How the Experts Score is calculatedEach factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (standing in the category can only raise it), then weighted; problems flagged in review highlights or a recent slide in ratings are subtracted:Satisfaction 55%63+34.4Reliability 24%47+11.4Value 14%100+14.1Replies to reviews 7%100+7.1Craft & service penalty47−5.3Momentum penalty26−7.4Experts Score= 54Grade C: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39. Needs 10+ reviews.54SCOREWorthmann Roofing and Gutters
Newberry, FL · Grade CLetter from the Experts Score: A = 80+, B = 60–79, C = 40–59, D = 20–39, F = under 20. · #25Position by Experts Score among all companies we track in this category. of 26 ice removal services · 4.7★ from 712 Google reviews
Report card
Percentile vs other ice removal services (100 = best)Each factor is scored 0–100 on absolute terms (star average, share of 1–2★ reviews, price verdicts…); standing within the category can only raise it, never lower it.. Strongest: value and replies to reviews; weakest: momentum.
Reviews for your job
Customers hired Worthmann Roofing and Gutters for 8 kinds of job.
Worthmann Roofing and Gutters for roof installation
Clear ✕All 154 Google reviews tagged “Roof installation” · showing 80
Company lacks skill and integrity. Updating this review because things are even worse than we could have imagined. New roof leaked! AND, Worthmann gutters have failed in less than two years despite being cleaned monthly. Gutters caused a MASSIVE mold issue in our crawlspace. Instead of diverting water from the…
I had a great experience using Worthmann Roofing. Blayne, the Sales Rep was very personable, easy to work with and not pushy at all. He kept us informed every step of the way. The Crew was great and replaced our 2700 sq ft roof in 13 hours. Their Supervisor, Tyler checked in with us several times during the day. I…
Like most of us I am not a roofer I am a teacher. Due to this fact I do my research as much a possible but at the end of the day I have to rely on the experience of the professionals. Unfortunately this company has 100% lost my trust. When my roof was finished I noticed that a few shingles were raised in a way that…
I had a new roof installed. The work was outstanding and the roof looks great. The crew showed up on time, were polite and professional and did a very good job. I recommend Worthmann Construction very highly.
The installation was done professionally and all my questions were answered fully. DJHardy was my contact and he was extraordinarily helpful in solving minor challenges and ensuring an excellent outcome. Ivy was my site supervisor and also did excellent work. A large branch recently fell on the shingled portion…
You want a stress free reroof job call worthmann ask for Jeremy and you can sit back and relax he will get the ball rolling and if you are as lucky as I was you will get Charlie and crew they were awesome I could not be happier
We were not in need of a roof, but due to these insurance companies we were forced to replace our roof. Remy came out to give us an estimate from Worthmann and was up front and honest about what the process would be as well as time frame expectations. Jose and his team came out to put our new roof on exactly on…
We had a new metal roof installed on our 2000 sq ft house and they did an outstanding job. From the estimate by Scot to the install by John and his amazing crew it was a first rate job all the way. We are set for life.
Worthmann Roofing is an amazing roofing company! The salesman Josh is very honest. Not you typical salesman that wants to sell you everything, even if you don't need it. The project manager Tyler is just as good. He was onsite the whole time. Only left to get supplies and water for the roofers. Josh also came onsite…
Can't say enough about this company, Scott and John mccuiston and the team were all great, clean up well too, great to have a metal roof now, thank you guys
I used Worthmann Roofing to replace my roof and highly recommend this company. My salesman, Eric, was professional, knowledgeable, and courteous. The quote was fair and Eric built the quote the same day as the inspection. The final product exceeded expectations!
My experience working with Joseph from Worthmann roofing was amazing. He was very helpful and always kept me up to speed about the progress of the project. He made sure that everything was done with confidence and assurance. I couldn't be more excited about my new roof. I highly recommend Worthmann roofing and Joseph for anyone in need of roofing services.
Worthmann Roofing is the best!!! Especially DJ Hardy and Ivy very professional, honest, caring people. from replacing the roof from start to finish. it’s great to know that there’s still a wonderful contractor in the area. The whole crew knew what they were doing and did it very well thank you all for being you and for what you do.
