google reviewers rate C. Carlin Plumbing Inc. 4.8 out of 5 based on 655 reviews, noting that the owner responds to 91% of feedback. Customers frequently praise the team for punctuality, clear communication, and thorough work on furnace maintenance, boiler repairs, and plumbing issues. Common criticisms involve high initial estimates, perceived lack of diagnostic depth, and difficulties obtaining itemized invoices or follow-up calls from office staff.
Data from Google, last updated November 1, 2026.
Score per factor (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: momentum and craft & service; weakest: replies to reviews.
Bar = this company · dark tick = category median.
655 Google reviews we collected
Phrases our text analysis found in 548 written reviews
Price verdicts customers left with their Google review
Middle half of what 163 customers paid ($114–$1.4k) · gold mark = category median.
How often each topic comes up in the written reviews
We read 548 written reviews and marked every phrase about these topics. The same colors are highlighted in the reviews.
“David was friendly, and explained the maintenance in easy to understand fashion.”
“RUDE, DISRESPECTFUL AND REFUSE TO LET YOU TALK TO ANYONE.”
“He was very efficient and knowledgeable, answering all of our questions.”
“Unfortunately he never got back to me with the estimate.”
“Outstanding service - stopped in on my lunch break and the team showed up 15 minutes later.”
“Not just come to my house look at the outside, and say I need a new one based on my word " it's not working well.”
“I highly recommend this business, and if my mother needs a plumber in the future, we will definitely be using them.”
“Save your money and don't be insulted stay away from Crooked Carlins!”
“Adam explained what was wrong and what he needed to do to fix the situation.”
“Called the office and left a message for the estimate and/or a call back and was totally ghosted!”
“Carlin plumbing are friendly, efficient, knowledgeable, responsive, and reasonably priced.”
“They didn’t even do a diagnosis and she told me a repair would cost $10,000.”
“An unfortunate event did happen, but the company was honest about it, and delt with it professionally, and quickly.”
“Carol in the office is committing fraud by taking advantage of a contract they have with Wesleyville.”
praise complaint · found by our text analysis, Google review wording unchanged.
Customers hired C. Carlin Plumbing Inc. for 8 kinds of job. Pick one to see what they paid and said.
Great job with checking our furnaces. In time and very knowledgeable. Would highly recommend. Thanks!
Unfortunately, Jay Sr. could have taken the time to look inside my furnace and inspect any possible problems. Not just come to my house look at the outside, and say I need a new one based on my word " it's not working well." Than just say I need a new furnace ranging at $6800.00 or more. DO NOT USE THEM. THE…
Very satisfied with the work Chris performed. Very knowledgeable when asked questions. Please note for Chris to be assigned to service my account in the future.
Service was top notch. David was friendly, and explained the maintenance in easy to understand fashion. He was very efficient and knowledgeable, answering all of our questions. He also changed the filter for us. We are very pleased with his work and the C Carlin Company, and will use them when needed.
Outstanding service - stopped in on my lunch break and the team showed up 15 minutes later. Very professional and polite group of fellas. Thank you for a great experience and will use again for future needs.
Adam was the plumber that came today. He's personable, professional and knowledgeable. Adam explained what was wrong and what he needed to do to fix the situation. I was very happy with the outcome.
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater installation | 47 | $1.3k–$2.1k |
| Plumbing pipe repair | 43 | $227–$880 |
| Toilet repair | 38 | $209–$383 |
| Drain cleaning | 37 | $148–$353 |
| Faucet repair | 27 | $145–$322 |
| Plumbing leak detection | 25 | $114–$308 |
| Faucet installation | 23 | $276–$611 |
| Heating system maintenance | 20 | $26–$148 |
4.8 ★★★★★ 655 reviews on Google · rating breakdown
Reviews from Google, shown as published (original wording, unedited).
Great job with checking our furnaces. In time and very knowledgeable. Would highly recommend. Thanks!
Unfortunately, Jay Sr. could have taken the time to look inside my furnace and inspect any possible problems. Not just come to my house look at the outside, and say I need a new one based on my word " it's not working well." Than just say I need a new furnace ranging at $6800.00 or more. DO NOT USE THEM. THE OFFICE STAFF IS RUDE AND DO NOT BILL PROPERLY. I asked for an itemized bill. In which, they refused to do. Also, they do not accept cash for payment. They left my basement, carpeting and lawn a mess from parking their trucks on my grass. When I go to call about my concerns they hang up on me all of the time. The technicians are good, but the office staff and management are terrible. And that's being mild! Save your money and don't be insulted stay away from Crooked Carlins!
Very satisfied with the work Chris performed. Very knowledgeable when asked questions. Please note for Chris to be assigned to service my account in the future.
I will certainly pass your request along to Chris. Glad he helped you out!
Mike did a great job and wasn't a salesman
Glad Mike kept things honest and straightforward for you, Leland!
Service was top notch. David was friendly, and explained the maintenance in easy to understand fashion. He was very efficient and knowledgeable, answering all of our questions. He also changed the filter for us. We are very pleased with his work and the C Carlin Company, and will use them when needed.
David will be thrilled to hear your filter change and maintenance explanation went so well, Carol!
Great experience start to end. Professional, hard working team that got my baseboards installed and boiler up and running again before winter. They also swapped a faucet out for me that was leaking. I'll be using them for all plumbing & heating needs.
Glad we could get your baseboards, boiler, and leaky faucet sorted out before winter, Mandi!
Mike was quick and easy to get along with.
Jay was very helpful and explained my problem.
Jay is fantastic at clarifying complex plumbing issues for our customers!
Chuck the plumber for you guys did a Great job...give him a RAISE!!
David is very efficient and professional He arrived and immediately went to work He reviewed the completed work and arranged a quote for service needed on a booster fan.
David will be glad to hear this, Eric! We are happy to help with your booster fan.
Analyzing 7,234,1467.2M ReviewsFor 20,51020.5K Experts
