How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%63+34.4Reliability 24%47+11.4Value 14%100+14.1Replies to reviews 7%100+7.1Craft & service penalty47−5.3Momentum penalty26−7.4Experts Score= 54Grade C: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.54SCOREWorthmann Roofing and Gutters
Newberry, FL · Grade CLetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #25Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 26 ice removal services · 4.7★ from 712 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other ice removal services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: value and replies to reviews; weakest: momentum.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Worthmann Roofing and Gutters for 8 kinds of job.
Worthmann Roofing and Gutters for roof damage repair
Clear ✕All 48 Google reviews tagged “Roof damage repair” · showing 40
The supposed foreman Axel was rude so unprofessional wouldn't listen to anything the home owner had to say they butchered the existing wood and refused to replace or even attempt to fix the actual problem the last photo is what they did the first time and the first photo is what they did now they replaced the wood…
We bought a house in June 2025, Worthmann replaced the roof in February 2023. We are having a leak issue and Worthmann says that the contract only covered 2 years. Buyer beware. We will NOT EVER use them! I’d give a zero star if possible. A new roof should not leak this soon. They didn’t even consider coming out to look at it without a charge.
Had a great experience with Noah, he came out to help build a quote to install gutters on my home. He was patient, professional, and took the time speaking to my wife and I about everything that would be needed. We would definitely recommend working with this company if you needed any work done on your roof!
Company lacks skill and integrity. Updating this review because things are even worse than we could have imagined. New roof leaked! AND, Worthmann gutters have failed in less than two years despite being cleaned monthly. Gutters caused a MASSIVE mold issue in our crawlspace. Instead of diverting water from the…
I can't say enough about this company and Chad Cardoso. From the very beginning they were great. Chad came out the very next day and gave us an estimate. He took the time to explain everything in detail. This company was very reasonable with their pricing and extremely understanding about our situation. I would…
Contracted for a residential metal roof, everything went well until the invoice came. Scott the salesman stated he added facia boards to his estimate so I would be charged a lower price. The invoice had facia board added at an additional expense for the same amount already added. Scott added 2x8 for the facia at…
Worthmann Roofing and Gutters is definitely the place to go for all your roofing needs! Whether you need a brand-new roof or just routine repairs, they deliver fantastic service. Highly recommend!!!!
Fantastic customer service!! Chad walked me through the entire process. And was in contact with me until roof was finished. It was fast, good quality and excellent price. I definitely recommend them!! A metal roof for under 20,000 and zero percent financing for a year. 8-10 thousand less than the other bids in Tallahassee FL.
Worthmann roofing installed a roof on my house for a fair, competitive price. There was an alignment issue with the dryer vent. Paul the project manager was exceptional with his response time and communication in getting it repaired. He sent out David, a repair specialist, and this guy was great. He got soaked in a…
Mr David Glass provided a extra effort to help repair the leak in my roof which has been ongoing for over a year he took his time to locate and repair the leak I would like to thank him for going over and beyond his service to provide a ending to my frustration Thank You Mr David Glass
I had the pleasure working with Hunter Gilland, he was kind and informative assessing my roof damages
they were great. they fixed everything that needed fixed. igivethem an a+
Talking with Chad was such a nice experience he is so knowledgeable about his work. With all our questions and some of them silly am sure Chad made us feel at ease about what needed to be done regards to the roof and what we can expect at the beginning, middle and end. We have a lot of projects that we will be…
We recently had our roof replaced by Worthmann Roofing and Gutters, and the experience was excellent from start to finish. The quality of the work was outstanding, the crew was professional, and everything was completed efficiently and on schedule. Hunter Gilland, the site supervisor, was fantastic—communicative,…
Excellent services! Mr. Hunter Gilland was excellent in his by going beyond what was ask for. We delighted and will recommend friends and neighbors.
Very professional, very clean, very efficient
I had a preliminary appointment with Blayne Willis today from Worthmann Roofing & Gutters. Blayne showed up on time and got right into assessing the condition of my roof and his recommendations for my next steps. Everything was direct and to the point and what you're hoping for when you're interacting with an…
Hi we had our roof replaced and they did a wonderful job. Love the color and fixes that were needed. We had 2 layers of shingles and 1 metal roof on top and they removed them for us. Hunter Gillard helped us make sure everything was cohesive color wise and that the job was done right.