I had shopped for an honest/reputable roofing company starting a year ago. I landed on Worthmann Roofing back then. I was impressed by the quality and patience of the man I spoke with that day. One year later, when ready to contract for my roof replacement, I called Worthmann. They sent their sales rep. Jeremy…
This company is great to work with. Detailed reports from my salesman Frits, to the workers coming ON TIME and completed the project. Join the foreman, was very attentive and made sure everything was so cleared and cleaned up once the job was complete. Cost a bit more than estimate but I understand it was an…
If I could give zero stars I would . This company made promises they couldn't keep from the start. Th,ey never sent a project manager to our home except for once and when he got there the crew wasn't there. They never did show that day. I had to withhold the last payment for weeks to get them to repair damage…
The roof on our home was replaced at the end of 2022 and last Saturday we noted water coming from a can light. Worthmann sent Donald Calvert out to assess the problem. He was very thorough and took time to ensure the problem was correctly identified and then was diligent about making appropriate repairs. He was very…
Very professional. Friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating. Workmanship was great.
too many nails left at site after job in driveway and around grounds
Josh Snyder was a pleasure to deal with and he was straight-forward and clear in his estimate. Their team came out quickly and had my three story house done in a little over two days. My roof is steep and high - but this did not deter them. They had a person on-site the whole time willing to answer questions as…
Very hard working and professional team. Phillip Martinez called and gave us regular updates. Roofers worked fast and did a great job. They cleaned up and were very tidy too. Thank you, we love our new roof!
Great job, appreciate the extra attention to detail
Worthmann had great, friendly people who worked extra hard and got the job done well and in great time!
Large double crew worked one long day, but outcome is beautiful, neighbors comment on it too. I am very satisfied, and Scott, and on-site crew very efficient, professional, hard working. Even a month afterward, and two very heavy rain storms, almost NO debris, nails, etc. clean up work was excellent. I highly recommend them, and would use them again.
DJ was easy to work with and got the ball rolling quickly. My roof was replaced within the time frame that was promised and looks fantastic!
Worthmann roofing did a great job removing old damaged shingles, replacing damage wood and installing a new metal roof on my house. The whole crew assigned to my home was awesome and profesional and my house look totally different with my new metal roof , Thanks Worthmann crew. I recommended this company to many friends and co workers.
The roof looks great. The only suggestion I might offer is training on how to replace roof on properties that have a screened in Pool. Lots of fine dust got into the pool and then into the filter. Also the downspouts were not cleared of roof nails and debri. Thank you.
The initial experience was great and Worthmann was very professional. Our roof was installed about 9 months ago and I do not have complaints about the roof itself. After going into my attic recently I noticed lint was accumulating and after further inspection found that the vent was no longer connected to the roof.…
New metal roof installed. Very pleased with the quality of workmanship. The on-site roofing team led by Mr. M. Roblero were punctual and courteous. Having personally installed, metal, asphalt and roll roofing it was uplifting to see a crew work so well together. Their attention to detail especially on a metal…
We were in the process of selling our mother's house and was told a new roof was needed. Worthmann Roofing and Gutters was recommended. My sister and I are in a different state and we were kept abreast of what was going on from when materials were ordered, when workers were on-site and when the job was completed.…
After hurricane Ian, Scott helped us getting our beautiful metal roof during this stressful time.Great company!
Outstanding experience! Finally, a contractor that communicates with you and actually follows through on everything they say they're going to do. Great staff, great company. Will do business again with them in a heartbeat!
I used Worthmann for my roof replacement. They performed the work timely and professionally. I would use them again and recommend them to anyone.
Excellent service. Worth every penny.
They did a wonderful job. Very pleased with the whole process.
I can't say enough about how pleased I was with my roof replacement. They worked me into their busy schedule at the end of the good weather. The plants in the yard did not suffer from their work, and they did a good job cleaning up afterward. This business is very accountable. The price was agreeable with current work and materials price range.
Awesome. Will refer friends and family
DJ Hardy was our Sales Associate he delivered as promised. He delivered the estimate within the timeline and answered all of our questions. His team was efficient and timely. I would recommend them. Isael the foreman on the job kept us info and update. He was very pleasant and timely. Thank you DJ and the team for making the process so easy.
On time and as promised. Quality work and great customer service. I would definitely recommend them.
The job foreman kept me updated on the entire process. The workers arrived on schedule and did an excellent job. There was no debris left around the house. I highly recommend Worthmann Roofing and I'm completely satisfied for a job well done. I have a beautiful roof!!
Work was done on time like promised. Workers were very professional and cleaned up behind themselves daily. I highly recommend Worthmann Roofing.
Worthmann replaced my roof and my parents' roof, and they did a great job. They were highly professional and communicative throughout the process. I recommend them to my clients and will work with them again.
Very fast and professional job done.
Worthmann roofing and gutters gets five stars from me! A very professional company with highly skilled employees. The superintendent over my roofing job was Joey Blanco. He was very courteous and kept me well informed throughout the process. My new roof and gutters look terrific! Would definitely recommend this company.
The work is yet to be done . However they have displayed professionalism and have always been available for questions. Very helpful. I am satisfied with my decision to work with them.
I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS COMPANY!!!!! NO PROFESSIONALISM, NO RESPECT, NO COMMUNICATION, THEY DID WHATEVER THEY WANT. STILL WAITING ON SCREENS FOR MY WINDOWS THAT WERE INSTALLED 6 MONTHS AGO. I HAD THE WORST ROOF AND WINDOW INSTALLATION EXPERIENCE EVER.
Worthmann responded to my initial inquiry promptly and professionally. Pricing, materials, and scheduling were transparent and well-communicated. During the roof and skylight installation process everything went smoothly and cleanup was thorough. Site supervisor Israel was excellent at keeping things moving and…
Worthmann installed a new roof and new gutters, gutter caps and downspouts. Remy and John were excellent to work with.
Worthmann is such a great company to deal with,They are on time, very professional and made the whole experience easy and stress free.From sales to install this is a top quality company..And I will be using for all my needs that they provide...
Had new shingle roof installed. Started on time. Finished on time and left surrounding area as found. No material left in yard. Site supervisor John McCuiston very professional and very knowledgeable. All my questions we answered and job went smoothly. I would highly recommend Worthmann roofing to anyone…
Worthmann roofing did an excellent job installing a new roof at my mom’s house. Everything was done on time and looks amazing. DJ was fantastic with talking me through the different steps and everything was done within the quoted price range. I highly recommend using Worthmann roofing.
I had a great experience with Worthmann Roofing from start to finish. From the salesman Jeremy Wilkinson explaining every part of the project to the sight supervisor John making sure everything ran smooth. I would highly recommend to anyone needed a honest roofing company.
If you are in need of a new roof I highly recommend you choose Worthmann Roofing. As a first time home owner, there are many scary hurdles to cross and a new roof was one of them. The staff at Worthmann has made me feel so taken care of! Communication has been excellent and I feel totally comfortable asking…
Donnie was great and kept me informed. We had a few issues. But he made sure everything was taken care of.
Contacted worthmann roofing LLC , was contacted by Scott Register their sales associate who promptly made arrangements to come to my home and evaluated my roof. It was determined that I needed a new roof which I had suspected prior to calling Worthmann Roofing. I was contacted by their production manager Phillip…
From the very start my experience with them has been fantastic. First I met with Scott Register for the estimate to replace our roof, he was a half hour early very professional and always available to answer any questions I had about the job and the process, I had contacted two other roofing contractors for…
Company completed New Roof for us. The final product was great; However, the processes was terrible. Lack of communication, no one was on the same page, took two days just to tear off the roof, and they left a mess around the home till the end. If you are okay with your roof taking four - five days to complete then…
The Superintendent (Kevin Funk) and Supervisor (Chris Koch) were extremely responsive to any inquiries or questions that I had. The roofing crew was extremely hard working and on-time every day. They had challenges dealing with rain, and met those challenges. They did a fantastic job cleaning up my property after…
Superior work, they dont cut corners if damage is discovered they will take care of it. Top notch quality installation Williston FL 32696
We shopped around and found very few companies that offered the quality and professionalism of Worthmann Roofing. Their price was not the lowest, but it was the very BEST value. We were not interested in chasing after contractors that either don't show up or delay starting after taking your money. We didn't want to…
Worthmann Roofing was a pleasure to work with. They did a great job replacing my 26 year old roof! I'm sure the roof installation was high quality as they used well-known name-brand roofing materials. However, the best part of the process was the customer service, especially that of Remy who was my sales…
From the initial point of contact with DJ Hardy, to the roof inspection and estimate, choosing materials, signing contracts, job initiation, work in progress, and finally job completion...everything was wonderful. The communication was perfect! The on site Superintendent, Cody, effectively kept the job moving while…
Everyone from sales, administration, supervisors and crew did what the offered. They did it in a timely manner. Overall, I am satisfied with the project and would recommend this contractor to others!