I was 1200 miles away from the home while they roofed the entire house. Hunter kept me informed the whole time . They were in and out in less than 2 days.it looks Great. Thank you Great job...
My experience with Worthmann roofing and gutters was awesome. The customer service, the professionalism, and the energy was great. They gave me an excellent roof. Our site supervisor, Hunter Gilland was awesome. He was with us the entire time of the process and answered any questions we had. We also there to ensure…
Great experience with Worthmann. Worked with Blayne and the process was very easy and straightforward. Fair pricing and good communication.
We had a leak show up in our bathroom so we called Worthmann Roofing to come inspect. Blayne came out and looked over the whole roof, found the leak and fixed it for free. When offered money for his services, he refused to accept. Blayne is extremely professional and kind, I would recommend this company to anyone.
This was my first experience with a roofing company. Luke Gleason made the entire process smooth and easy to manage. He was extremely helpful, friendly, and great to work with. His team were also great to work with and answered any questions that we had. This was a very positive experience during a stressful time…
We are excited and happy to be talking with Chad this morning , looking to get a new roof!! Chad was courteous, professional and great conversation . He communicated and explained the process from beginning to end . We felt good having him and his company handle our roofing experience . We are happy to…
You want a stress free reroof job call worthmann ask for Jeremy and you can sit back and relax he will get the ball rolling and if you are as lucky as I was you will get Charlie and crew they were awesome I could not be happier
We had such a very good experience with this company I definitely recommend them! Ginger reassured us every step of the way!! All in all is was a wonderful experience!
We had a new metal roof installed on our 2000 sq ft house and they did an outstanding job. From the estimate by Scot to the install by John and his amazing crew it was a first rate job all the way. We are set for life.
Can't say enough about this company, Scott and John mccuiston and the team were all great, clean up well too, great to have a metal roof now, thank you guys
Worthmann Roofing completo mi techo. Ashly se communico con migo desde el primer dia y explico el processo paso por paso. Mi techo se ve hermoso y la attencion de cliente ha sido superior. Gracias por todo su servicio .
Jessica was very good at helping me with what i needed and was kind
Jessica was so nice to me and my family on the phone
I have a few rental properties and my father referred me over to Worthman for some roofing needs. Tiffany Bukszar helped me get the service and repairs that I needed within a few days. Tiffany was professional and knowledgeable about my needs!
Me and my wife had some leaks in our garage We called worthmann roofing. The next day they sent a team member named Theodore out. He was very informative Super fast and friendly. Overall 100 for customer service. Highly recommend this company
I had an issue with my invoice and Tiffany did a great job helping me fix it. She identified the error and helped me correct it. Thank you!
Worthmann roofing was a huge help in repairing my roof. I was especially surprised by how well Joseph handled the situations and helped me throughout the job. My roof has never seen better days before Worthmann. I highly recommend working with Joseph from Worthmann roofing.
I had an excellent experience working with Joseph from Worthmann roofing. He was very communicative and always kept me informed about the progress of the project. He made sure that everything was done to my satisfaction and I couldn't be happier with the final result. I highly recommend Worthmann roofing and Joseph for anyone in need of roofing services.
Got my roof done by Worthmann Roofing. Super great company to work with. My project Manager Joseph was very informative!
I had an horrorabile experience with Worthmann roofing. The shingles on my roofing where place any type of way. Also the trim from the boarded of the house was scripts and when I tried to show pictures and ask for repairs with they were very rude and nasty towards me . I had to reach out to four different people…
Jeremy was very easy to work with. He got our estimate back quickly. Dannielle and her work crew were a delight. Our roof is very steep but they got it scrapped and back on quickly on days we were under a heat advisory. When the were finished they did a fantastic clean up, Nothing left. Would recommend them!!
This company is great to work with. Detailed reports from my salesman Frits, to the workers coming ON TIME and completed the project. Join the foreman, was very attentive and made sure everything was so cleared and cleaned up once the job was complete. Cost a bit more than estimate but I understand it was an…
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Roof installation | 154 | $11k–$21k |
| Roof inspection | 50 | — |
| Roof damage repair | 48 | $8.6k–$17k |
| Gutter installation | 48 | $2.1k–$5.1k |
| Roof repair | 41 | $539–$9.4k |
| Roof repair for storm & wind damage | 17 | $2.4k–$13k |
| Gutter repairs | 14 | — |
| Skylight installation | 7 | — |