Worthmann LLC was very responsive to our request. Carlos Colbert was quick to provide us with a quote and helped us get the information that we needed for HOA approval. The crew was hard working and professional, and we are very pleased with our new roof. Kevin was a good contact while the job was progressing and…
Great to work with. Ricky Schaff supervised the project with frequent check-ins. Highly recommend!
From start to finish, a great company to work with. Thank you so much to Remy, my sales rep, and Cody, my project manager, for making the whole process uncomplicated. Price was more than fair and the roof and new gutters look fantastic!! Highly recommend for any roofing/ gutter needs.
Couldnt be happier with this company. Josh was my initial contact. Probably one of the nicest people I ever met. The crew that did the work were UNBELEIVABLE. Fast, clean and very friendly. And Kevin Funk was awesome Coordinating the whole thing. Thank you worthman roofing.
Had my roof replaced by Worthmann Roofing. Kevin Funk and his crew did an excellent job. I highly recommend this company and especially this crew! Thank you for the awesome job!
Worthman roofing was trustworthy and attentive. They did a great job tearing off and cleaning up there mess. Our new roof looks amazing! The superintendent Axle Marino was exceptional very thorough and professional. 10/10 would recommend and use again
You're superintendent Axel helped with everything i needed! He was punctual and answered all of our questions in a way we understood and he lead his team very well. He was informative and Attentive. High praise for the work done on my roof and for the great employee!
Had to get a new roof on my house. Worthmann was my choice because of the responsiveness of my point of contact (Carlos) and the professional quote I received. The quote package was impressive and laid out the job and my options. My part as a homeowner/consumer. Once we got a permit install was done in a matter of…
My mother had been needing a new roof for a while and I was just too busy to help her with the process. After meeting with the sales rep from Worthmann roofing I felt super comfortable with the company and we decided to go with them. The staff at Worthmann made the entire process go smoothly. Joseph, our site…
Very professional team - to include the salesman, Frits, and the coordinator, Kevin, who did a fantastic job keeping me updated on the entire process and came after installation to inspect to new metal roof. Very smooth install - the team of four did a fantastic job of installing the roof and trim, and of yard…
Eric was great to work with. Very personable and responsive to all my questions. The roof looks great they did a nice touch by painting the chimney for the Heating and AC. Really updated the outside. We did gutters as well. Chazz came back to make sure everything was working right after the first rainfall and…
I must admit that at 1st I was somewhat skeptical but thank goodness Dave and Christy were able to explain the entire process and put my fears to rest. Having conversation with my realtor and Wondering how much a new roof was going to cost, my realtor told me to get an estimate from Dave & Christy at Worthmann…
Throughout our experience, Dave and Christy provided excellent customer service, providing valuable insights about roofing decisions, shingle selections, and follow-up. After completing the roof, we noticed some color variations in the shingles. We contacted Worthmann, who arranged for the Shingle company to examine…
Worthmann Roofing put a whole new roof on for us and repaired our rafters after tree damage following a tropical storm. Their whole team was responsive, friendly, and professional. The new roof looks great and we are pleased with the whole process. They provided a detailed, itemized estimate and actual costs were…
From my first call where Mr. Worthmann answered the phone, everyone I dealt with was professional and prompt. Scott came out, looked at my roof, and handled the scheduling and communication. He was thoughtful and thorough and always able to quickly handle anything that came up. Overall I had a good experience and my…
This company was very professional and the roofers did quality work. The new roof looks amazing!
Derek and the whole crew were amazing to work with start to finish. Don’t know what I would’ve done with out them! Highly recommend this company!
Price
Bar = middle half of what customers paid · gold mark = category median.
Price verdictsGoogle asks reviewers whether the price was great, reasonable or overpriced; these are their answers.
Jobs customers hired them for
| Job | Reviews | Category typical |
|---|---|---|
| Roof installation | 154 | $11k–$21k |
| Roof inspection | 50 | — |
| Roof damage repair | 48 | $8.6k–$17k |
| Gutter installation | 48 | $2.1k–$5.1k |
| Roof repair | 41 | $539–$9.4k |
| Roof repair for storm & wind damage | 17 | $2.4k–$13k |
| Gutter repairs | 14 | — |
| Skylight installation | 7 | — |
